Renaissance

Raised on Chisels and Hammers

Pater traces Michelangelo’s education from a stonecutters’ village to a painter’s workshop and a garden of sculpture. The apprenticeship contract helps separate the training from the origin story.

Vasari gives Michelangelo a joke about taking in chisels with his nurse’s milk. Condivi downplays his debt to Ghirlandaio, while the contract Vasari transcribed establishes the workshop’s place in his training.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The story begins among stonecuttersVasari says Michelangelo’s nurse was married to a stonecutter. He turns the setting into a joke about the boy taking in his tools with her milk.
  • A contract puts him in a painter’s shopIn 1488 his father placed him with Domenico and Davide Ghirlandaio. The agreement specifies three years of training and twenty-four florins in pay.
  • The early biographies emphasize different thingsCondivi acknowledges contact with Ghirlandaio but denies that Michelangelo owed his excellence to him. Vasari quotes the record of the apprenticeship.
  • The garden adds earlier sculpture to his trainingAt San Marco, antique and Renaissance sculpture gave the young artist work to study. Pater makes the garden the third stage of an education.

Every great career eventually gets an origin story, the basketball player who slept with a ball in his crib or the guitarist who grew up sleeping under the mixing desk, and Michelangelo told his own version with a straight face. Vasari reports that he once said, jokingly, that whatever was good in his brain came from the pure air of Arezzo, where he was born, and that he had sucked in the chisels and hammers he worked with along with his nurse’s milk. Pater takes the joke seriously and makes it the first step of a little curriculum, writing that the infant was put out to nurse “at a country-house among the hills of Settignano, where every other inhabitant is a worker in the marble-quarries, and the child early became familiar with that strange first stage in the sculptor’s art.”

That stage is real, though Pater polishes it a bit. Michelangelo’s father owned a small property at Settignano, a few miles outside Florence, and the boy’s wet nurse was the wife of a local stonecutter, but Vasari describes the village’s stone as a hard local sandstone, the gray stone Florentine builders used for columns and doorframes, while Pater calls them marble quarries. The difference matters because Pater’s version makes the beginning of the story sound uncannily like the career that follows.

The second stage is the one Michelangelo later wanted to delete. “To this succeeded the influence of the sweetest and most placid master Florence had yet seen, Domenico Ghirlandajo,” Pater writes, and on this point the surviving documents bear him out completely. On the first of April 1488 Michelangelo’s father signed a contract placing the thirteen-year-old in the workshop of Domenico and his brother Davide for three years, at twenty-four florins spread across the term, with a first payment recorded later that month. The Met’s exhibition account places his contact with the workshop as early as 1487. Ghirlandaio was then frescoing the Tornabuoni Chapel in Santa Maria Novella, so the apprentice watched plaster laid, cartoons transferred and walls painted day after day, which is the exact technique he’d use twenty years later on the Sistine ceiling.

Yet in 1553 Ascanio Condivi’s biography denies that Michelangelo owed his development to Ghirlandaio and describes Ghirlandaio as a man with “the reputation of being a little envious,” who wouldn’t even lend the boy a book of drawings. Vasari, stung by Condivi’s suggestion that he had his facts wrong, answered in his 1568 edition by printing the 1488 contract from the records kept by Ghirlandaio’s son Ridolfo. The contract answers the question of whether he trained there. How much he learned and how much credit he wanted to give his teacher are separate questions.

Pater sides with the contract, and he gives Ghirlandaio the gentlest adjectives in the paragraph. Then comes the third stage, when “at fifteen he was at work among the curiosities of the garden of the Medici, copying and restoring antiques, winning the condescending notice of the great Lorenzo.” The garden near San Marco held Lorenzo de’ Medici’s antique sculpture, with the old sculptor Bertoldo di Giovanni, once a pupil of Donatello, looking after the young men who studied there. The famous story from those years has the boy copying the head of an old faun and giving it a full set of teeth, until Lorenzo teased him that old men never have all their teeth, at which point Michelangelo knocked one out and hollowed the gum so that the loss looked natural. Lorenzo took him into his household, where the boy lived for about two years, until the great man’s death in April 1492 ended the arrangement.

Put the three stages in a row and you get a neat education, the hand trained among stonecutters, the eye trained in a fresco workshop and the memory trained on ancient marbles, a bit like a chef who grew up on a farm, apprenticed in a busy restaurant kitchen and then spent years studying old cookbooks in a library. Pater’s sequence moves from material to method to model, and each stage feeds something he’ll praise later in the essay. The rough first stage of carving looks ahead to his love of half-emergent figures, the “sweetest and most placid” teacher looks ahead to the sweetness he finds inside Michelangelo’s strength, and the garden of antiques looks ahead to the young sculptor who could carve a Cupid convincing enough to be sold as Roman.

That’s also the trouble with origin stories, because they’re written backward from the finished person. Pater picks the details that rhyme with the art he already admires, so the nurse’s milk becomes marble and the placid master becomes a source of sweetness, and Michelangelo himself trimmed the record the other way, cutting Ghirlandaio so that the genius would seem self-made. Every reboot of a superhero changes the origin a little to fit the hero the audience now loves, and Renaissance biographers were doing the same thing with their artists, with Michelangelo writing his own reboot while he was still alive.

So my verdict is that Pater’s account of the apprenticeship is better than Michelangelo’s own, because it keeps the workshop he tried to erase, and the documents prove the workshop happened. The sequence gives us three real settings for his early life. Pater’s account makes them look like a planned education in material, technique and models. What Pater adds is the poetry, a marble village where there was sandstone and a placid master whose placidity conveniently forecasts the essay’s theme, and as long as readers enjoy that poetry knowing what it is, his little curriculum is one of the most persuasive portraits of an education in the whole book.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

Why does the distinction between Settignano’s sandstone and Pater’s marble matter to the article’s argument?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.