Greek Antiquity

Sea Nymphs as Founders of a Mystery

The Nereids’ dance leads to a claim that they revealed the rite of Bakchos and Persephone.

The hymn’s close places Kalliope and Apollo beside the sea nymphs. Their company and the story of Thetis sheltering Dionysos give the surprising claim a setting in older poetry.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The dance has a Bacchic nameThe Greek verb for the Nereids’ reveling belongs to the language of Dionysian worship.
  • Thetis sheltered the godThe Iliad gives the daughters of Nereus a link with Dionysos through the young god’s rescue at sea.
  • Kalliope and Apollo stand beside themTheir presence connects the scene with the singer Orpheus and with another hymn’s account of the Muses revealing the rites.
  • The collection has several beginningsThe Nereids’ claim is one of several accounts in which different divine groups disclose the mystery.

Orphic Hymns, XXIV.1–5, 9–12, with the note on XXIV.10–12

The last three lines of the hymn to the Nereids make a claim nobody sees coming. “For you were the first to show forth the august rite / of well-hallowed Bakchos and of holy Phersephoneia, / with Kalliope the mother, and with lord Apollo.” The edition’s note calls it “An aetiology, and a surprising one,” “the mysteries founded by sea-nymphs,” and it points out that the collection names founders of its rite in several places, each time different ones, the Kouretes, the Muses and Themis among them, so that there are “Four aetiologies of the rite, none aware of the others.” The question here is whether the Nereids are plausible revealers of a mystery, given that the hymn has introduced them as dancers on the waves.

The case that their play prepares the revelation is stronger than it first looks. The Nereids are “dance-players” and, more pointedly, “revelling about the waves,” bakcheuousai, using the very verb for Bacchic worship, the frenzied dance of the god’s followers. So before the hymn ever mentions a rite, it has shown the nymphs doing what Bacchic initiates did, dancing in ecstasy, and the mysteries of the Greek world were full of dance, from the Bacchic revels on the mountains to the dances of women at the well beside the Eleusinian sanctuary. Dancers who already revel like maenads are reasonable candidates to have shown mortals how the rite is done.

There’s also a famous story that links the Nereids directly to Dionysos. In the Iliad, when the Thracian king Lykourgos chased the young Dionysos and his nurses with an ox-goad, the terrified god plunged into the sea, and Thetis, the most famous of the Nereids, took him into her bosom and sheltered him. So the sea nymphs were the god’s refuge in his moment of danger, the ones who knew him when he was hunted and hidden, and that makes them natural keepers of his secrets. A rite of Bakchos revealed by the sisters of the nymph who saved him has a real mythological logic behind it. The god’s ties to the sea don’t end there, either, since his aunt and nurse Ino, in the usual story, leapt into the sea with her son and became the sea-goddess Leukothea, so the waves held more than one of the women who had cared for Dionysos.

The sea setting does complicate the other half of the claim, though. Persephone is a goddess of the earth and the underworld, her story set in a meadow, at Eleusis and in the house of Hades, and nothing in her myth connects her with the sea nymphs. The Bacchic connection runs through Thetis, but there’s no comparable bridge to Persephone, and a reader is entitled to find it odd that dancers of the waves should reveal the mysteries of a goddess of the depths of the earth. The hymn joins the two gods in one rite, which fits Orphic tradition, where Dionysos is often Persephone’s son, but it doesn’t explain why the sea should be the place the joint rite came from.

The companions in the last line change the picture considerably. The Nereids revealed the rite “with Kalliope the mother, and with lord Apollo,” and in the ancient tradition Kalliope, the chief of the Muses, was the mother of Orpheus, while some accounts named Apollo as his father. So the founders’ companions are Orpheus’s own parents, which turns the aetiology into a family story about the singer whose name the collection bears. The rite revealed by the sea nymphs is, on this reading, shown forth in the presence of the parents of Orpheus, and that ties the mysteries to the very tradition the hymns claim to belong to.

Kalliope also links this hymn to another of the founding claims the note mentions. Elsewhere the collection says that the Muses “showed the rites to mortals,” using, as the note points out, “the same verb as here, and in the same tense and person.” Kalliope is a Muse, so the Nereids’ claim and the Muses’ claim meet in her, and the two aetiologies look less like rivals than like overlapping versions of a story in which a company of divine women, sea nymphs and Muses together, first revealed the rite. The other founders, the Kouretes and Themis, remain separate, and the collection never reconciles them.

That multiplicity is worth taking seriously rather than explaining away. A Christian reader may think of how different churches tell the story of their own founding, one tracing itself to Peter, another to Thomas, another to Mark, each honoring a different apostle without denying the others. The hymns seem to work in a similar way, each giving the honor of founding the rite to the powers it is addressing at the moment, so that the Nereids get the credit in their hymn and the Kouretes in theirs. The claim in this hymn is a way of honoring the Nereids, not a history meant to rule out every other.

My verdict is that the Nereids are more plausible revealers than they first seem, because their play is already Bacchic revelry and because their sister Thetis sheltered the young Dionysos in the sea, which gives them a real claim to his secrets. The sea setting complicates the Persephone half of the rite, which has no comparable bridge to the waves, and the hymn doesn’t try to supply one. But the final companions, Kalliope and Apollo, Orpheus’s mother and his reputed father, turn the claim into an Orphic family story, and that, more than anything in the dancing, is what makes sea nymphs fitting founders for the rite of a book that carries Orpheus’s name.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

How does the article interpret the Nereids’ wave-dancing as preparation for their role as revealers of the rite?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.