Renaissance

Points for Asking the Question

Pater credits the Renaissance with asking how religions fit together. The answer he admires belongs to a different question.

Pico wanted to know whether apparently opposed traditions shared a truth. Pater’s modern historian asks how different beliefs arose and what they meant to the people who held them.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • Credit for a beginningPater praises the Renaissance for the questions it saw before later scholars had the means to answer them.
  • Pico’s questionPico wants to know whether thinkers from different traditions can be understood as speaking a common truth.
  • The historian’s questionPater’s later scholar tries to understand why each belief arose and what part it played in its own age.
  • An unfinished designHistorical explanation can make rival beliefs intelligible together while leaving Pico’s question about shared truth open.

Right after Heine’s empty grave, Pater gives a judgment on the whole period that sounds like a teacher grading a brilliant, disorganized student. “The Renaissance of the fifteenth century was, in many things, great rather by what it designed than by what it achieved,” he says, and much of what it “aspired to do, and did but imperfectly or mistakenly, was accomplished in what is called the éclaircissement of the eighteenth century, or in our own generation,” meaning the Enlightenment, the great clarification, and Pater’s own Victorian age. So what does the fifteenth century get to keep for itself? Only “the leading instinct, the curiosity, the initiatory idea,” which is to say the opening move, the question asked before anybody was in a position to answer it.

That’s a real theory of historical credit, and it has a familiar shape. Mathematicians still call it Fermat’s Last Theorem, after the seventeenth-century French lawyer who scribbled in a margin around 1637 that he had a marvelous proof the margin was too small to hold, although no proof by Fermat is known. Andrew Wiles’s proof appeared in 1995 with a companion paper he wrote with Richard Taylor. We honor the person who saw the question, and Pater wants the fifteenth century honored the same way, as the age that first felt the need to reconcile the religion of antiquity with the religion of Christ and couldn’t yet do it properly. It’s a generous arrangement, and it explains how he can be so tough on Pico’s methods while still writing a whole chapter in his honor.

The trouble starts when you look at what the later age actually achieved, because Pater’s modern scholar doesn’t reconcile the religions in Pico’s sense at all. He observes that “all religions may be regarded as natural products,” that they “arise spontaneously out of the human mind,” and that “every intellectual product must be judged from the point of view of the age and the people in which it was produced,” and the peace he offers comes from treating them as stages, the way “the fancies of childhood and the thoughts of old age meet and are laid to rest” in a single life. The fifteenth century, by contrast, “lacked the very rudiments of the historic sense,” and Pater even puts the word “educated” in quotation marks, which recalls Lessing’s Education of the Human Race of 1780 and its image of humanity being educated through successive religious dispensations.

Now compare what Pico was trying to do, which Pater describes himself, and not kindly. The fifteenth-century scholars wanted the religions reconciled “not as successive stages in a regular development of the religious sense, but as subsisting side by side, and substantially in agreement with one another,” so for them the question was whether Plato, Moses and the Kabbalists were telling the same truth. The modern scholar’s question is where each belief came from and what need it served in its own time, and his answer reconciles the religions by explaining them, which means none of them has to be true for the reconciliation to work. That isn’t a better answer to Pico’s question so much as a polite decision to stop asking it, and it changes what the word reconciliation means.

Pater half admits this in a sentence tucked into Pico’s biography. Describing Pico’s arrival in Florence, he calls him “an early instance of those who, after following the vain hope of an impossible reconciliation from system to system, have at last fallen back unsatisfied on the simplicities of their childhood’s belief.” Notice the adjective, because a design that later ages fulfilled can’t also be impossible, so Pater is running two accounts at once, one in which the fifteenth century started a job the nineteenth finished, and another in which the job Pico wanted done can never be done by anybody. The second account is the truer one, and once you’ve seen it, it quietly undoes the tidy credit scheme of the first.

When Pater returns to the theme near the end, the substitution becomes plain. “I said that the Renaissance of the fifteenth century was, in many things, great rather by what it designed or aspired to do, than by what it actually achieved,” he repeats, and then he says a later age conceived “the true method of effecting a scientific reconciliation of Christian sentiment with the imagery, the legends, the theories about the world, of pagan poetry and philosophy.” Look at what’s being reconciled now, because it’s no longer two claims to truth but a sentiment on one side and a set of images on the other, and of course you can reconcile a feeling with a picture, since neither one is trying to win an argument. The scientific method in this sentence reconciles the religions the way a museum does, by giving each one a room and a label.

This changes how we should weigh Pico, because if his importance were that he got there first on a road the Victorians finished, he’d be a footnote, an early adopter of an idea done better later, the way nobody reads the rough draft once the book is out. Pater clearly doesn’t believe that, because his final paragraph moves Pico’s value somewhere else entirely, saying that “while his actual work has passed away, yet his own qualities are still active,” and that what drove him was the belief, as Pater puts it, that “there was a spirit of order and beauty in knowledge, which would come down and unite what men’s ignorance had divided.” That hope is Pico’s question in its purest form, and no amount of historical method has answered it.

My verdict is that Pater’s praise of the unfinished is right and his bookkeeping is wrong. The fifteenth century deserves credit for its design, but not because later ages completed it, since what the Enlightenment and the Victorians built was a different house, a history of religions that explains every belief and asks none of them to be true. Pico’s design, a single truth that every tradition was trying to say, is still unbuilt and possibly unbuildable, which is exactly why his name keeps its interest while the confident Victorian ladder of stages now looks like a staircase built to put the Victorians at the top. Like Fermat’s theorem before Wiles, Pico’s question is the thing worth naming him for, with the difference that nobody has come along to prove it.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

According to the article, what is the central difference between Pico’s reconciliation and the modern scholar’s reconciliation of religions?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.