Renaissance
Strength That Changes Hands
A French tale and Michelangelo’s figures make Pater’s idea of strength visible in different ways.
The Renaissance (1893)Pater finds medieval strength first in the alarming loyalty of Amis and Amile and then in the strain of Michelangelo’s figures. One unfolds through action, while the other holds strain and grace within the same form.
Orientation
At a Glance
- A quality crosses chaptersPater pairs the strength of medieval art with sweetness in his French tale and again in his account of Michelangelo.
- An ordeal unfolds in timeAmile’s terrible choice comes before the tale restores his children to life, so readers must reckon with the act before the ending.
- A figure holds both qualitiesMichelangelo’s Adam lets Pater see the effort of coming to life alongside the beauty of the emerging form.
- The analogy has a limitThe tale’s moral extremity and the fresco’s formal energy remain different experiences even when Pater calls them both strength.
The Renaissance · Two Early French Stories, rude strength and sweetness · Two Early French Stories, Amis takes his friend’s place · Two Early French Stories, Amile faces the choice · Two Early French Stories, the children at play · Two Early French Stories, Pater names the story’s strength · Michelangelo, sweetness and strength · Michelangelo, Adam and the sense of resurrection
Pater’s whole theory of the Renaissance has two ingredients, and he names them early. In the first essay, “the rude strength of the middle age turns to sweetness” under rare and happy conditions, and after the tale of Amis and Amile he says the Renaissance has “not only the sweetness which it derives from the classical world, but also that curious strength of which there are great resources in the true middle age.” Nearly forty pages later, introducing Michelangelo, he names the same pair, “sweetness and strength,” and says Michelangelo “sums up” for his admirers “the whole character of medieval art itself.” So the strength Pater finds in a medieval tale reappears in his account of a sixteenth-century sculptor, and the question is what survives the trip.
In the tale, the strength is in what people do. Amis has taken his friend’s place in a fight to the death, and when Amis is struck with leprosy and an angel says he can be healed with the blood of Amile’s two small children, Amile does it, and the children are later found alive and playing. “There, as I said, is the strength of the old French story,” Pater says, and he means a loyalty that goes past every limit a sensible person would set. It’s medieval in the way he says the tale comes from the North with “a certain racy Teutonic flavour,” blunt, extreme, and willing to put the most terrible act in a single plain clause. It’s the kind of story that makes a modern reader flinch, and Pater’s point is that the flinch is part of its power.
In Michelangelo, the strength is in how matter is shaped. Pater speaks of “an energy of conception which seems at every moment about to break through all the conditions of comely form,” and of a “convulsive energy” that, in lesser hands, becomes “merely monstrous or forbidding.” His example is the Adam of the Sistine ceiling, “something rude and satyr-like” about him, a figure that seems to be dragging itself into being out of the rock it lies on. Here nobody does anything terrible, and the violence is all in the form, in a body that looks as though its making had cost a struggle, and the sweetness is the loveliness it recovers, as Pater says, “touch by touch.”
The crucial difference between the two forms is time. A story has to be read in order, so the tale gives you its strength first and its sweetness only at the end, and you have to get through the horror before you reach the restoration. You can’t skip ahead without losing what the story is, and for several paragraphs you live with a father who has killed his children for a friend. A figure in stone or paint places the energy and loveliness together. A viewer may notice them in stages, but the work lets both qualities occupy the same space. The tale also controls its own pace, slowing at the bedside and hurrying at the blow, while a picture leaves the pace to the viewer, who can look for a second or an hour.
That means the two forms make opposite demands on their audiences. The tale asks for moral patience, a willingness to suspend judgment on a monstrous act until the story completes it, and many modern readers can’t or won’t give that, which is fair, since the tale really does ask a great deal. The figure asks for perceptual double vision, seeing the strain and the grace at the same moment, and a viewer who sees only strain finds Michelangelo brutal, while one who sees only grace finds him merely beautiful. Pater’s phrase “pleasure with surprise” names that double demand exactly.
There’s a pattern under both that explains why Pater pairs them. In each case the strength ends in a return to life. Amis is cleansed and the children are found at play, and Michelangelo’s creations, Pater says in the same passage, have “all the characteristics of resurrection,” the recovery of a life that seemed suspended. The Latin tag he gives the Michelangelesque, ex forti dulcedo, “sweetness out of strength,” fits both, since in each the sweetness isn’t added to the strength from outside but comes out of it, like honey from the lion in Samson’s riddle, and wouldn’t exist without it. The comparison even explains the thread of crimson left on the children’s throats, which keeps the strength visible inside the sweetness, much as Michelangelo’s unfinished surfaces keep the stone visible inside the figure.
The skeptic will object that Pater is stretching one word to cover two unrelated things, a moral extremity in a story and a formal energy in a sculpture, and that calling both “strength” hides more than it reveals. A father’s terrible act and a muscular torso don’t obviously belong to the same category. Pater’s historical claim is also a comparison. He treats the tale and the figure as expressions of a capacity for extremity that Renaissance art could inherit and transform. The resemblance rests on the reading, not on a direct line of transmission from the story to the fresco. Pater adds a further hint when he traces the tale to the North and its “Teutonic” flavor, while Michelangelo was a Florentine, so the shared strength crosses regions as well as centuries.
The strength passes, then, from content to form, from what people do in the tale to how matter behaves under Michelangelo’s hands, and that transfer is the Renaissance in miniature, as Pater tells it, the middle age’s energy becoming a property of style. The tale demands patience through time, the figure demands double vision in a single moment, and both ask the reader to accept a strangeness that only becomes sweet if you stay with it. In lesser hands both would be monstrous, which is Pater’s own warning, and it’s the measure of these two works that each turns its violence into a return to life.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
How does the article characterize the change in “strength” from the medieval tale to Michelangelo’s art?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- If the tale’s restoration does not erase the horror that precedes it, in what sense can its ending transform the meaning of Amile’s act?→
- Does describing both moral extremity and formal energy as “strength” deepen the comparison, or does it blur an important distinction? Why?→
- Why might an artwork’s ability to present strain and grace simultaneously create a different ethical experience from a story that reveals them in sequence?→