Renaissance

Put the Book Down and Look at the Hand

A hand on a musician’s shoulder is a small test of Pater’s way of looking.

The Diotimos introduction asks readers to look at a Venetian concert before reading Pater’s account. Trying the same exercise with Pico’s speech shows where Pater’s eye is sharp and where his expectations take over.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • Look before readingThe Diotimos introduction turns Pater’s advice about knowing your own impression into an exercise. Look at the painting before reading his description.
  • The hand on the shoulderPater notices the finger, plume, and linen in The Concert. The touch on the player’s shoulder and the turn of his head suggest an interruption that his description passes over.
  • Pico ranks his reasonsPico gives human beings the power to shape what they become. The traditional accounts of humanity as the bond of the world are important but secondary in his speech.
  • What survives a second lookLooking first makes it easier to tell which of Pater’s observations survive a return to the evidence. His eye for painted details often fares better than his account of Pico’s argument.

Most introductions want to tell you what to think before you look at anything, but this one sends you off the page under a heading that sounds like an order from a museum guard, “Look at the hand.” It points you to The Concert, a Venetian picture of three musicians, and asks you to study the details Pater singles out “before reading his account of what the painting makes audible.” That’s a wild instruction in an edition of Pater, a writer so good at describing pictures that readers often see his sentence where the canvas should be. It also follows Pater’s own rule, because his Preface says the first step in criticism is “to know one’s own impression as it really is,” and you can’t do that with a painting if his impression got there first.

So look first, and you’ll see three men standing close together against a dark ground, where the one in the middle, in a dark, fur-trimmed robe, has his hands on the keys of a keyboard while his head is turned hard to his left. He’s turning toward an older, bald man in a black cape over white linen, who holds a viol by its neck and rests his other hand on the player’s shoulder, while on the far left a long-haired young man in a feathered cap looks straight out at you. The introduction puts it plainly, “The musician in the middle turns his head, and the man behind him touches his shoulder,” and that touch and that turn are the event of the picture, a detail that makes the scene look like an interrupted concert.

Now read Pater, who gives you “a monk, with cowl and tonsure,” at the keys, “a clerk, placed behind him,” who “grasps the handle of a viol,” and “a third, with cap and plume,” who “seems to wait upon the true interval for beginning to sing.” Then he praises “the outline of the lifted finger, the trace of the plume, the very threads of the fine linen,” and every one of those is legit and right there in the paint. What he never mentions is the hand on the shoulder or the head swung away from the keys. His sentence hands each man a part in the music and holds the whole room on a breath before the singing starts, with “the waves of wandering sound” fixed “on the lips and hands,” so Pater hears a concert while the picture shows somebody breaking into one.

The exercise doesn’t make Pater look bad, because his details survive and only his arrangement of them and his name for the painter fall away. He calls the picture “undoubtedly Giorgione’s,” and the Uffizi attributes it to the young Titian, and the finger, plume and linen never depended on whose hand made them. Looking first also shows something funnier, that the gesture Pater skipped fits his own theory better than his description does. A few pages later he praises the Giorgione school for arresting “the sudden act, the rapid transition of thought, the passing expression,” and you’d struggle to find a better example of all of it than a player who turns from his keys at a touch on the shoulder.

The introduction’s second exercise does the same thing to a text, asking you to read Pater’s account of Pico’s planned debate “alongside Diotimos’s research on the speech later called the Oration on the Dignity of Man,” so try it with the speech first. The Diotimos research note supplies the background to the canceled debate. Pico was about twenty-three when he wrote it to open a public defense of nine hundred theses in Rome, a papal commission went after thirteen of those theses, the debate never happened, and the speech was never given. Even the title about human dignity was added after his death. Pater treats “the oration which Pico composed for the opening of this philosophical tournament” as having a settled subject, “the dignity of human nature, the greatness of man.”

Then read the speech, where early on Pico runs through the reasons people usually give for human greatness, that man is the go-between of creatures, the interpreter of nature, and, as the Persians say, the bond of the world, and he says of the lot magna haec quidem, sed non principalia, “great things, certainly, but not the principal ones.” The principal one is that God gave Adam no fixed seat and no face of his own, so that he could sink toward the beasts or rise toward the angels by his own choosing. Pater, meanwhile, builds Pico’s theory of dignity on man placed in the midst of things as “nodus et vinculum mundi, the bond or copula of the world,” and as the “interpreter of nature,” which is the very list Pico waved off before getting to his point.

Pater even notices that Pico calls the little-world idea “a commonplace of the schools,” and yet he says Bacon’s phrase about the interpreter of nature “really belongs to Pico,” when in the speech it belongs to the many people Pico is setting aside. Then he calls Pico’s theory “founded on a misconception” about the earth’s place in the cosmos, which is a fair hit on medieval astronomy and a miss on Pico, whose big idea in the speech is that man has no fixed place at all. Even granting the edition’s point that this freedom is a ladder toward the angels rather than a modern self-made man, it’s the most Renaissance thing in the speech by Pater’s own lights, and he walked right past it.

Run the two experiments in the editors’ order and they come out opposite, which is exactly why they’re worth running. With the painting Pater’s eye holds up and only his story and his attribution fall away, while with the speech his source argues against him, because he read Pico through what he expected a fifteenth-century mind to believe about a small, centered world. My verdict is that the introduction’s “look first” is no dig at Pater, since it’s his own Preface turned back on him, and it shows him at his most trustworthy where he stood in front of something and looked hard, and at his shakiest where he already knew what a period was supposed to think. Read him second and he’s a superb guide to linen and fingers you’d have rushed past, but read him first and he can quietly become the thing you think you saw.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

How does Pater’s account most significantly change the apparent event depicted in The Concert?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.