Renaissance
The Anemone From Holy Ground
Pater pictures a flower growing from Jerusalem earth mixed with Pisan clay. Michelangelo’s Doni Tondo gives him another way to put sacred and pagan forms together.
The Renaissance (1893)An old burial-ground legend gives Pater his image of the Renaissance. In Michelangelo’s round painting, the Holy Family and the background nudes share a frame, and a low barrier keeps them apart.
Orientation
At a Glance
- The legend mixes two kinds of soilPater imagines Jerusalem earth mingling with Pisan clay and producing an anemone with rings of color. The flower gives him an image for a mythology nourished by two traditions.
- The flower has a classical storyIn Ovid, Venus makes a short-lived flower from Adonis’s blood. That story gives Pater’s windflower another association before it grows in the Christian burial ground.
- Michelangelo keeps the groups visibleThe Holy Family fills the foreground of the Doni Tondo. A low barrier sets it apart from the young nudes at the back, with John the Baptist between the groups.
- Pater supplies the faunsPater imagines the young men as figures from a Dionysiac revel. The Uffizi offers a different reading and leaves their identity open to interpretation.
The Renaissance · Pico della Mirandola, pp. 30–31, the Camposanto fresco · Pico della Mirandola, note 71 · Pico della Mirandola, pp. 34–35, the anemone and the Doni Tondo · Pico della Mirandola, note 80 · Pico della Mirandola, p. 35, the union of contrasts
Pater tells the legend in one long, gorgeous sentence. “When the ship-load of sacred earth from the soil of Jerusalem was mingled with the common clay in the Campo Santo at Pisa, a new flower grew up from it, unlike any flower men had seen before, the anemone with its concentric rings of strangely blended colour, still to be found by those who search long enough for it, in the long grass of the Maremma,” the marshy coast of southern Tuscany. Then comes the moral, which turns the flower into a theory of the age. “Just such a strange flower was that mythology of the Italian Renaissance, which grew up from the mixture of two traditions, two sentiments, the sacred and the profane.” The edition’s note glosses camposanto, the holy field that serves as Pisa’s great cemetery.
The legend is itself a mixed growth. The University of Zurich’s Camposanto research project traces the holy-earth story in writing to the later fourteenth century, after the cemetery’s building campaign had begun. Later accounts credit the earth with consuming bodies unusually quickly. One fifteenth-century version places its origin in the burial ground for strangers outside Jerusalem associated with Judas’s silver.
The flower is mixed too, and more deeply than Pater says. Its name comes from the Greek for wind, so the anemone is the windflower, and in Ovid’s Metamorphoses Venus makes it spring from the blood of her dying lover Adonis, a blossom as brief as his life, shaken loose by the very winds that give it its name. So the flower Pater says grew from Christian holy ground already had a story about a pagan death before Pater set it in the cemetery. That makes it an even better emblem than he lets on, since the profane tradition was in the flower’s petals from the start, and the sacred earth only gave the old story a new place to grow.
What does the image prepare us to notice, then? It primes us for blending, for an art in which sacred and pagan bleed into each other the way Pater imagines the anemone’s colors mixing, and his next example is chosen to deliver exactly that. In the Doni Madonna, he says, “Michelangelo actually brings the pagan religion, and with it the unveiled human form, the sleepy-looking fauns of a Dionysiac revel, into the presence of the Madonna,” just as simpler painters had put birds or flowers there, “while he has given to that Madonna herself much of the uncouth energy of the older and more primitive” Mighty Mother, the older maternal figure he invokes.
Now look at the painting itself, which rewards a slow look. The Doni Tondo at the Uffizi is a round panel associated with Agnolo Doni and Maddalena Strozzi. The museum places it around the birth of their daughter Maria in 1507 and discusses a possible connection with her christening. In the foreground the Virgin sits on the grass and twists her powerful body, strong arms raised toward her shoulder, as the Child passes between her and Joseph. Behind them, in the middle ground, stands the young John the Baptist, set apart, and behind him a low horizontal band, a wall or ledge, separates the Holy Family from five nude young men who lean and sit along the background.
The five nudes have human bodies and appear at ease. The edition’s note treats Pater’s fauns as an interpretation. The Uffizi suggests that the nudes may represent pagan humanity and that John the Baptist may point toward the painting’s use for a christening. The figures leave room for both readers to ask what the arrangement says about a relation between the two groups.
What the painting clearly does show is arrangement rather than blending. The background nudes share the panel with the Holy Family, and a low wall sets the groups apart, with the Baptist standing between them and the Holy Family like a sentry at a border, and the composition reads from front to back as a series of zones. Here Pater’s own image turns out to fit better than his prose. The concentric rings in Pater’s flower are distinguishable even though they grow from the same soil. A round painting organized in zones can hold differences in a similar way.
My verdict is that the anemone legend prepares us to see mixture, and that it is a doubly mixed legend in its own right, a holy-earth story carrying a flower already associated with a pagan death. But the Doni Tondo shows coexistence by arrangement rather than by fusion, with the young nudes behind a wall and the Holy Family in front, and the revel Pater sees there is his own contribution. That’s a fitting last image for the Pico chapter, whose hero Pater calls a “picturesque union of contrasts,” since the union in Pico, as in the painting, was a matter of placing different things side by side and letting the viewer feel the strain.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
Why does the author consider the anemone an even stronger emblem of the Renaissance than Pater explicitly recognizes?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- How does the anemone's combination of Christian setting and pagan history complicate the difference between mixture and coexistence?→
- If the Doni Tondo keeps its groups visibly separate, in what sense can it still represent a “union of contrasts”?→
- What interpretive advantages and risks arise when Pater describes the background nudes as participants in a Dionysiac revel?→