Renaissance
The Critic as Pharmacist
A gem, a wine, and a medicinal herb offer three ways to think about what the critic finds in a work of art.
The Renaissance (1893)Pater’s critic isolates the property that makes an experience distinctive. The analogy with pharmacy helps explain how that property can belong to a work and still depend on the conditions in which someone encounters it.
Orientation
At a Glance
- A virtue is a powerPater calls the capacity to produce a distinctive pleasure a virtue. He compares the critic who identifies it to a chemist who notes a natural element.
- A gem and a wineA gem illustrates a property other people can examine. Wine brings in conditions such as age and a taster’s experience, which influence when a property becomes perceptible.
- The example of an herbA medicinal herb has a power whose effects depend on an encounter. The comparison illuminates Pater’s use of “active principle” for the distinctive way Wordsworth’s poetry makes nature feel alive.
- The work stays in viewA chemist can separate quinine from bark. A critic can name an effect and explain how to look for it, but the next reader or viewer still needs to encounter the work.
The Renaissance · Preface, pp. 3–4 and note 8 · Preface, p. 4, Wordsworth’s active principle
The comparison sits in the middle of the Preface’s busiest paragraph. Pictures, landscapes and engaging people are valuable for their virtues, Pater says, “as we say, in speaking of a herb, a wine, a gem,” and the critic’s job ends “when he has disengaged that virtue, and noted it” the way a chemist notes a natural element. The edition’s note explains that “virtue” here means an active property, as when people speak of a medicinal herb’s efficacy, and it adds that the chemist image makes criticism sound like a disciplined inquiry into what produces an effect. The discussion question is what exactly the critic isolates when he does this, and it’s worth noticing that Pater’s three examples already suggest three different answers.
Take the gem first, because it gives the tidiest answer, that the virtue is a stable ingredient. A diamond’s hardness and its way of bending light are properties it has whether anyone is looking or not, and on this model the critic’s finding is a fact about the work that any competent observer can confirm. That appeals to anyone who wants criticism to be more than mood, and Pater’s best observations often work this way, as when he points to the way light falls on a face or how an outline is drawn. The trouble is that a stable property isn’t yet a pleasure, since a gem’s hardness pleases nobody and its fire only shows up when light and an eye arrive together.
The wine gives a second answer, in which the virtue is real but needs a trained palate and changes with time. A vintage tastes different at five years and at twenty, and the sommelier’s tasting note is less a list of ingredients than a set of directions, telling you to look for leather on the nose or blackcurrant on the finish. On this model the critic offers others a procedure they can try, which is honest about the role of training, since a prompt can help a novice recognize a flavor they might otherwise miss. The weakness is that tasting notes are famous for drifting into fancy, and anyone who has read a few wine labels knows how easily the procedure turns into poetry.
Then there’s the herb, and it helps make sense of Pater’s vocabulary. The virtue of a medicinal plant is its power to act on a body, with effects that depend on dose and constitution. In 1820, Pierre Joseph Pelletier and Joseph Bienaimé Caventou published their work on extracting quinine from cinchona bark. A little further on in the Preface, Pater calls Wordsworth’s distinctive power “the active principle” in his poetry. The work on bark gives us a way to picture what Pater’s critic is trying to do.
The herb model fits the Preface better than the other two because it holds both of Pater’s commitments at once. The virtue is in the work, the way quinine is in the bark, so the critic isn’t just reporting a mood, and yet it’s defined by what it does to someone, the way the medicinal virtue of a plant is understood through its effect on a body, so the encounter can’t be left out. That explains why the Preface asks the critic to say both where an effect comes from and under what conditions it’s felt, since a pharmacist who named a drug without a dose would be dangerous, and a critic who named a virtue without its conditions would be useless.
The analogy also breaks at one important point, and the break is instructive. Quinine works once you extract it, so you can throw the bark away, but nobody can pour Botticelli’s melancholy into a vial and leave the painting behind. The critic “isolates” a virtue only in words, by naming it, and the name is worthless unless it sends you back to the work to find the thing it names. So what the critic actually delivers is a hybrid of all three examples, a named property like the gem’s, with the conditions of the herb attached, offered as a procedure the way a sommelier offers directions to the next drinker. The gem, the herb and the wine turn out to be less like rival theories than like three parts of a single job, with the herb holding the other two together.
There’s a fair complaint on the other side, which is that all this chemistry is costume. The laboratory’s language can make a practice built on impressions sound as exact as a chemical measurement. I think that’s partly true, since no critic’s finding is as repeatable as a melting point. But the costume also binds the person wearing it, because the analogy asks the critic to point to features and conditions another reader can examine. A reader may come away with a different impression and still be able to see where the critic’s account came from.
So what can a critic isolate like a chemist? Something closest to a herb’s virtue, a real power in the work that is named, specified with its conditions, and impossible to extract, so that the isolation takes the form of directions for someone else to reach it. The chemistry image is right about the naming and wrong about the extraction, and that gap is the whole reason criticism ends by sending you back to the work instead of handing you a substitute for it. A critic who gives you a finding you can use without ever looking at the painting has stopped doing Pater’s kind of chemistry, and started selling something else.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
Why does the author judge the herb model a better fit for Pater’s Preface than either the gem or wine model alone?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- If a work’s virtue belongs to the work but is defined partly by its effect on a person, where should we locate the boundary between interpretation and projection?→
- When does a critic’s guidance help readers perceive something they might have missed, and when might it improperly determine what they expect to find?→
- Does the chemistry metaphor make criticism more accountable, or does it give subjective impressions an undeserved appearance of scientific precision?→