Philosophy
Socrates Blames Himself
When the account of temperance fails, Socrates calls himself a poor inquirer. His choice of where to put the blame tells us what he thinks went wrong.
The Platonic Dialogues: CharmidesSocrates keeps his conviction that temperance is good and goes back over the concessions he and Critias made. His self-blame can sound humble, pointed, and stubborn in the space of a few lines.
Orientation
At a Glance
- Socrates takes responsibilityWhen the definition yields no benefit, Socrates blames his own inquiry and says he still thinks temperance is good.
- The shift from I to weSocrates calls himself a poor inquirer and says both men conceded claims their argument had yet to establish.
- Finding the weak pointDuhem’s account of experimental testing helps explain why a failed result can send an investigator back to several assumptions.
- A reason to keep examiningIn the Phaedo, Socrates suggests that disappointment with an argument can prompt a closer look at our own reasoning.
Charmides 165b, 172e–173a, 175a–b, 175b–176a, 176a · Phaedo 89d, 90d, 90e · Pierre Duhem, La Théorie physique Part II, Chapter VI, § II
Critias agrees that the kind of knowledge they’ve been calling temperance can’t benefit them. Socrates asks whether he was right “to blame myself for looking into temperance to no useful purpose.” It’s an odd thing to say just as Critias’s definition gives way. Socrates has been the one asking the questions, and now he suggests that a better questioner would have gotten further. He makes the point again to Charmides a little later. He calls himself “a poor inquirer” and says he still thinks temperance is a great good.
There’s reason to take the self-blame seriously. Earlier Socrates tells Critias that he asks about each proposal because he doesn’t know the answer himself. Later, as they begin to doubt whether the proposed knowledge could do them any good, he says he’s afraid they’ve been looking into it the wrong way. Then he says, “I think I’m talking nonsense,” and insists that they should look at what has come to light anyway. He’s been willing to question his own handling of the argument while there was still time to try another approach.
Listen to the pronouns when he reviews what went wrong. The poor inquirer is I. The people who let the questionable claims through are we. Socrates says they conceded the existence of knowledge of knowledge, and then let that knowledge do work their reasoning had given them no grounds to assign it. He takes responsibility and includes Critias in the accounting. There’s room for a joke in that combination. Socrates even tells Charmides that if he already has temperance, he might consider Socrates a babbler and himself happier the more temperate he is.
The most skeptical reading starts with the little word for. Socrates says he’s a poor inquirer, then explains that he does think temperance is a great good. His conviction leads him to suspect the inquiry. It’s worth asking what would happen if someone used that move every time a conclusion displeased them. They could keep any belief they liked by announcing that the argument must have gone wrong somewhere. Socrates has made it possible to ask a more particular question. Which parts of the argument does he think deserve another look?
The physicist Pierre Duhem offers a way to think about that question. A prediction depends on several assumptions, including ones that let the physicist interpret what the instruments show. If the result goes against the prediction, something in the set of assumptions needs attention. The result alone leaves the physicist to find out where. Socrates isn’t carrying out an experiment, but he faces a comparable problem of diagnosis. His final review names two places where he and Critias agreed to let the account do more than they had established. A new inquiry could start by looking there.
There’s a further clue in the Phaedo. Socrates warns about misology, the hatred of argument. Someone trusts a line of reasoning too readily, loses confidence when it lets him down, and after a few such experiences decides that reasoning itself is hopeless. Socrates suggests a different response. The person might still have things to learn about how to judge an argument. That possibility gives someone who has been disappointed a reason to try again. It also gives the self-blame in the wrestling school a practical point. There are things Socrates and Critias could do more carefully next time.
Each reading catches something in his speech. He has already put his own judgment in question, which makes the humility credible. His move from I to we brings Critias back into the story, and the conditional joke about being a babbler lets Charmides hear it too. His conviction about temperance plainly makes him reluctant to accept the result as the last word. The difference is that he can say what was weak in their test. The two concessions are there for anyone who wants to go back and check them.
The next question goes to Charmides. Socrates tells him to see whether he has temperance and needs the charm. That’s a peculiar way to end a conversation that has failed to define what he’s supposed to look for. It makes the failure harder to dismiss, since the question concerns a person who still has to work out how to live. Socrates has told him where their reasoning fell short. Now he’s asking him to keep looking at something the reasoning has left unresolved.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
Why does the article treat Socrates’ self-blame as more than a merely comic or ironic gesture?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- When does blaming a failed inquiry protect a reasonable conviction, and when does it become a way of insulating a favored belief from criticism?→
- What does Socrates’ shift from “I” to “we” suggest about how responsibility should be shared in a collaborative inquiry?→
- Why might Socrates ask Charmides to continue examining whether he has temperance even though the conversation has failed to define it?→