Greek Antiquity

Praying to the Goddess Who Hands Out Poverty

The hymn asks Fortune for abundance immediately after naming the poverty she gives others.

Tyche governs the varied livelihoods of mortals. The speaker asks for a fortunate share, and the repeated opening and closing phrase shows how closely that request fits the goddess’s office.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • Unequal sharesTyche fashions an abundance of goods for some people and gives bitter poverty to others.
  • The goddess’s angerThe hymn connects poverty with Tyche’s anger and gives no account of what the people who receive it have done.
  • A repeated phraseThe expression about possessions of good fortune closes both the opening address and the final request.
  • The scope of the prayerThe article compares the speaker’s request for personal abundance with biblical prayers for daily bread and enough to live on.

Orphic Hymns, LXXII.1–2, 6–10, with the note on LXXII.2, 10

The second half of the hymn to Tyche begins with a blunt piece of theology. “For in you the livelihood of mortals is all-various,” it says, and then it spells out what that variety means, “to some you fashion an abundance of goods, rich in blessing, / to others evil poverty, stirring anger in your heart.” The very next line is the prayer, “But, goddess, I beseech you to come kindly to my life, / abounding in blessings, over possessions of good fortune.” It has the shape of a lottery player’s prayer, offered by someone who knows perfectly well that most tickets lose and asks only that his be the one that wins.

What strikes me first is the hymn’s candor, since it offers no explanation for why some are rich and others poor, says nothing about desert, and makes poverty the product of the goddess’s own anger rather than of anything the poor have done. Theognis complained about the same arrangement in one of his elegies, asking Zeus how he can hold the wicked and the just in equal esteem, but the hymn does not complain at all. It accepts the unequal distribution as simply what Fortune is, and the edition’s note shows how tightly the request is tied to her nature, since the phrase about possessions of good fortune closes both the second line and the last, so that “what is asked for at the end is what she was named for at the beginning.”

The case against the petition is easy to make. It contains no word for the poor beyond the admission that they exist, no request that the goddess spare anyone else, and no request for justice, and it asks for more than enough, since the speaker wants to be “abounding in blessings.” The Lord’s Prayer asks for daily bread in the plural, for us and not for me, and the sayings of Agur in Proverbs go further, asking God for neither poverty nor riches, lest the speaker be full and deny him, or be poor and steal. Set beside those prayers, the hymn looks like a request to be on the right side of an unfair system without wishing the system any fairer.

The case for the petition is that it is honest about what Fortune can be asked. Tyche is a goddess of shares and not of deserts, and the hymn has just said that her shares are unequal by nature, so asking her to make them equal would be like asking the weather to be fair. The speaker’s request is the only kind Fortune can grant, a request for a share, and it is made with a kind of humility, since he claims no merit and simply beseeches. The English says my life, though the Greek has no possessive and asks only that she come kindly to life, so the prayer stays personal without boasting of any special claim on her.

The anger in line 8 sharpens what is being asked. Poverty comes, the hymn says, when Tyche stirs up anger in her heart, and the word in the prayer is “kindly,” the natural opposite of that anger, so the petition is less a request for wealth as such than a request to escape her wrath. Hannah’s song in the first book of Samuel says the same thing about the God of Israel, that the Lord makes poor and makes rich, brings low and lifts up, but Hannah goes on to say that he raises the poor out of the dust and the beggar from the dunghill, a turn toward the poor that the Tyche hymn never makes.

Greek prayers for wealth did not have to be as bare as this one. Solon, in his long elegy to the Muses, asks the gods for prosperity but adds at once that he wants wealth only if it is justly gained, because unjust wealth brings ruin in its train, and Hesiod tells his brother that wealth should not be seized, since god-given wealth is far better. Both put a moral limit inside the request itself. The Orphic hymn puts no such limit in, and the omission is telling, because the hymn is addressing a power whose gifts have nothing to do with justice, and limits of that kind belong to prayers addressed to Zeus or the Muses.

That is why the intimacy of the prayer is real but also narrow. It is the intimacy of someone who speaks to Fortune directly, without pretending she is something she is not, and who asks her to come close to his own life in her kindly mood rather than her angry one. It is narrow because Fortune cannot be asked to care about anyone else, and a worshipper who wanted to pray for the poor would have to turn to another hymn and another power, to Dike or to Nomos, whose business is fairness and not luck.

My verdict is that the petition is honest and limited, and that its limit belongs to the goddess and not to the speaker. A goddess of shares can only be asked for a share, and the hymn asks for one without dressing it up as justice or pretending that Fortune is kind to everyone. That candor is the hymn’s strength, since it names the poverty Tyche hands out and still dares to approach her, but it also shows why the biblical prayers sound so different, because they are addressed to a God who can be asked for daily bread and justice for the poor in the same breath.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

Why does the author regard the speaker’s request to Tyche as humble despite its desire for abundant blessings?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.