Renaissance
Red Pots, Blue Glaze and an Imagined Influence
Pater imagines Roman redware inspiring Luca’s glaze. The pharmacy jars already made in Florence give us a closer technical comparison.
The Renaissance (1893)The colors of ancient Arezzo appealed to Pater’s imagination. Comparing Roman clay slip with the tin glaze of Florentine pharmacy jars shows the difference between a resemblance and a possible workshop precedent.
Orientation
At a Glance
- Pater imagines a Roman connectionHe says the color of Arezzo’s Roman pots haunted Luca. No surviving account from Luca establishes the connection.
- Red slip and white glaze are different processesThe Arretine surface comes from an iron-rich clay coating. Luca’s white surface uses an opaque glaze that could carry additional colors.
- Florence offers a documented parallelThe hospital of Santa Maria Nuova ordered pharmacy jars with relief blue decoration in 1431. A decade later Luca made a tabernacle for the hospital.
- A precedent can leave the source openThe hospital jars show what Florentine potters could already do. They give the comparison a firm basis while leaving Luca’s own route to the technique uncertain.
The Renaissance · Luca della Robbia, Arezzo’s red pots and the invention of color · Note 128, the Arretine hypothesis · Arretine ceramics and their red slip, Crotone and Sibari archaeological parks · A Valencian example and the history of tin glaze, Metropolitan Museum · A pharmacy jar from the Santa Maria Nuova order, Toledo Museum of Art · Giunta’s workshop and Luca’s hospital commission, Italian Ministry of Culture · Technical study of the Federighi tomb tiles
Pater gives Luca’s invention a family tree, and it’s a romantic one. The fame of oriental pottery, “with its strange, bright colours,” he says, “mingled with the tradition of the old Roman pottery of the neighbourhood,” and “The little red, coral-like jars of Arezzo, dug up in that district from time to time, are much prized.” Then comes the decisive sentence, “These colours haunted Luca’s fancy,” which turns a regional fact into a psychological claim, and the edition’s note is right to flag it as an inference, because nothing Luca wrote or anyone recorded tells us what haunted him, and the claim has to stand or fall on how well the pieces fit.
The local fame is real and old, and Pater is right to call the jars prized. Arezzo was the great center of Roman red-gloss tableware in the age of Augustus, the ware archaeologists call Arretine, sometimes made in molds with crisp relief decoration and makers’ stamps, and distributed widely across the Roman world. Tuscans had been digging it up for centuries, and the thirteenth-century writer Ristoro d’Arezzo described the ancient vases found around his city with open wonder. Vasari, whose family included Arezzo potters, tells in his Lives of an ancestor who studied the old red vases and the ancient kilns near the city, so Pater is drawing on a genuine local legend.
The trouble begins with the technology, which is where the story starts to come apart. Arretine red isn’t a glaze at all but a fine clay slip, fired in an oxygen-rich kiln until it turns glossy and coral-colored, and it has nothing to do with tin, nothing to do with opaque white, and nothing to do with cobalt blue. Luca adapted opaque tin glaze to sculpture and used metal oxides to give it color, so the red ware gives us no direct technical explanation for the white and blue sculpture, even if its colors could have interested him.
Pater’s other source, the “oriental pottery,” has far better support. Tin glazes were developed in the Islamic world, in Abbasid Iraq by the ninth century, and the technique traveled west through Spain, where the potters of Málaga and later Manises near Valencia made lustered wares that rich Tuscan merchant families ordered by the service, with their own coats of arms painted on. Italians called these imports maiolica, apparently after Majorca, the island where the ships stopped, and the word came to mean all tin-glazed pottery, so the line from the East to Florence runs through documented trade rather than through anyone’s imagination. Cobalt blue also belongs to the history of ceramic trade and technique.
The closest precedent was in Florence itself, a short walk from the cathedral workshops. Around 1430 and 1431 the great hospital of Santa Maria Nuova ordered roughly a thousand pharmacy jars from the workshop of Giunta di Tugio and from other local potters, tin-glazed white and decorated with oak leaves and animals in a thick, raised cobalt blue the Florentines called zaffera a rilievo (relief blue), with the hospital’s crutch emblem on the handles of surviving examples. An early documented use of Luca’s glaze appears on a tabernacle commissioned for the same hospital in 1441, so the most skilled tin-glazing in Florence and Luca’s first glazed sculpture stood within a few steps of each other, about a decade apart.
None of that is proof, but it shows what proof would look like. To turn a haunting into a source you’d want documents, an inventory listing Arretine pieces in Luca’s house, a contract with a potter or a note about recipes, and you’d want chemistry, since modern analyses of Luca’s glazes, like the recent study of the tiles on Bishop Federighi’s tomb, can identify colorants and firing methods and compare them with the city’s maiolica. A shared motif or trace of a shared process would make the Roman comparison stronger. The contrast between red slip and white tin glaze shows what still needs to be explained.
It’s easy to see why Pater reached for Arezzo all the same. His whole book is about the revival of antiquity, so a Roman ancestor makes Luca’s invention a rebirth, a buried art coming back to light in the hills where it was made, while a source in Islamic Spain and a hospital pharmacy makes it a story of trade, craft and borrowing. Pater’s word “haunted” is honest about being imaginative, and it fits his method, which often reconstructs an artist’s inner life from the atmosphere around him, but here the atmosphere and the evidence point in different directions.
My verdict is that the Arezzo story works as atmosphere and fails as a source. Tuscans had admired those red Roman pots for centuries, and a sculptor working in fired clay might have known them, but the colors, the chemistry and the purpose all point elsewhere, toward the tin-glazed tradition that came from the Islamic world through Spain and was already flourishing in Florence’s hospital jars. To promote Arezzo from mood to influence would take documents or analysis that nobody has found, and until then Pater’s haunting tells us more about what moved Pater than about what moved Luca.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
Why does the article reject Arretine pottery as a direct technical source for Luca della Robbia’s white-and-blue glazed sculpture?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- When can a historically plausible cultural atmosphere reasonably count as artistic influence, and what additional evidence should be required before making that claim?→
- How does the contrast between Pater’s Roman-revival narrative and the article’s trade-and-borrowing narrative change the meaning assigned to Luca’s innovation?→
- Why might the author accept proximity between Luca and Florentine tin-glazing workshops as significant evidence while still refusing to treat it as proof?→