Philosophy

Quiet Isn’t the Same as Slow

The word Socrates spends least time on may hold Charmides’ strongest idea about temperance.

Charmides says temperance is doing things quietly, and Socrates responds with example after example of speed being better than slowness. Charmides never said slow, so is Socrates cheating, and what would a stronger version of the boy’s answer say?

Orientation

At a Glance

  • Two parts to the answerCharmides describes temperance as doing things in an orderly way and quietly.
  • A change of termsSocrates starts by contrasting speed with quietness, then asks whether reading quickly is finer than reading slowly.
  • Composure at any paceThe examples show that speed can be admirable and leave open the possibility of acting quickly with self-command.
  • Order and harmonyThe Gorgias and Republic connect temperance with order, while the Statesman brings vigorous and restrained characters together.

Charmides 159b–d, 159d–160b, 160b–e · Gorgias 506e–507a · Republic 430e–432a, 442c–d · Statesman 306e–307c, 309b, 311b–c

The boy’s word is worth slowing down for, since the whole refutation turns on it. Charmides says temperance is doing everything “in an orderly way and quietly,” and the Greek word behind “quietly,” hēsychēi (ἡσυχῇ), can suggest moving calmly or gently, as a well-raised boy might walk down the street. Socrates’ first question sets that word against speed, asking whether it’s finer at the writing-master’s to copy out the letters “quickly, or quietly,” and his very next question slips in a word Charmides never used at all, asking whether reading is better done “Quickly, or slowly?”

That little substitution is the heart of the matter, because quiet and slow aren’t the same thing at all. A calm surgeon can work very fast, a composed point guard can push the tempo all game long, and the quietest person in a crisis is often the one moving most efficiently while everybody else panics. By sliding from calm to slow, Socrates gets a much easier target, since almost nobody thinks slowness is a virtue in itself, and he runs through examples, from lyre playing and boxing to learning and remembering, showing that quick is usually finer than slow. Charmides agrees every time, and by the end his quiet way of doing things has been judged largely by its speed.

There’s a defense of Socrates, and it deserves a fair hearing. Quiet movement can suggest an unhurried pace as well as a calm manner, so the ambiguity was arguably already sitting in the boy’s answer, and Charmides himself illustrated temperance with walking and talking, activities where tempo is very much part of the picture, since when you say a boy walks quietly through the streets, you probably do mean he doesn’t run. On that reading Socrates is pressing on an ambiguity already present in the boy’s examples. Charmides goes along with the comparisons, so the two never have to settle which sense he meant.

Notice what Socrates leaves out of the examples. The boy said “in an orderly way” as well as “quietly,” and nothing in the comparison of fast and slow tests orderliness on its own. In the Gorgias, Socrates argues that a soul with its own proper order is a good soul and that the orderly soul is the temperate one, and in the Republic temperance becomes a kind of order and harmony in which every part of the soul agrees about who should be in charge. The half of the boy’s answer that gets less attention here comes into focus in those dialogues.

A stronger version of the definition would build on that half. Temperance, it might say, is acting from a settled and orderly state, calm and composed, never hurried along by appetite or panic, whether the task in front of you calls for speed or for patience. On that version Socrates’ examples stop landing, because you can write quickly and calmly, learn fast without being frantic, and win a wrestling match without losing your head, so the speed of the action drops out of the picture and the composure of the person acting becomes the whole point. Think of the difference between an athlete who’s fast and an athlete who’s fast and never rattled, since only the second one is showing anything like self-command.

The boy’s intuition gets another hearing in the Statesman. There, a visitor from Elea describes two kinds of temperament, one quick, vigorous and intense, which people praise as courage, and one quiet, gentle and slow, which people praise as orderly and moderate, and he argues that each turns into a vice when it goes too far for the occasion, the first becoming violent and the second sluggish. A good statesman, he says, weaves the two kinds of people together like warp and woof in a cloth, so the old association between quietness and temperance has a place in the comparison, with a warning about what happens when quietness goes too far.

So is Socrates cheating in the Charmides, or teaching? He presses the part of the boy’s answer that is easiest to test, and he may have a teaching reason for it. The boy described temperance entirely from the outside, as a manner, and the fastest way to show him that a manner can’t be a virtue is to show the manner failing in obvious cases. The very next thing Socrates does is ask him to look within himself and consider what sort of person temperance makes him. Charmides never gets to defend “orderly” on its own. He does get a chance to move from describing a manner to thinking about a character.

My verdict is that Socrates exploits a real ambiguity, leaves the better half of the answer largely untested, and still makes a fair point. Temperance can’t be a tempo. He leaves the stronger version, temperance as calm and orderly self-command, lying on the table for readers to pick up, and the Gorgias and the Republic give us ways to think it through. The page of examples about fast and slow is less a refutation of the boy’s insight than a demonstration that he hadn’t yet found the words for it, and finding the words for what you half see is pretty much what the rest of the dialogue is trying to teach him.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

What verbal shift does the article identify as central to Socrates’ refutation of Charmides?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.