Renaissance
The Causes Lose Their Names
Political and religious enthusiasm disappear from Pater’s list. His new phrase admits more kinds of activity while asking readers to supply their own examples.
The Renaissance (1893)The 1873 text names commitments that might sharpen experience. The 1893 wording keeps those commitments possible and gives their place to a broader account of enthusiasm.
Orientation
At a Glance
- Three named causesThe earlier edition puts political and religious enthusiasm and the enthusiasm of humanity beside the joys and sorrows of love.
- A cause and an experienceA commitment can make its supporter feel intensely alive even when the reason for acting lies in what the cause would achieve.
- More room in the later listThe words “disinterested or otherwise” leave room for people whose enthusiasm serves either a public purpose or an interest of their own.
- What readers have to supplyBy removing the named causes, the revision makes it harder to picture the public commitments that the earlier wording immediately brought to mind.
The Renaissance · 1873 Conclusion, p. 160, political and religious enthusiasm · 1873 Conclusion, note 351 · 1893 Conclusion, pp. 152–153, disinterested or otherwise
Set the two sentences side by side and the change is easy to see. In 1873 Pater wrote “High passions give one this quickened sense of life, ecstasy and sorrow of love, political or religious enthusiasm,” and finished the list with the “enthusiasm of humanity.” In 1893 the sentence reads “Great passions may give us this quickened sense of life, ecstasy and sorrow of love, the various forms of enthusiastic activity, disinterested or otherwise, which come naturally to many of us.” Four things have moved at once, since “High” became “Great,” the flat “give one” became the gentler “may give us,” three named causes became one generic phrase, and a new clause about what comes “naturally” was added at the end.
The names meant something specific to a reader in 1873, because political enthusiasm in Pater’s England had faces and crowds, from reform agitation in Britain to the Paris Commune of 1871. John Robert Seeley uses “enthusiasm of humanity” in Ecce Homo for the love of humankind he sees Christ trying to kindle. So the first edition put the activist, the believer and the philanthropist on the same list as the lover and the art lover, which was a striking thing for the supposed prophet of art for art’s sake to do.
That gesture cuts two ways, and both are worth taking seriously. It honors political passion as a real way of living intensely, and it admits that a crowd in the street can quicken a life as much as a painting in a gallery. But it also judges that passion by the same test as all the others, “Only, be sure it is passion,” which means valuing it for the quickened consciousness it gives the person who feels it. A reformer in 1873 might fairly have bristled, since you don’t campaign against child labor to feel alive, you campaign because children are working in mills, and a cause valued for the intensity it gives its supporters starts to look like a gym membership with banners.
By 1893 the names are gone, and it isn’t because public passion had cooled. The London Dock Strike of 1889 and the second Irish Home Rule Bill, rejected by the Lords in 1893, gave Pater’s later readers examples of political enthusiasm close at hand. In East London, Toynbee Hall had offered university graduates a way to work among people facing poverty since 1884. The enthusiasm of humanity had become an institution with a street address, so if Pater stopped naming causes, it wasn’t for lack of causes to name.
The new phrase is worth reading slowly, word by word, because “disinterested” was Matthew Arnold’s word for criticism in “The Function of Criticism at the Present Time” (1864), where it meant keeping aloof from the practical view of things, and “or otherwise” opens the door to interested activity too, ambition, business, a run for office, a fortune being made. The 1893 list is therefore wider than the 1873 list, broad enough to include the speculator’s thrill on a busy day at the exchange alongside the reformer’s zeal. That’s more honest about Pater’s test, which was always about intensity and never about virtue, but it also flattens the moral difference between the person working for others and the person working for himself. Arnold’s critic kept his distance from practice in order to see clearly, while Pater’s phrase asks for no distance at all, since activity of every kind counts as long as it quickens the person doing it.
The added clause, “which come naturally to many of us,” does something subtler. It turns enthusiasm from a cause you choose into a temperament you happen to have, like being a morning person or a talker, and it implies that not everyone is built for it. The clause makes the paragraph sound more like an observation about what moves some people than a summons to commitment. Put that together with “may give us” in place of “give one,” and the sentence has stopped telling you what quickens life and started observing what sometimes does.
So what forms of commitment remain imaginable in the 1893 paragraph? In principle, every one, since the phrase is roomy enough for a union organizer, a missionary, a campaigner or the founder of a firm, and nothing is ruled out. But nothing is named either, and naming is how a sentence makes you picture something. A reader who loved the first edition could close the book and go to a meeting, while a reader of the last edition is more likely to close it and go back to the book. In 1873 the reader could see the crowd and hear the speeches, while in 1893 the reader sees a category, and the closing paragraph becomes almost entirely a matter of how individuals feel, with very little left about where they stand in the society around them.
The revision widens the range of passions Pater will admit and drains the public stakes out of his list. It’s tactful, more consistent with the test of passion, and less exposed to the charge of treating causes as stimulants, but it’s also less brave. I think the 1873 sentence was the better and riskier one, because it dared to put the barricade and the sonnet on a single list, while the 1893 phrase still leaves that possibility open without asking the reader to imagine it.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
Why does the author regard Pater’s 1873 treatment of political passion as double-edged?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- When Pater evaluates political, religious, artistic, and personal passions by how intensely they are felt, what becomes visible—and what becomes obscured—about the value of those commitments?→
- Does replacing named causes with a broad category make the 1893 sentence more inclusive, less politically meaningful, or both? How would you defend your judgment?→
- Why might naming specific commitments influence a reader differently from leaving every form of commitment possible but unstated?→