Philosophy
Ranking the Knowledges
Socrates offers Critias a list that runs from draughts to medicine. The question is what puts knowledge of good and bad above them all.
The Platonic Dialogues: CharmidesA skill can be demanding, exact, or useful in its own field. Critias has to decide which kind of knowledge could help a person live well.
Orientation
At a Glance
- Socrates changes the questionCritias begins by defending the value of acting with knowledge. Socrates asks what a person would have to know in order to live well.
- Exactness gives a different orderThe Philebus puts arithmetic and measurement high for their exactness. Critias gives medicine more weight when he is asked about happiness.
- What each skill is forAristotle’s example of bridle-making shows how one craft can serve a wider aim. The dialogue asks what would guide those aims in a life.
- Critias names good and badCritias gives knowledge of good and bad the highest place. He still has to show how his account of temperance could supply it.
Charmides 173d–174a, 174a–d, 174d–175a · Republic 374c, 487c · Vatican Museums Exekias’s amphora · Philebus 56a, 57c–d · Aristotle, Nicomachean Ethics I.1, 1094a, I.2, 1094a, I.2, 1094b
Socrates asks Critias to imagine a person who knows everything that has happened, everything happening now, and everything to come. Which of his kinds of knowledge makes him happy? Socrates offers a candidate. “Draughts?” Critias says. “What draughts?” Calculation gets a flat refusal. Knowing what is healthy comes closer. At last, with some prompting, Critias names the knowledge by which a person knows good and bad. He’s been defending the importance of living knowledgeably. The list makes him say which part of all that knowledge he thinks matters most.
Draughts is easy to laugh off in this company, but the game makes a useful first test. In the Republic, Socrates treats draughts and dice as games that take sustained practice to play well. You can also see the seriousness of play in a vase by Exekias, where Achilles and Ajax lean toward each other over a game. The picture gives the players the attention of two people absorbed in what they’re doing. The difficulty of the skill can explain why somebody takes it seriously. Critias has been asked a different question about what it could contribute to a life.
Calculation supplies a second test. In the Philebus, Socrates distinguishes arts that achieve great exactness from practices that leave more to practiced judgment. Medicine falls on the less exact side of the comparison, while arithmetic and measurement rank high. In the Charmides, Critias gives medicine a better chance than calculation of accounting for happiness. The change makes sense once you see what the two conversations are asking. The ability to get an exact answer and the ability to help somebody live well are different things to look for in an art.
Try asking what each skill is for. A good move serves the game. Calculation can serve many activities, from keeping accounts to building a ship, depending on where you apply it. Medicine aims at health, a good that matters to the person whose body it treats. When Critias names good and bad, the question takes in a whole life. Someone has to judge what the healthy body, the accurate accounts, or the well-built ship will help a person do. That gives us a way to read the order of his answers, even though he gives us no rule for it himself.
Aristotle gives a more explicit account of how the aims of crafts can fit together. At the start of the Nicomachean Ethics, bridle-making serves horsemanship, and horsemanship, in the example, serves military strategy. The bridle-maker can tell whether the strap will hold. That’s a necessary piece of knowledge, and the point of having the bridle depends on what the rider needs it for. Aristotle goes on to ask what we would choose for its own sake and treats the human good as the concern of political inquiry. The comparison helps us hear how far Socrates has moved from the first game on his list.
Critias’s tone leaves another possibility open. His reply about draughts sounds impatient, and earlier he quickly rules out work such as cutting leather and working bronze. A reader might hear disdain for the kinds of people who make a living at those trades. The dialogue gives us little to go on about why Critias answers as he does. What Socrates gets him to grant is more specific. A person could exercise real knowledge at the workbench, and there would still be a question about how well that person is living. The question would apply just as well to the person who can afford to buy what the craftsperson makes.
The game makes one more appearance elsewhere in Plato. In the Republic, Adeimantus compares answering Socrates to being hemmed in at draughts. A player gets blocked one move at a time, with words taking the place of counters. Adeimantus doubts that the result of the game settles what is true. That’s a nice complication for this scene. Socrates has asked the questions in a way that gets Critias to name good and bad. Now the two still have to work out what that knowledge has to do with the definition of temperance they were trying to defend.
A person who knows how to win at draughts has a reason to notice the best move. A doctor has a reason to notice what would restore health. Socrates’s list asks what would let either person judge the place of those successes in a life. Critias can see why the question about good and bad should come first when the subject is happiness. He’s put that knowledge at the head of the list. He still owes Socrates an account of how a kind of knowledge concerned with knowledge itself could give a person that judgment.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
Why does the article say Critias can rank medicine above calculation when considering happiness?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- If technical excellence does not by itself determine whether a skill contributes to happiness, what further kind of judgment does the article suggest is needed?→
- Does Socrates's questioning help Critias discover what he believes, or might it merely hem him into a conclusion? How would that affect the argument?→
- Can knowledge of good and bad meaningfully guide specialized skills without mastering their technical details? Why or why not?→