Greek Antiquity
The Daimones, Sorted by Zip Code
Three lines of the Prayer start by sorting the daimones by what they do to us and end by sorting them by where they live. It looks like a cosmology, but it works more like an old way of saying everybody, everywhere.
The Orphic Collection, Volume I: The HymnsThe Prayer to Musaeus moves from two daimones that affect human fortune to groups named by their regions. The order of the regions tests how much of a cosmology the list supplies.
Orientation
At a Glance
- Two kinds of fortuneThe Prayer starts with two figures, one described as most divine and the other as a cause of human ruin. Their descriptions tell readers what they do.
- A change in how beings are namedThe following groups are identified by where they belong. The list moves through several regions of the world.
- The order is unevenThe sequence begins by descending from heaven through air and water. Its later movement resists a consistent hierarchy.
- A list meant to include everyoneThe article reads the named regions as a way to summon all their inhabitants. The apparatus also shows that editorial choices affect the wording of the list.
Orphic Hymns, Prayer 30–33, 39, with the apparatus at 32–33 and the note on 31–33; LXXIII.4–6
Right after Providence is set “over them all” at line 30, the Prayer turns to the daimones, and it starts with two single figures, “the most divine Daimon, and the Daimon who brings men ruin.” Those two are defined entirely by what they do to you, one good for you and one bad, and then the next two lines switch to a completely different way of sorting, “and daimones of heaven, and of the air, and of the waters, / and of earth, and beneath the earth, and those that walk in fire.” It’s as if you started describing your street as the nice neighbor and the one who calls the cops on your parties, and then pulled out the zip codes.
The first pair belongs to an old Greek idea, the daimon as the power that runs a person’s luck, and here it comes split in two, one “most divine” and one who is ruin to mortals. The book later gives the Daimon a hymn of his own, and there the two halves are one figure, “giver of wealth, whenever he comes teeming into a house, / and again chilling the life of much-toiling mortals,” because, as the next line says, “in you the keys of grief and of joy are held.” The Prayer splits into two what the hymn holds in one hand, which tells you the composer was thinking about effects here, about what a daimon can do to a household, before he turned to geography. It also tells you the two ways of sorting aren’t competing theories, since the same poet who sorts by effect at line 31 sorts by address at line 32 without a word of transition, the way you’d describe the same crowd once by temperament and once by neighborhood.
Then come the regions, and the edition’s note calls them “the nearest thing in the proem to a system,” which is fair, because six zones look a lot like a cosmology. A reader who knows the Platonist tradition will think at once of the Epinomis, the dialogue that follows Plato’s Laws, where each element gets its own kind of living being, the stars made mostly of fire, creatures like us made mostly of earth, and the daimones in the clear middle zone of aether and air between them. Later Platonists ran with that scheme, and it’s easy to read the Prayer’s list as a pocket version of it.
But look at the order, because it’s where the system starts to wobble. Anyone ranking the world from top to bottom puts fire and the bright upper air first and earth last, and the Prayer does begin at heaven and work down through air and water to earth and below it, but then it tacks fire on at the very end, after the underworld, like a guest who wandered in late. Those that walk in fire might be the fiery heaven or the burning rivers under the earth, and the line doesn’t say which. The Prayer even names “the parts of the four-pillared Kosmos” at line 39, the four elements as the world’s supports, so the composer knew the standard four and still didn’t line his daimones up with them.
You might suspect the editors built the scheme, since two of them have their hands on these lines. The apparatus shows that Hermann added the little “and” in line 32, and that the fire-walkers at the end of 33 are Wiel’s empyriphoitous, “walking in fire,” where the manuscripts read ēde pyriphoitous, “and fire-roaming.” Neither change touches the map, though, because the fire-walkers are in the manuscripts either way, and both repairs exist to fix the meter, since the manuscripts’ version of line 33 doesn’t scan and Wiel’s does, by clipping the “and” and adding a single letter, so whatever scheme there is belongs to the poet and not to the men who tidied his lines.
What the list most resembles is an old trick of speech, naming the regions to mean everyone in them. Christians say one version every time they read Philippians, where every knee is to bow, “of things in heaven, and things in earth, and things under the earth,” and nobody takes Paul to be teaching cosmology there, because heaven, earth and under the earth is simply the long way of saying all of them. The Prayer’s six zones are the deluxe edition of that formula, with air, water and fire thrown in so that no corner of the world is left without a name.
That fits what the Prayer is trying to do, which is get everybody to the rite without slighting anyone. When a family plans a big reunion somebody goes down the list branch by branch, the cousins in Fresno and the ones back east and the great-aunt in the home, so that nobody can say they weren’t asked, and that’s the logic of sorting by address. The pair at line 31 covers the daimones by what they do, the regional list covers them by where they are, and between the two of them the sweep is complete, which is all a summons needs. Nobody planning a reunion stops to rank the branches of the family by importance, and this list doesn’t rank its zones either, it just makes sure each one gets a call.
So the cluster supports a sweep and not a system, and the note’s word “nearest” is doing honest work, since this is as close as the Prayer comes to a scheme and it isn’t very close. A real system would rank its zones and match them to its elements, and this list does neither, putting heaven where fire should go and fire where nothing should. What it does show is a mind that pictured the divine world as a crowded landscape, with somebody living in every quarter of it, and wanted every one of them called by their address.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
How does the article interpret the relationship between the two individual daimones and the following regional list?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- What features of the list initially invite readers to see a cosmological system, and what assumptions must they make to sustain that interpretation?→
- How does the placement of fire alter your understanding of the list’s purpose? Would one irregularity be enough to reject a systematic reading?→
- If the Prayer’s main aim is to summon every daimon without omission, how do its classifications by effect and location work together rhetorically?→