Philosophy
Refuting Critias or Testing the Argument?
Critias thinks Socrates is trying to win. Socrates asks him to judge what happens to the argument, whoever turns out to be wrong.
The Platonic Dialogues: CharmidesWhat would show that a questioner cares more about the claim than the contest? Plato gives us a few things to watch for, including what happens when the argument stalls.
Orientation
At a Glance
- Critias hears a challengeWhen Socrates asks what temperance knows, Critias takes the question as an attempt to refute him personally.
- A claim they can examine togetherSocrates restates what he takes Critias’ account to imply and asks whether he has understood it before carrying on.
- What happens at an impasseSocrates sets the question of possibility aside for the moment so they can still ask what this kind of knowledge would do.
- The cost of admitting confusionSocrates says Critias is ashamed to acknowledge his perplexity before the company. The audience makes their agreement to pursue the argument harder to keep.
“You are trying to refute me, and letting go of what the argument is about.” Critias says this after Socrates asks what temperance is knowledge of. Calculation deals with odd and even numbers, which are distinct from calculation itself. What can temperance point to in the same way? Critias thinks the question puts his proposal at a disadvantage. Its very point, he says, is that temperance can take itself as an object. He also suspects Socrates already knows that and is pressing the question to catch him out. The conversation is in a crowded wrestling school, and the other people can hear him say it.
Socrates answers that he questions Critias for the same reason he would question himself. He’s afraid of coming to think he knows something he doesn’t. Both of them have something to gain, he says, if they can make the matter clearer. “Just pay attention to the argument itself,” he tells Critias. Then he asks him to state his position again. The invitation changes what would count as success. If the examination shows that a claim fails, both people have learned something, regardless of whose claim it was.
In the Gorgias, Socrates describes how easily a discussion can go the other way. Someone says that a claim is mistaken or unclear, and the speaker hears jealousy or rivalry in the objection. The argument can end in insults, with the audience sorry it ever came. Socrates asks Gorgias whether he belongs to the sort of people who are glad to be corrected as well as glad to correct someone else. His reason is that there’s more to gain by losing one’s own false belief than by removing somebody else’s. That’s a demanding condition to agree to before you know whose belief is at stake.
A declaration like that is easy to make and hard to verify. One thing you can watch is how the questioner handles a claim before objecting to it. Does the speaker get a chance to recognize it in the questioner’s account? Here Socrates draws out what he thinks follows from Critias’ proposal. Temperance would let someone see what they and others know, including the things they mistakenly think they know. He asks Critias whether that’s what he means, and Critias says it is. The exchange gives them a particular claim to investigate together, with room for Critias to correct the account before they go on.
Watch, too, what happens when the argument stops moving. Critias can’t show how the proposed knowledge could exist, so Socrates offers to grant that it’s possible for now. They can still ask what it would accomplish. Granting the point keeps an unresolved question on the table and makes room to consider a separate one. When the inquiry ends without finding the benefit Socrates expected, he says he was right to blame himself for having looked into temperance to no useful purpose. He treats the result as a failure he shares.
Critias’ experience is harder to read. Socrates says that when he showed his own perplexity, Critias caught it like a yawn. He says Critias was accustomed to being admired and felt ashamed to admit that he couldn’t answer in front of the company. That’s Socrates’ account, and it brings us back to the room in which the argument is taking place. A person can accept the idea of shared inquiry at the start and still find it difficult to be seen running out of answers.
The audience matters in the Gorgias too. Gorgias says he’s willing to go on, then wonders aloud if the people listening have other things to do. When they encourage him to continue, he says it would be shameful for him to decline after publicly inviting questions. His reply gives us another way to see the strain on the agreement. The people watching can make it easier to keep talking and harder to admit why you might want to stop. A conversation can be genuinely useful even when its participants have more than one reason to stay in it.
Socrates can make good on part of his promise by giving Critias room to state his claim, allowing the inquiry to continue past a difficulty, and counting the failure as partly his own. The rest depends on whether Critias can acknowledge a mistake with the same people watching who have been accustomed to admiring him. That puts an unexpected weight on the little pause when Critias has nothing clear to say. It’s where he might have been able to ask for help with the argument, if he’d been able to let the room hear that he needed it.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
How does Socrates’ response to Critias redefine success in their exchange?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- If admitting uncertainty is necessary for shared inquiry, what conditions would make such an admission easier when other people are watching?→
- When Socrates temporarily grants an unresolved premise in order to examine its consequences, what does that method reveal—and what might it risk overlooking?→
- How can participants distinguish a sincere attempt to test an argument from a strategic attempt to embarrass the person making it?→