Renaissance
The Blind Schoolmaster’s Library
Helping a nearly blind rector gave Winckelmann access to books he could explore for himself.
The Renaissance (1893)Pater makes a small school library the beginning of an education that took Winckelmann from Homer and Herodotus toward the art of antiquity.
Orientation
At a Glance
- Work as a readerWinckelmann read aloud and assisted Esaias Wilhelm Tappert as the rector’s sight failed.
- A library opens upThe school entrusted Winckelmann with its books, which he used to pursue interests beyond the tasks assigned to him.
- Theology and Greek literatureWinckelmann went on to study theology at Halle, while Homer and Herodotus kept their hold on him.
- A lifelong patternAccess to the school library anticipates the later collections where employment again gave him room to study for himself.
The Renaissance · Winckelmann, the schoolmaster and the Greek books · Note 277, famulus or personal attendant · Winckelmann, longing for the ancient world · Winckelmann, theology at Halle and Herodotus · Winckelmann Museum, the school years and Tappert · Staatsbibliothek zu Berlin, the Tappert archive catalogue
Pater gives the scene in a few quick strokes. “We find him as a child in the dusky precincts of a German school, hungrily feeding on a few colourless books. The master of this school grows blind; Winckelmann becomes his famulus,” his personal attendant. “The old man would have had him study theology. Winckelmann, free of the master’s library, chooses rather to become familiar with the Greek classics.” Then “Herodotus and Homer win, with their ’vowelled’ Greek, his warmest enthusiasm; whole nights of fever are devoted to them; disturbing dreams of an Odyssey of his own come to him.”
The documents fill in the outline, and they make the scene richer. The master was Esaias Wilhelm Tappert, rector of the Latin school at Stendal. As his sight failed, the cobbler’s son became his reader and assistant. Winckelmann was also given charge of the small school library. Tappert later recommended him for the Cöllnisches Gymnasium in Berlin. The arrangement was service, but it was also patronage, an old man spending what credit he had on a talent he could no longer see.
Think for a moment about what the job actually involved, day to day. A reader for a blind scholar has to voice whatever the master wants to hear, Latin, Greek, sermons and commentaries, and that means hearing the languages aloud long before they’re fully understood. Milton’s daughters, the old story goes, read to their blind father in languages they had only been taught to pronounce. Closer to our time, a teenage bookshop clerk named Alberto Manguel spent evenings in Buenos Aires reading aloud to the blind Jorge Luis Borges and grew up to become one of the great writers about reading. The service of reading aloud turns out to be one of the oldest apprenticeships there is.
That’s why Pater’s odd little word “vowelled” matters so much here. Pater’s word makes the vowels and rhythm of Greek something we can imagine hearing. We know Winckelmann read aloud for Tappert. Which passages he read to him is a separate question, and the sound of Homer’s hexameter belongs to Pater’s picture of the boy’s growing enthusiasm. Winckelmann’s later prose about sculpture is famous for its sense of smooth, flowing surfaces, and it’s tempting to think that his first experience of the Greek world was through the ear rather than the eye, in a dark house where the only light that mattered was the boy’s voice.
The irony of the library is that it was meant for something else. Tappert hoped his pupil would study theology, and the Latin school gave boys a route into such work, so the same shelves that were supposed to lead toward the pulpit led instead toward Homer and Herodotus. Winckelmann did go to Halle to study theology, as his friends wanted, and promptly became “the enthusiastic translator of Herodotus,” so the pagan Greece he would spend his life recovering came to him through a Christian schoolmaster’s collection.
The imagined Odyssey turns the arrangement from service into opportunity. In Pater’s account, reading about Odysseus opens up a kind of freedom the boy cannot yet exercise, and Pater says the dreams were “disturbing,” as if the poem were unsettling the life it was supposed to furnish. The plans that followed were wild, journeys to Egypt and to France, and Pater notes that in them there “seems always to be rather a wistful sense of something lost to be regained, than the desire of discovering anything new.” The Odyssey is the right poem for that feeling, since it’s the story of a man trying to get home. The adult Winckelmann gave the dream a real shape, planning journeys to Greece that never happened while Rome and Naples became the actual stages of his wandering.
Pater’s phrase “free of the master’s library” is the hinge of the scene. Being someone’s eyes could have been mere drudgery, and plenty of poor boys in service never got further than the chores. What made the difference was that the job carried a key, the run of the shelves after the reading was done, and that the boy used it for his own purposes rather than the master’s. It’s a pattern that recurs throughout Winckelmann’s life, in Count Bünau’s library and then in the cardinals’ libraries of Rome, where a position of service opened a collection he could make his own.
My verdict is that the blind schoolmaster’s library turns an arrangement of service into an intellectual opportunity because it joins three things a poor boy rarely gets at once, access to books, the habit of hearing old languages aloud and a patron willing to spend on him. Tappert’s hopes for a theologian went unanswered, and in a sense he was outwitted by his own generosity, but the debt was real, and it complicates Winckelmann’s later claim to have been his own teacher. What Pater adds to the account is the suggestion that a future student of sculpture could first have fallen for the sound of Greek.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
Why does the author call Pater’s phrase “free of the master’s library” the hinge of the scene?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- How does the article complicate the distinction between service and education in Winckelmann’s relationship with Tappert?→
- What does the emphasis on hearing Greek suggest about the relationship between sound, imagination, and Winckelmann’s later interest in visual art?→
- To what extent does Tappert’s patronage challenge Winckelmann’s later claim that he was his own teacher?→