Greek Antiquity

Seeds for the Earth, but Not Beans

Gaia’s offering consists of seeds from the earth, with beans and aromatics expressly left out.

The unusual fumigation gives the worshippers a way to offer the promise of a crop. The two exclusions raise separate questions about a gift that suits Gaia and a possible taboo around beans.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • An offering from the fieldThe rubric calls for seeds, the very things the hymn asks Gaia to bring to fruit.
  • A familiar offering is omittedAromatics are common elsewhere in the collection, so their exclusion makes the offering to Gaia distinctive.
  • The bean has to be namedBeans are seeds, and the rubric specifically excludes them from the otherwise wide instruction.
  • A clue on the Sacred WayPausanias’s account of the hero Kyamites points to a ritual association that helps explain why the article considers a taboo.

Orphic Hymns, XXVI rubric, with its note; XXVI.1–3, 10–11

Most hymns in the collection open with an instruction to burn something fragrant, but the hymn to Gaia opens with a farmer’s list. “Fumigation from every seed except beans and aromatics,” the rubric says, and then the hymn calls on “Gaia goddess, mother of the blessed and of mortal men, / all-nourishing, all-giving,” “fruit-bearing, teeming with fair seasons,” and ends by asking her to “increase the gladdening fruits.” The edition’s note calls the rubric “the collection’s plainest ritual restriction,” adding that it is “an instruction about what may be burnt, not a description of a god,” and the two exclusions in it, aromatics and beans, are what make it worth reading slowly.

Start with the offering itself, which is seed, and only seed. To the goddess of the fruitful earth the worshippers burn grain and seeds, the very things they’ll ask her to multiply, so the offering is the potential harvest given back to the one who grows it. Paul uses the same logic when he writes of the God who supplies seed to the sower and bread for food, and prays that he will “multiply your seed sown, and increase the fruits.” The hymn’s worshippers give Earth seeds and ask her to increase the fruits, an exchange shaped exactly like sowing, where you put seed into the ground and hope to get much more back.

The exclusion of aromatics is, as the note says, “the more curious half,” since aromatics are the commonest offering in the book, burned in twenty-two hymns, so the question is why the obvious choice was left out here. The likeliest answer is that aromatics were imported, the resins and spices of Arabia and the East, luxuries traded across the sea, while seeds were the earth’s own produce from local fields. An offering to Earth made only of what Earth grows here is fitting in a way that frankincense isn’t, like bringing a farmer a basket of his own vegetables cooked well instead of an expensive imported delicacy. The exclusion makes visible that the offering was chosen to match the goddess, not just taken from the usual supply.

Beans are the other exclusion, and they’re a different matter. Beans are seeds, and among the commonest seeds a Greek farmer grew, so “every seed” would naturally include them, which is why the rubric has to rule them out by name. The note explains that the bean prohibition is “the well-known Pythagorean and Orphic taboo,” and points to Aristotle’s list of explanations, preserved by Diogenes Laertius, and to an Orphic verse that ranks eating beans with eating one’s parents’ heads. So the rubric isn’t a farmer’s practical preference, it carries a religious rule into the offering itself.

The note’s third piece of evidence is the most revealing. Pausanias, walking the Sacred Way from Athens to Eleusis, passes a little temple of a hero called Kyamites, the Bean-man, and says he can’t say for certain whether this hero first sowed beans or whether the name was given because people may not attribute the discovery of beans to Demeter. Then he stops short, adding that whoever has seen the rite at Eleusis or read the so-called Orphica knows what he means. That’s about as close as an ancient writer comes to winking, and it ties the bean rule to exactly the world these hymns belong to, the mysteries and the Orphic writings, while keeping its reason secret.

Pausanias’s hint also explains why beans would be out of place in an offering to Earth for good crops. If beans were not Demeter’s gift, if they belonged in some way to a different and darker order, perhaps to the dead, as several ancient explanations suggest, then burning them to the goddess of the fruitful harvest would be offering her something that wasn’t hers. The grain and the other seeds are the earth’s blessings in the ordinary sense, and the beans stand apart from them, which the rubric marks by naming them as the one exception to “every seed.”

It’s important, though, to keep this rubric distinct from the wider evidence about beans. Most of what the ancients say concerns eating beans, the Pythagorean diet and its many explanations, from the beans’ resemblance to the gates of Hades to their use in voting by lot, and the evidence is scattered, late and contradictory. The rubric is about burning beans in one specific rite, and it doesn’t tell us what these worshippers ate or why they avoided beans. It shows only that their offering to Earth excluded them, which is a narrower fact, and a reader shouldn’t pour the whole tangled history of the Pythagorean bean into a single line of ritual instruction. The note itself is careful in just this way, citing the wider evidence for context while calling the rubric an instruction about burning, which is the right level of claim for a single line at the head of a hymn.

My verdict is that the two exclusions make the logic of the offering visible from two directions. Leaving out aromatics shows the offering being matched to the goddess, seeds of her own fields rather than the imported fragrances that served other gods, and leaving out beans shows a religious boundary inside the category of seed, a taboo the Orphic and Eleusinian world knew and kept quiet about. Together they reveal an offering chosen with care, the earth’s own produce minus the one seed that wasn’t hers to receive, burned by people who were asking her to send their fields abundance in return.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

Why does the article describe the seed offering as an exchange shaped like sowing?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.