Philosophy

Socrates Examines Plato’s Family

Charmides was Plato’s uncle and Critias his mother’s cousin. Socrates praises their family’s beauty and talent, then asks them to explain the virtue they’re said to possess.

A celebrated pedigree sets high expectations for Charmides. Socrates’ questions put the family’s reputation for temperance to a different test.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • Plato’s family is in the roomCharmides is Plato’s uncle, and Critias is related through Plato’s mother. Socrates also singles out Pyrilampes in his praise of the family.
  • The praise reaches back to SolonSocrates names the poets who celebrated Charmides’ family. The pedigree helps explain why so much is expected of him before he speaks.
  • The family has to answerCharmides cannot explain a definition he has heard. When Critias takes over, Socrates keeps asking what the words mean.
  • Reputation sets the stakesBeauty and talent can give the family a distinguished name. The dialogue asks what each person understands about temperance for himself.

Charmides Introduction, 154e–155a, 157e–158b, 162c–e, 176b–d · Republic 368a · Parmenides 126a–c, 126b–c · Seventh Letter 324d–325a

The family connections are set out in the edition’s introduction. Critias was the cousin of Plato’s mother, Perictione, and Charmides was her brother, which makes him Plato’s uncle. Pyrilampes, whom Socrates praises as a striking ambassador to the Great King, later married Perictione and became Plato’s stepfather. The dramatic setting is earlier than Plato’s birth. The author stands outside the scene while putting two generations of his own family in the room.

And the family is praised extravagantly, since Socrates tells Charmides that his father’s house has come down celebrated by Anacreon, Solon, and others for beauty and virtue, and that his mother’s side “is no different.” When Critias says his ward is a philosopher and a poet, Socrates replies that “That fine gift, my dear Critias,” has been in the family “a long way back, from your kinship with Solon.” Kinship with Solon, the Athenian lawgiver and poet, gives the compliment some weight.

Yet the same dialogue exposes these relatives’ weaknesses with real precision. Charmides borrows a definition from his guardian and then lets it be refuted while laughing slyly at its author. Critias loses his temper with the boy, retreats from one definition to another, can’t admit he’s stuck and covers up his perplexity in front of the company, and by the end the two of them are plotting to use force. None of this is savage, but none of it is flattering either, and an author defending his family would hardly have shown them this way. Even Critias’ angriest moment is described with a comparison to a poet annoyed at an actor who mangles his verses, which is wry rather than cruel.

A letter attributed to Plato says relatives and acquaintances invited him to take part in the new regime. The author recalls early hopes for it and horror at what followed, especially when the rulers tried to involve Socrates in an unjust arrest. The letter’s authenticity is disputed. In the Charmides itself we can watch the praise and the scrutiny coexist without assigning Plato a private motive for writing the scene.

Plato puts relatives into other dialogues too. Glaucon and Adeimantus are Socrates’ main partners in the Republic, where Socrates praises them with a line of verse about the sons of their father. In the Parmenides, their half-brother Antiphon has learned the account of a conversation involving Socrates, Zeno, and Parmenides and is persuaded to retell it. The family connections take a different shape in each dialogue, depending on what the inquiry needs.

The praise and the exposure coexist because they concern different things. The praise is for inheritance, beauty, pedigree, poetic talent and a famous name, while the exposure is of understanding, what these men actually know about the virtue they’re said to embody. A family can be genuinely distinguished in the first way and still produce members who fail the second test, and the dialogue’s whole argument is that the second test is the one that matters. Socrates’ compliments are real, but they’re compliments about the things a family can hand down, and temperance turns out not to be one of them. The question about temperance puts that illustrious inheritance to a test it can’t answer on its own.

That is perhaps the most pointed thing about the portrait. A family that prided itself on being “beautiful and good,” and whose youngest star was “thought far and away the most temperate of anyone nowadays,” is shown unable to say what temperance is, and its most powerful member is shown unable to admit what he doesn’t know. Plato doesn’t mock his family’s pride, but he examines it, and the examination finds that reputation passed down through generations is no substitute for understanding that has to be won by each person for himself. It’s the lesson the Thracian doctor taught at the start, that the soul has to be treated directly, since no amount of inherited beauty treats it.

My verdict is that the Charmides places Plato’s own family under examination with a mixture of genuine admiration and unsparing clarity, and that it is neither a family defense nor a recoverable confession. The praise honors what the family really had, beauty, talent and a famous lineage, while the argument exposes what it lacked, a grasp of the virtue it was famous for. Plato’s achievement is to let both be true at once, and to show that the closer a subject is to the author, the more the same rule of examination applies.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

How does the article reconcile Socrates’ praise of Plato’s family with the dialogue’s exposure of its members’ shortcomings?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.