Philosophy

Self-Control Isn’t the Whole Virtue

Socrates regains his composure in front of the whole gym. Aristotle’s distinction helps us see how much that moment can tell us.

It’s tempting to say Socrates proves he’s temperate by pulling himself together on the bench. The text lets us say something more careful about him, and more interesting.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The recovery on the benchA glimpse of Charmides’ beauty leaves Socrates flustered. He answers anyway, and the boy’s agreement helps him regain his confidence.
  • Aristotle’s distinctionAristotle distinguishes mastering unruly desires from having desires that are already in tune with good judgment. The bench scene looks like a case of the first kind.
  • Two accounts of SocratesIn the Symposium, Alcibiades praises Socrates’ temperance after spending a night beside him. In the Charmides, Socrates tells us how it feels to lose his composure.
  • Temperance remains openThe discussion ends without a definition of temperance. Socrates still calls it a great good and asks Charmides to consider whether he has it.

Charmides 155c–e, 155e–156c, 156d, 158a–b, 175b–176a · Symposium 216d, 219b–d · Aristotle, Nicomachean Ethics 7.9

Here’s the claim, and it’s an attractive one that plenty of good readers have made. Socrates walks into the gym confident, gets knocked flat by the boy’s beauty, sees inside the cloak, catches fire and loses possession of himself, and then, in front of the whole crowd, he remembers a line of poetry, somehow answers the boy’s question, and starts a long, careful conversation. On this reading Socrates shows temperance in action before anybody in the dialogue can say what it is, and the scene is a demonstration that the virtue can be lived before it can be defined.

There’s a lot to be said for it, and it deserves a fair hearing before anyone pokes holes in it. The recovery happens in public, where losing it would be easiest and most embarrassing, and Socrates gets himself back quickly and completely enough to run one of the most demanding conversations in Plato. He even says that when Charmides agreed with him, his boldness “began to gather itself together,” which sounds like a man regaining command of himself, and plenty of readers have taken the whole sequence as a test passed in full view of everyone. It also suits the comedy, since the whole point of telling the story against himself is that Socrates came through it, a little singed but still talking.

The first problem is that the flirtation never actually stops. A couple of pages later Socrates is praising the boy’s looks in the most lavish terms, telling him that “as for what can be seen of your looks,” he falls short of none of his famous ancestors, and at the very end of the dialogue he’s still at it, saying he’s grieved for Charmides, “being such as you are in your looks.” Socrates keeps noticing the boy’s looks and saying so, even as he keeps his mind on the argument. It’s like a man who has sworn off sweets and spends the whole party describing the dessert table, never eating a bite but never quite looking away either.

The second problem is a distinction that Aristotle made famous later. Aristotle separates the self-controlled person, who has strong desires pulling the wrong way and masters them, from the temperate person, whose desires are already in tune with good sense. On that standard what we see on the bench looks a lot more like self-control than temperance, since it’s the picture of a man wrestling an impulse and winning the round. In Aristotle’s terms the self-controlled person deserves real praise, but he’s a step short of the ideal, because part of him is still pulling against the rest.

Compare the Socrates of the Symposium, and the difference gets vivid. There Alcibiades tells how he spent a whole night under one cloak with Socrates and got up, as he puts it, as if he had slept beside a father or an older brother, and earlier in the same speech he describes Socrates as full of temperance inside. Alcibiades sees a man who can turn aside his advances. In the Charmides, Socrates tells us what it feels like to catch fire. The contrast is sharper because we hear the story from a different person each time. Alcibiades can tell us what Socrates did, and in the Charmides Socrates can tell us how he felt.

The third problem is the one Socrates himself would raise first. He makes no claim to have temperance. By the end they still can’t say what it is, and he calls himself “a poor inquirer.” His final advice to the boy, to look into whether he has it, applies to Socrates as much as anyone. Even the man asking the questions has some looking to do.

So what does the recovery show, if not the whole virtue? It shows a piece of it, the ability to get yourself back after being carried away, steadily enough to keep a conversation honest and kind. You can practice part of something long before you can define it, the way a kid can keep her balance on a bike for years before she could explain the physics, but practicing a part isn’t the same as possessing the whole, and the dialogue never lets us forget the difference.

My verdict is that Socrates shows self-control, and the scene gives us a good reason to keep asking about the larger virtue. Later the speakers test a definition that would let a person know what he knows and what he doesn’t, and even with generous concessions they can’t make it work. The bench gives us evidence about Socrates, not proof, and the Charmides is the kind of dialogue that teaches you to tell those two things apart, which may be one of the most useful habits a reader can take away from it.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

Why does the author classify Socrates’ recovery as self-control rather than full temperance?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.