Renaissance
Second Rank, First Love
Pater wonders whether a painter like Botticelli deserves a critic’s time. His answer is that a smaller reputation can offer a pleasure no great name can supply.
The Renaissance (1893)Pater ends his essay with a test for which artists deserve attention. Botticelli’s growing fame shows both what affectionate criticism can find and what can happen when it changes the rankings.
Orientation
At a Glance
- The critic asks who deserves a publicPater distinguishes the great names of general culture from painters who mainly attract specialists. Botticelli makes him question the division.
- The test is a distinctive pleasureA painter earns attention by doing something a reader or viewer cannot find elsewhere. Importance measured this way need not track fame.
- Affection can sharpen attentionThe critic who feels a painter’s charm may linger over details that an established reputation would never direct anyone to notice.
- A reputation can change the conditionsRuskin’s lectures, museum acquisitions and later scholarship helped bring Botticelli to a wider public. He eventually acquired the very authority that Pater found liberating to look without.
The Renaissance · Sandro Botticelli, a secondary painter and the scope of criticism · Note 110, the question of general criticism · Sandro Botticelli, a name quietly becoming important · Sandro Botticelli, the uncertain engraving attributions · Matthew Arnold, Culture and Anarchy, preface · John Ruskin, Ariadne Florentina, 1872 lectures · Botticelli’s Mystic Nativity, National Gallery, London · Aby Warburg and Botticelli’s reception, UCL Press
Near the end of his essay Pater does something critics rarely do, which is stop and ask whether the subject was worth the trouble. He wonders aloud whether Botticelli, “a secondary painter,” is “a proper subject for general criticism,” and the edition’s note points out that the question belongs to a nineteenth-century ladder of reputation, with a few giants at the top and everybody else filed below as material for specialists. Pater wrote it in 1870, when Botticelli’s name, as he says at the start of the essay, was only “quietly becoming important,” and the fun of reading his answer now is that it sounds like a fan’s defense of a cult band, written a few years before the band got huge.
His map of the art world has two levels to begin with. At the top are the few great painters, “like Michelangelo or Leonardo,” whose work “has become a force in general culture,” partly because they’ve “absorbed into themselves all such workmen as Sandro Botticelli,” the way a superstar’s sound swallows a dozen forgotten session players. Below them are the smaller men, who can be “the proper subjects only of technical or antiquarian treatment,” the business of connoisseurs who date panels and argue over drawings. “General culture” was a loaded phrase in 1870, since Matthew Arnold’s Culture and Anarchy had just described culture as a pursuit of perfection aided by knowing “the best which has been thought and said in the world,” and the question is whether that canon has room for anybody below the peak.
Pater’s answer is to add a category the ladder doesn’t have. “Besides those great men,” he says, there are artists “who have a distinct faculty of their own by which they convey to us a peculiar quality of pleasure which we cannot get elsewhere,” and these “too have their place in general culture.” The test has quietly shifted from size to irreplaceability, from how much an artist contains to whether anyone else can give you what he gives, and that’s a real philosophical move, because it means rank stops being a single scale, the way a world-class orchestra doesn’t make a great blues guitarist redundant, since you can’t buy his sound from them at any price.
The second half of his answer is about the critic, and it’s the more personal part. These artists “must be interpreted to it by those who have felt their charm strongly,” and they’re “often the object of a special diligence and a consideration wholly affectionate, just because there is not about them the stress of a great name and authority.” That last phrase is sharp, because with Michelangelo you’re always looking through three centuries of reverence, while with a smaller name you get to see the work without a crowd standing between you and it, and the affectionate critic, the one who looks longer because nobody told him to, can notice effects the official ranking would never have sent anyone looking for.
Botticelli’s own reception shows the method working almost too well. Pater’s essay, first printed in the Fortnightly Review in 1870, was an early English essay devoted to him, and two years later John Ruskin stood up in Oxford and called him “the greatest Florentine master of engraving,” while in 1878 the National Gallery in London bought his Mystic Nativity. Aby Warburg submitted his dissertation on the Birth of Venus and the Primavera in 1891 and published it in 1893. Herbert Horne’s English monograph followed in 1908. Those two paintings now draw crowds at the Uffizi.
That success complicates Pater’s argument in an interesting way. Ruskin’s praise leaned partly on engravings that Pater, more cautiously, says are Botticelli’s only in a sense, since “his share in them is doubtful,” and the attribution of those engravings has remained a matter for caution, which shows how affection can overshoot, turning love for a painter’s line into a belief that every good line from his city must be his. The diligence Pater praises is the engine of rediscovery, but it’s also the engine of fandom, and fandom has a habit of inflating its object until it’s a great name carrying all the “stress” Pater was glad to escape, which is exactly what happened to Botticelli in the century after him.
So the ranking question deserves a sharper answer than either Pater or his age gave it. The ladder of great and secondary assumes importance is a fixed property of the artist, when Botticelli’s career shows it’s partly a property of attention, something critics, museums and audiences build and can unbuild, since he was famous in the Florence of the 1480s, “little known in the last century,” as Pater says, and famous again by the twentieth. Pater’s real contribution is the criterion he slipped in under the modest question, that what earns an artist a place is a pleasure “we cannot get elsewhere,” which is a test you can run on anyone at any level of fame, without waiting for the market to report the result.
My verdict is that Pater is right that a distinctive pleasure earns a painter a place in general culture, and right that affectionate attention finds what reputation overlooks, but he was wrong to accept the category of secondary painter in the first place, and his own success proves it. The essay that began by half apologizing for Botticelli helped make him one of the great names, which means the hierarchy Pater politely deferred to was a snapshot of who’d been looked at lately rather than a fact about painters. The lesson now cuts the other way, because Botticelli carries the stress of a great name today, and the special diligence Pater recommended is better spent on whoever stands where Botticelli stood in 1870, quietly becoming important while nobody’s watching.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
What fundamental change does Pater make to the standard test of whether an artist belongs in general culture?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- If an artist’s place in general culture depends on offering a pleasure unavailable elsewhere, how could critics judge that distinctiveness without turning personal taste into a universal standard?→
- When does affectionate attention help a critic perceive what established reputation overlooks, and when does that same affection become distorting fandom?→
- If artistic hierarchies are partly snapshots of who has recently received attention, what responsibilities do critics, museums, and audiences have toward artists who remain overlooked?→