Renaissance

Reading a Mountain Like a Painting

Pater puts the Mona Lisa, the hills of Carrara, and Pico della Mirandola on the same list. Each asks a critic to pay attention to something different.

A frame holds a painter’s choices in place. Changing light helps shape a landscape, and a translation helps shape the portrait of a person. Pater’s method can handle all three if the critic accounts for what makes each encounter possible.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • One method for three objectsPater’s critic identifies a distinctive effect, then asks what produces it and under what conditions. His examples include a portrait, a mountain landscape, and a historical person.
  • The picture offers fixed detailsA painter fixes the arrangement of figures and the light within the frame. Those choices give viewers shared details to check, even when varnish and gallery lighting affect what they see.
  • The hour changes the landscapeCarrara’s grey peaks can suggest evening even at noon. Pater’s comparison of a French riverbank and a Swiss valley asks how the shape of a place affects what passing light can do.
  • Pico comes through other writersPater encounters Pico partly through his nephew’s biography and Thomas More’s English translation. The critic has to ask how much of the effect comes from the person and how much from the telling.

The list is so casual you can read right past it. Pater’s critic values “the picture, the landscape, the engaging personality in life or in a book,” and then come the examples, “La Gioconda, the hills of Carrara, Pico of Mirandola,” as if a portrait, a mountain range and a man who died in 1494 were the same sort of thing. The edition’s note points out that putting a landscape beside a painting and a historical person widens aesthetic criticism beyond the fine arts, and that’s putting it mildly. A painting hangs still in a frame, the Apuan Alps above Carrara are enormous and change by the hour, and Pico reaches us only through books, his own and other people’s, so the question is whether one method can really handle all three.

The method itself is short enough to carry around. You start by knowing your own impression, then you separate the object’s distinctive power, its virtue, from everything that came along with it, and finally you say where the effect comes from and under what conditions it’s felt. The first step travels everywhere without trouble, because you can have an impression of anything, a sunset or a sonnet or a stranger at a party. The interesting question is what happens to the other two steps when the object stops being a framed rectangle on a wall, and the honest answer is that each kind of object loads the weight onto a different step.

With a painting, the analysis of the object does most of the work. Somebody has already chosen what’s in the frame, fixed the light and arranged the figures, so the critic can point at a finger or a fold of linen and expect the next viewer to find it in the same place tomorrow. Conditions still matter, since varnish yellows and a museum’s lights are not a Florentine palace’s candles, but they matter at the edges. In a picture, the artist has already settled much of what the critic needs to describe. That makes painting a convenient place to learn the method.

A landscape flips that around, because its scale and its changes make the conditions the main event. You can’t see the Apuan Alps whole, you have to walk them, and what they give you depends on the hour, the weather and where you’re standing. Pater shows this beautifully when Carrara turns up again in the Michelangelo chapter, where he describes “those strange grey peaks which even at mid-day convey into any scene from which they are visible something of the solemnity and stillness of evening.” Look at how that sentence works, naming a virtue, solemnity and stillness, and pinning it to its conditions, midday and the bare fact of being visible, and adding that Michelangelo sometimes wandered among them “month after month.” The duration is part of Pater’s picture of how the place got into his work.

The Giorgione essay takes the point further and almost makes the critic of landscape a reader of weather. Pater notes how a sudden effect of light can turn a homely, familiar scene into something “like a picture,” and he says this happens most easily in country with little character of its own, which is why he declares, a little cheekily, “the superiority, for most conditions of the picturesque, of a river-side in France to a Swiss valley.” In Pater’s example, a Swiss valley’s stronger character gives light less room to transform it than a French riverbank does. The critic has to judge what the place offers and what the hour does to it.

With a person, the step that takes over is the separation of the virtue from its adjuncts, because the adjuncts include whoever told you about him. Pater’s phrase admits as much, since he speaks of the engaging personality “in life or in a book,” and Pico comes to him almost entirely in books, through Ficino’s dedication, the Latin life by Pico’s nephew, and Thomas More’s English rendering. The life “seemed worthy,” in Pater’s account, “for some touch of sweetness in it,” of translation. So when Pater feels the charm of Pico, part of what he’s feeling is More’s prose, and a careful critic of a person has to ask how much of the portrait is the sitter and how much is the painter, even when the painter used words.

There’s a serious objection on the other side, and it deserves more than a nod. A landscape has no maker, so its virtue can’t be anybody’s achievement, and a person is not an object at all, so treating Pico as one more source of pleasant impressions looks like a moral mistake, the kind that turns people into exhibits. That’s a fair worry about aestheticism in general, and Pater doesn’t escape it entirely. Still, the method only asks what effect something has and where the effect comes from, and those questions are as reasonable about a mountain or a life as about a canvas, as long as you remember that the life was lived for its own sake and not for yours.

So yes, the same method can read a landscape and a painting, and a person too, but it reads them with different emphasis, putting analysis of the object first for the picture, conditions first for the mountains, and the problem of mediation first for the man. I’d go a step further and say the lesson runs backward as well. Pater’s comparison draws on the powers of natural things, and the landscape may be the method’s real home ground, with the painting as the special case where an artist has already done some of the critic’s choosing, fixing the light and the hour so that the rest of us can find the same virtue in the same place.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

According to the article, which critical emphasis becomes most important when considering Pico as a historical person?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.