Greek Antiquity

The Bonds That Hold the World

Kronos holds the world’s bonds, and the article reads them as the limits that let change hold together.

The hymn puts cosmic bonds in the hands of a god often pictured in chains. Whether the bonds are unbreakable or unspeakable, the article asks how they can sustain a world that continually changes.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The myth’s position is reversedKronos holds the bonds throughout the kosmos in the hymn and is himself bound in stories of the Titans.
  • One letter changes the bondLennep’s reading makes the bonds unbreakable, while the manuscripts call them unspeakable.
  • The god sustains changeKronos consumes and renews everything and is said to dwell in every part of the kosmos.
  • A bond can give coherenceThe article proposes that the bonds give recurring change its limits and measures.

Orphic Hymns, XIII.3–8, with the apparatus; XII.4

The fourth line of the hymn to Kronos is a reversal worth stopping on, “you who hold unbreakable bonds throughout the boundless kosmos.” In the myths Kronos is the one who ends up bound. Hesiod has the Titans chained in Tartarus after their war with the Olympians, and the Orphic theogony, as Porphyry reports it, had Night advise Zeus to make Kronos drunk on honey under the oaks and tie him up while he slept. The hymn takes the god who wore the chains and puts the chains in his hands, and stretches them across the whole cosmos, which raises a real question about what these bonds are for, whether they hold something prisoner, hold the world together, or hold change within limits.

First a word about the text, because it matters to the argument. “Unbreakable,” arrhēktous, is a conjecture by Lennep, the same editor who touched line 7, and the manuscripts read arrhētous, which differs by one letter and means “unspeakable,” the word used of sacred things that may not be told. Lennep’s word has Homer behind it, since Hephaestus forges bonds “unbreakable, unloosable” to trap Ares and Aphrodite in bed, and the manuscripts’ word has the hymns behind it, since Herakles is called “unspeakable” just one hymn earlier. The two readings lean in different directions, unbreakable toward a snare and unspeakable toward a mystery, but the question of what the bonds hold survives either way, so it’s fair to weigh the three possibilities with both in view.

Restraint is the reading the myths would suggest, and it deserves its due. In Greek story bonds are mostly prisons, Hephaestus’ net, Prometheus fettered to his pillar, the Titans in the pit, and a Titan who has been bound might well be imagined in his turn as a binder, the jailer of whatever powers threaten the world. The trouble with it is the company the line keeps, since the line before addresses him as “you who consume all things and yourself increase them again,” and four lines later he is addressed as “you who dwell in every part of the kosmos,” and a jailer isn’t much of a description of someone who makes things grow and lives inside everything he binds. Restraint fits the old stories about Kronos far better than it fits the god this hymn describes.

Coherence has much better credentials, at least in the language of the philosophers. In philosophical Greek a bond, desmos, is the standard word for whatever holds a whole together, and Plato’s Timaeus says the finest of bonds is the one that makes itself and the things it binds as nearly one as possible, which he identifies with proportion. Later in the same dialogue the maker of the world tells the lesser gods that whatever is bound can in principle be loosed, but that his own will is a greater bond than the ones they were made with. On this reading Kronos’ bonds are the ties that keep the boundless kosmos from flying apart, and that fits beautifully with a god who dwells in every part of the world, present everywhere because he is what holds everything in place.

The third option, a limit on change, comes straight out of the Stoic reading of Kronos as time. Cicero reports that the Stoics explained the binding of Kronos by Zeus as a way of keeping time’s courses from running without limit, so that Zeus fettered him with the bonds of the stars. On that view the bonds are measures, the regular courses of the heavens that keep the seasons in order, much like Heraclitus’ saying that the sun will not overstep his measures, or the Furies, ministers of Justice, will find him out. Bonds of this kind don’t stop change, they shape it, and that suits a god who consumes and restores, since what gets consumed comes back only if the cycle holds.

What makes the hymn interesting is that it takes the Stoic picture and flips it. In Cicero’s allegory time is the prisoner and the stars are the chains, but in the hymn Kronos is the one holding the bonds, so time is no longer the thing held to its measures but the keeper of the measures themselves. That turns the bonds into something like the rhythm of the world, the pattern by which things arrive and depart, and it explains why the line can speak of bonds in a “boundless” kosmos without contradicting itself. The world can be without edge and still be held together, the way a piece of music can go on and on and still be held together by its beat.

If the manuscripts’ “unspeakable” is right, the picture gets richer rather than different. The ties that make a seed become a tree and a tree fall and a generation give way to the next aren’t visible things you could point to, and calling them unspeakable fits both their hiddenness and the reverence of a group of initiates who sang about holy things they didn’t spell out. A Christian reader will hear a close cousin in the letter to the Colossians, which says of Christ that “by him all things consist,” using a Greek verb that means to hold together, so that the coherence of the world is located in a person rather than in a law.

My verdict is that the bonds most naturally mean coherence through limit, the measures by which change is held in its cycles across every part of the world. Restraint belongs to the myths about Kronos rather than to this hymn, whose god renews and dwells in all things rather than locking them up, and the Stoic idea of a limit on change is right about the content but backwards about the direction, since here Kronos holds the bonds instead of wearing them. Whether they are unbreakable with Lennep or unspeakable with the manuscripts, they are the ties of time, the hidden rhythm that lets a boundless world consume itself and grow again without falling apart.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

Why does the author consider a purely punitive interpretation of Kronos’ bonds inadequate for the hymn?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.