Philosophy

Socrates Tells on Himself

Three asides to an unnamed listener reveal what Socrates is willing to admit about himself.

Socrates tells this whole story to a friend Plato never names, and he turns to that friend only three times. Every single time, he’s about to confess something embarrassing about himself.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • An unnamed listenerPlato presents the dialogue as Socrates’ account of a visit to the wrestling school, told to someone whose identity remains open.
  • Three revealing asidesSocrates turns to his listener when he questions his eye for beauty, loses his confidence, and catches sight inside Charmides’ cloak.
  • An honest self-portraitSocrates includes details that make him look embarrassed and flustered. He could have told the story in a way that made him look composed.
  • Knowing yourselfThe asides show what it sounds like to admit your limits before the dialogue tests definitions of temperance.

Charmides 153a, 154b, 155c–d, 167a, 169c

The Charmides isn’t written like a script, with names in the margin and lines for each speaker, because the whole thing comes to us as a story Socrates is telling someone after the fact, starting with “We had got back from the army at Potidaea the evening before,” and Plato never tells us who that someone is. There’s no name, no reply, and no little frame scene where a friend asks Socrates what happened at the gym yesterday, and Plato pulls the same move in other narrated dialogues like the Republic and the Lysis, where Socrates simply starts talking and we’re never told who’s on the other end. It’s tempting to cast the part, but the text gives you nothing to go on, so the more interesting question is what Socrates does with his listener.

What he does turns out to be surprisingly specific. Socrates turns and speaks straight to his listener exactly three times, all within about a page, and each time he’s about to admit something that makes him look bad. The first comes when Charmides walks in and Socrates confesses that he’s hopeless as a judge, “Now I, my friend, am no measure of anything,” because where the beautiful are concerned he’s “simply a white measuring-line on white stone” and nearly every kid that age looks gorgeous to him. The second comes on the bench, “And then, my friend, I really was at a loss,” when his confidence gets knocked out of him, and the third is the big one, “then, my noble friend, I saw inside his cloak, and I was on fire.”

If you’ve ever told a friend a story that makes you look like an idiot, you know exactly what these little nudges are doing. They’re the moments where you stop narrating and look your buddy in the eye, the “dude, I’m telling you” that comes right before the part you’d rather skip, and the Greek words carry the same warmth. Socrates calls his listener his comrade, then his friend, and finally, at the most undignified moment of all, his gennada, literally his “noble” or “well-born” friend, which gives the confession a mock-heroic grandeur exactly when Socrates has lost every scrap of his own dignity. It’s funny, and it’s meant to be funny, because the comedy is what lets Plato put a frankly erotic scene into a dialogue about self-control without making it either sleazy or solemn.

Now think about what Socrates could have done instead, because it tells you a lot about him. He’s telling this story later, calm and in control, and he could easily have edited himself into the cool one, the philosopher who sized up the beautiful boy without breaking a sweat. That’s what most of us would do, and it’s the opposite of what Socrates does with the material that would actually make him look good, since this is the same man who squeezed an entire battle at Potidaea into a single sentence. He spends his words where a vain narrator would cut corners, on his own weakness, and he saves his nudges for the details that cost him something, as if he wants to be sure his friend heard the embarrassing bits.

Then look at what happens once the argument gets going, because the addresses to the friend stop completely. Later in the dialogue Critias gets cornered, and Socrates narrates his discomfort in loving detail, how he caught Socrates’ perplexity “like people who catch a yawn” and then refused to admit he was stuck in front of everyone. That’s a juicy moment, the kind you’d love to share with a buddy, and Socrates doesn’t turn to his listener once while telling it. The nudges are reserved for Socrates’ own humiliations, and he never uses them to make fun of somebody else.

That pattern lines up with the dialogue’s big theme in a way that’s hard to call an accident. When Critias finally gets to his favorite definition, temperance turns out to be “knowing oneself,” which he and Socrates spell out as “knowing what one knows and what one does not know.” The argument goes on to take that definition apart, but the narration has already shown us a man doing something very close to it in practice. Socrates tells his friend straight out what he’s no good at, that he’s “no measure” when it comes to beauty, that he was “at a loss,” that he was “no longer in my own possession,” and he does it without spin and without dragging anyone else down to make himself look better.

That’s also why the listener has to stay unnamed. A named friend, a Crito or an Echecrates like the ones who get named in other dialogues, would turn the story into a private exchange between two particular men, and we’d be eavesdropping on it. An empty chair works differently, because anyone who picks up the dialogue ends up sitting in it, so that when Socrates says “my friend,” he’s saying it to you. Plato builds the reader into the scene as the person Socrates trusts enough to hear the embarrassing version, which is a strange kind of compliment from a writer, since it puts us in the position of the one who hears the truth and has to decide what to do with it.

So the unnamed friend is a lot more than decoration, because Plato gives Socrates a listener so that the dialogue can show us, before anyone defines anything, what honest self-report actually sounds like. It sounds like a man telling a buddy that he got flustered by a teenager and nearly lost it on a bench in front of everybody. The definitions of temperance all collapse by the end, but this habit survives the wreckage, and I’d argue that the most practical lesson the Charmides has to offer about knowing yourself is in the way its narrator talks to us, telling on himself first and saving his nudges for the parts that make him look worst.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

What does the contrast between Socrates’ direct addresses during his own embarrassing moments and his narration of Critias’s discomfort most strongly suggest?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.