Philosophy
Sparring Partners
Socrates says he’s examining Critias’ argument for his own sake. In a wrestling school, there’s a ready image for what one person can learn by meeting another’s resistance.
The Platonic Dialogues: CharmidesCritias supplies the definition, but Socrates brings a hunch about temperance that the inquiry also puts under strain. He ends up having to account for what his own questioning achieved.
Orientation
At a Glance
- Who stands to learnSocrates says he tests Critias’ words to guard against mistaking his own confidence for knowledge.
- Socrates brings a hunchSocrates expects temperance to benefit people. Critias’ account gives him a concrete proposal to test against that expectation.
- What resistance revealsThe wrestling school suggests how a partner can expose weaknesses a person might miss alone. Critias’ proposal plays that role for Socrates’ inquiry.
- The hunch survives the testAt the end Socrates still believes temperance is good, even though he counts his own inquiry as a failure.
Socrates says he’s examining the argument “for my own sake above all.” It’s a strange thing to tell the man who has just accused him of trying to win. Critias supplies the answers and has to defend them. Socrates gets to ask the questions. Yet Socrates says he would scrutinize his own words for the very reason he’s questioning Critias. He wants to catch himself if he starts to believe he knows something he doesn’t. What could an argument with somebody else show him about himself?
At first it looks as though Critias is doing all the risking. He has to say what temperance knows, whether that sort of knowledge could exist, and what good it might do. Socrates can say he’s perplexed and ask for another answer. If the conversation ends there, Critias is the one whose definition has broken down in front of the company. It would be easy to hear Socrates’ explanation as a gracious way of taking the sting out of the questions. The test is whether he brings anything of his own that the inquiry could unsettle.
He does bring a conviction about what temperance should be able to do. Before they settle whether knowledge can know itself, he says he has “a prophetic hunch that temperance is something beneficial and good.” He also admits he can’t say confidently whether there can be knowledge of knowledge in the first place. These are different kinds of uncertainty. He knows what he hopes an account of temperance will explain. He has yet to find out if the account on offer can explain it, or if his way of pursuing the question will get them anywhere better.
The setting offers an image for what he’s doing. Socrates tells us at the start that he went to Taureas’ wrestling school when he got back from Potidaea. Imagine trying out a hold in a place like that. You can rehearse how it’s supposed to work on your own. A partner makes you find out whether you can keep your balance when someone shifts their weight just as you make the move. The point of the partner is the resistance. A move that felt sound by yourself can suddenly tell you where you were relying on the other person to stand still.
Critias’ proposal gives Socrates something comparable to push against. If a kind of knowledge could look after all the others, there’s an appealing thought that it might make a person’s life go better. Critias presses that possibility even after they assign benefit to knowledge of good and bad. Socrates follows the exchange far enough to see that the definition they’ve been using has left temperance with no benefit of its own. He then has a problem of his own to face. He still believes temperance is good, and the inquiry he has led can’t show him why.
In the Apology, Socrates tells the jury that examining himself and others belongs to the same daily practice. He says it’s the greatest good for a human being to discuss virtue and the other things they’ve heard him examine. The two dialogues put that practice under different kinds of pressure. In the courtroom, he has to explain why he can’t simply promise to keep quiet. In the wrestling school, we can see why he might need another person’s proposal to find a weakness in his own understanding. By himself, he might never have had to ask how a virtue that governs expertise would actually make anyone better off.
A practice bout is useful to both people when they have some agreement about what they’re doing. Socrates says that Critias, who is used to being admired, covers up his perplexity before the company. They can still put a claim under pressure, but it’s harder to call that shared training if one of them feels he has to hide what the exercise has shown him. Socrates, as narrator, gets to tell us what he thinks Critias felt. We can see what he does with his own difficulty more directly in the words he reports speaking at the end.
Socrates tells Charmides he still thinks temperance is a great good and calls himself “a poor inquirer.” The phrase leaves a mark that a victory over Critias wouldn’t explain. He’s found a place where his own questioning can’t do what he needs it to do. At the close he still has a hunch he can’t account for. That’s one thing a demanding partner can give you. You come away knowing where your hold slipped.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
What distinction does the article draw between Socrates’ two kinds of uncertainty?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- If questioning another person can reveal weaknesses in your own beliefs, what attitudes must you bring to the conversation for that self-examination to occur?→
- Does Socrates’ continued belief that temperance is good strengthen his inquiry by guiding it, or weaken it by prejudging the result? Why?→
- When Critias hides his perplexity, how does that change the inquiry from shared practice into something more competitive?→