Greek Antiquity
The Bonds That Make a Life Hold Together
Death loosens the bonds of nature, and the hymn leaves the fate of the soul open at the moment of separation.
The Orphic Collection, Volume I: The HymnsThanatos holds the tiller of mortals and keeps his distance for the span allotted to them. When he comes, the hymn pictures dying as an unfastening of the structure that held soul and body together.
Orientation
At a Glance
- Death guides the mortal spanThe opening gives Thanatos the tiller of all mortals and ties his distance to the time allotted to each life.
- His arrival unfastens a structureThe hymn describes him loosening the firm-held bonds of nature as his sleep shatters soul and bodily frame.
- The image marks a permanent sleepThe unfastening brings living things the long sleep the hymn calls everlasting.
- The soul’s fate remains openThe article asks whether the soul is broken with the frame or released from the bonds that held them together.
Orphic Hymns, LXXXVII.1–5, with the notes on LXXXVII.1 and LXXXVII.2
The hymn to Thanatos begins by naming Death’s office and then describes his act. He is the one “who hold the tiller of all mortals,” giving each a holy span of time, and then the hymn says what happens when the span is over, in lines that begin with a reason, “for your sleep shatters the soul and the body’s frame, / whenever you loose the firm-held bonds of nature, / bringing to living things the long everlasting sleep.” Death is pictured not as a blow from outside but as an undoing, the release of bonds that had been holding a life together.
The bonds are the key image, since a living creature, on this picture, is something bound, soul and body fastened together by nature and held firm for as long as life lasts, and death is the moment those bonds are loosed. Greek physicians and philosophers thought about life in exactly these terms, and Plato’s Timaeus describes the soul as anchored in the body by bonds fastened in the marrow. When those bonds wear out with age and come loose, Plato says, the soul is released by nature and flies away with pleasure, which he calls the painless death that comes at the natural end of life.
The verb for loosing is the same one the collection uses for untying ships from their moorings and freeing captives, and it makes dying an act of release as much as destruction. Plato’s Phaedo calls death exactly that, the release and separation of the soul from the body, and the hymn’s language sits close to his. Yet the hymn also says that Death’s sleep “shatters the soul and the body’s frame,” using a verb for breaking something brittle, so that the same sentence holds a gentle unfastening and a violent breaking side by side.
That pairing is where the image leaves the soul’s fate open. If the sleep shatters the soul, the soul may be broken along with the body, the view of the Epicureans, who held that the soul is made of fine atoms that scatter at death like smoke, and Lucretius compares the soul to water that spills away when the vessel of the body is shattered. If what is shattered is the joining of soul and body, the soul may go free, the view of Plato and of the Orphic gold leaves, whose dead initiates claim to be children of Earth and starry Heaven on their way to the meadows of the blessed. The hymn’s words allow either, and it chooses not to say which.
The image also makes dying imaginable in a way that abstract language cannot. Everyone has seen a knot come loose or a frame fall apart when its joints give way, and the hymn asks the listener to picture death as that kind of event, a structure that was held firm coming undone. The body’s frame is the Greek for something drawn or hauled, the long shape of a body as a ship’s hull is a shape, and its shattering is the end of that held-together form. The soul, which was fastened into it, is released from the frame or broken with it, and the image stops at that point. Homer calls death the long bronze sleep and says again and again that a dying warrior’s limbs were loosed, so loosening had always been the epic word for dying.
The edition’s note on line 2 adds a quiet detail about the holy span of time that precedes all this. It says that the second half of the line means Death “is at a distance from the living for exactly as long as their time lasts,” so that the bonds hold precisely as long as Death stands far off. The note on line 1 points out that the hymn gives Death the tiller of all mortals, a title it gave earlier to Eros and to Nomos, but without the word alone, which comes only later in the hymn. Death steers the whole course of a life, and the loosing of the bonds is the moment he brings it to shore.
The Bible describes dying in almost the same physical terms, and then says what becomes of the spirit. The Preacher tells the young to remember their Creator before the silver cord is loosed, or the golden bowl is broken, or the pitcher is broken at the fountain, and then the dust shall return to the earth as it was, and the spirit shall return to God who gave it. Paul uses a verb of loosing for his own death, saying that he desires to depart and be with Christ, and later that the time of his departure is at hand, as a ship is loosed from its moorings, and the King James translators chose the word departure, which keeps the sense of a journey begun.
My verdict is that the hymn’s physical language makes dying imaginable as the loosing of bonds that held a life together, a structure of soul and body unfastened at the end of its appointed span. The image is precise about what happens to the joining and silent about what happens to the soul, which may be shattered with the frame or released from it. Ecclesiastes completes the same image by saying where the spirit goes, but the hymn stops at the moment of unfastening, and its restraint leaves the worshipper facing Death’s act without being told what lies on the other side of it.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
Why does the article treat the hymn’s pairing of “loosing” and “shattering” as especially significant?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- How does imagining death as the loosening of bonds change its emotional or philosophical meaning compared with imagining it as an external blow?→
- Does the hymn’s refusal to decide the soul’s fate make its account of death weaker, more powerful, or simply different? Why?→
- What might the paired images of steering a life and bringing it to shore suggest about Death’s relationship to both life’s duration and its ending?→