Renaissance
The Critic Who Eats What He Studies
Pater pairs the precision of a chemist with the appetite of someone who returns to the same poems for years.
The Renaissance (1893)A French maxim in Pater’s Preface asks critics to feed on beautiful things. The image adds time, pleasure, and familiarity to the work of identifying what gives a painting or poem its effect.
Orientation
At a Glance
- Two kinds of attentionPater’s critic studies the source of an impression as a chemist studies an element. The French maxim adds the kind of familiarity that grows from returning to beautiful things.
- A rule learned at close rangeThe maxim asks readers to limit themselves to knowing works intimately. The focus on individual objects helps explain why Pater wrote studies of particular people, poems, and paintings.
- Appetite sustains attentionFeeding is a repeated activity. The feature uses that image to show how enjoyment can keep a critic returning long enough to notice what a first encounter missed.
- Pleasure still needs an accountAn accomplished reader can say which feature of a work produced an effect and under what conditions it did so. Analysis gives lasting enjoyment a form someone else can test.
The Renaissance · Preface, pp. 2–3 · Preface, note 9
The Preface changes outfits in the middle of a sentence. One moment the critic is in a lab coat, noting the virtue of a picture the way a chemist notes an element, and the next Pater says the rule for reaching that goal has been stated exactly by a recent writer on Sainte-Beuve, and he quotes it in French. De se borner à connaître de près les belles choses, et à s’en nourrir en exquis amateurs, en humanistes accomplis. The edition translates it as “To confine oneself to knowing beautiful things intimately and to nourishing oneself on them as discerning lovers of art and accomplished humanists.” We’ve gone from the laboratory to the dinner table, and the interesting question is what the eating adds that the chemistry couldn’t.
It helps to know whose name hangs over the quotation. Charles-Augustin Sainte-Beuve was the most famous French critic of the century, and he had died in 1869, only a few years before Pater wrote. His long run of weekly literary essays is collected in the Causeries du lundi and Nouveaux Lundis, so his authority came from a lifetime of close, regular, unhurried acquaintance with books, the kind of knowledge you get only by reading steadily week after week. The maxim comes from someone writing about that life, and it carries the life inside it, which is why it reads less like a theory than like a description of a habit. It’s advice drawn from the example of a man who earned his judgments one Monday at a time, and that matters, because the rule Pater is quoting assumes a critic who will still be reading next week and the week after.
Take it one phrase at a time and you can see how much it packs in. Se borner, to confine oneself, is a vow of restraint, in line with the Preface’s refusal to bother with the abstract question of what beauty is. Connaître de près means knowing up close, at handshake distance rather than from a survey. S’en nourrir means feeding on them. Exquis amateurs are discerning lovers, and the French amateur still keeps its root in the Latin for lover, so it means a devotee and not a bungler. And humanistes accomplis, accomplished humanists, borrows the very word for the scholars this book is about, so the critic is being asked to turn into one of his own subjects, a Pico or a Winckelmann, someone whose learning and whose pleasure have grown into a single way of life.
The difference between analyzing and feeding is the difference between a food chemist and someone who eats peaches every summer of his life. The chemist can tell you the sugars and acids in a peach without ever enjoying one, and his knowledge stays outside him, on a sheet of results. Feeding adds three things to that, and the first is repetition, because nobody eats once, while the second is assimilation, because what you eat becomes part of you, and the chemist’s sample never does. Most of all it adds appetite, since you only keep returning to the table for what you actually want, so the feeding critic can’t fake a taste for long.
That’s why the maxim quietly treats sustained enjoyment as a qualification for criticism. On this view you earn the right to judge beautiful things by having fed on them closely for years, not by holding the correct theory or the right degree, and a long record of pleasure is a credential in the way a long record of cases is a credential for a doctor. You know the type from ordinary life, the record-store clerk who has listened to everything and can tell you in ten seconds why one pressing sounds better than another, and whose authority comes from love kept up over decades rather than from any course he took.
The restraint in se borner matters as much as the appetite. Pater’s critic gives up the big questions, beauty in itself and its relation to truth, and in exchange he gets nearness. It’s a trade of scope for intimacy, and it explains why the book that follows is a set of studies of particular people and pictures rather than a system, and why it keeps stopping to look at a single drawing or a single line of verse. A critic who has confined himself in this way can’t give you a theory of everything, but he can tell you exactly what a particular thing is like, because he has lived with it.
There are obvious dangers, and the maxim’s own words point to them. An amateur can slide into a dilettante, a person who samples everything and commits to nothing, and exquis can curdle into preciousness, the connoisseur who enjoys being refined more than he enjoys the art. Pater guards against both in two ways, since the word accomplis insists that the lover also be learned, a finished humanist who has done the work, while the chemist image right before it keeps the feeding honest, since you are still supposed to name what nourished you and say where it came from. Analysis without nourishment is sterile, while nourishment without analysis is just consumption.
So nourishment adds what the chemist lacks, which is time, assimilation and love, and it turns sustained enjoyment into a real qualification for criticism. I’d call it the more radical half of the Preface’s method, because it says a critic’s authority comes from what beautiful things have done to him over years, and that can’t be faked or crammed. Pater puts the chemist and the eater side by side and means for them to be held together, and the best critics you’ve read probably fit both descriptions, people who can tell you precisely why something works because they’ve been feeding on things like it for most of their lives.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
According to the article, what does the metaphor of “feeding” add to the chemist’s analytical knowledge?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- If a critic’s authority rests partly on sustained enjoyment, how should readers evaluate a careful judgment about a work the critic does not personally enjoy?→
- What might criticism gain and lose when it trades broad theories of beauty for intimate attention to particular works?→
- How can a critic tell whether years of returning to an artwork have produced genuine understanding rather than habit, nostalgia, or refined self-image?→