Philosophy
Perplexity Is Catching
Socrates says Critias caught his perplexity like a yawn. The two men differ in how willing they are to let the room see that they’re stuck.
The Platonic Dialogues: CharmidesCritias catches Socrates’ uncertainty, or so Socrates tells it. When he gives no clear answer, Socrates finds a way to keep their inquiry going.
Orientation
At a Glance
- A yawn across the roomSocrates says Critias seemed to catch his perplexity the way someone catches a yawn from a person opposite him. The comparison makes getting stuck look ordinary.
- The narrator has been caught tooEarlier, Socrates used the language of being caught for his own loss of composure at the sight of Charmides. Now he describes Critias as caught by a difficulty in the argument.
- Another image of shared uncertaintyIn the Meno, Socrates accepts the comparison with a numbing fish only if the fish is itself numb. He presents his own uncertainty as part of what others experience when he questions them.
- Letting the question stay openSocrates acknowledges the difficulty and provisionally grants the point they can’t settle. That gives them another question to work on together.
Charmides 155d–e, 169a–d · Meno 80a–d · Aristotelian Problems book 7, opening problems
Socrates has been asking which things can turn their powers on themselves. He ends with a confession, telling Critias, “I, for my part, don’t trust myself to be capable of making these distinctions.” Then he hands the problem over, asking Critias to show first that such a knowledge is possible and then that it would do us any good. What happens next, Socrates tells us, “was like people who catch a yawn from those they see yawning opposite them,” since Critias “too seemed to me to be forced by my perplexity to be caught by perplexity himself.” It’s a funny picture. The two men who have kept the conversation going are suddenly stuck together.
The collection of Problems transmitted under Aristotle’s name asks why people yawn when they see others yawning. It treats the sight of someone else’s yawn as enough, under the right conditions, to set off a response. You can see why the comparison appealed to Socrates. Catching a yawn feels like something that happens to you. Critias has been listening to a problem he thought he could solve. On Socrates’ telling, the difficulty has now got hold of him too.
The word “caught” has already done work in this story. When Socrates glimpsed inside Charmides’ cloak, he said he “felt I had been caught by just such a creature myself.” He was thinking of Cydias’ warning about a fawn coming before a lion. The image at the other end of the exchange is gentler. Critias sits opposite a man who has just admitted his limits, and Socrates pictures him doing what people do across a table when one of them yawns. The language of being caught survives the change in scene.
Plato uses a similar image in the Meno, where it has a sharper edge. Meno, tied in knots by Socrates’ questions, compares him to the torpedo fish, the ray that numbs anyone who touches it. Socrates accepts the comparison on the condition that the fish is numb itself. He says he makes other people perplexed because he’s perplexed. The yawn in the Charmides makes the same point with an ordinary gesture. What Critias seems to catch is something Socrates has already admitted to having.
Uncertainty in public is a different experience from uncertainty in private. Getting stuck on a crossword at the kitchen table is one thing. Getting stuck at a whiteboard while people are waiting for an answer can change how you feel about admitting it. Socrates says Critias was used to being admired and felt ashamed in front of the company. That is the narrator’s reading of the moment. Even if we leave Critias’ motives open, we can see the social difference between saying you’re stuck and leaving the room to guess.
What separates the two men is what they do once the difficulty is in view. Socrates tells everyone that he doesn’t trust himself to make the distinctions. Critias gives no clear reply and, as Socrates reports it, keeps covering up his perplexity. Think of someone stifling a yawn behind a hand in polite company. The hand changes what everyone can see. It does very little about the yawn.
Socrates then makes an offer that changes what the room has to do. They can grant for now that knowledge of knowledge is possible, ask what difference it would make, and leave the first question for another time. The offer depends on identifying exactly where they’re stuck. Without that, they might go on taking turns trying to look as though the difficulty had passed. Now they can name what they are granting and find out what follows.
My verdict is that the yawn image makes getting stuck look like part of paying attention. It’s hardly a reproach to Critias that Socrates’ problem gets hold of him. The telling difference is what happens once both men feel its pull. A hand over the mouth may help a man look composed. The person who lets the room see the difficulty gives everyone else a chance to do something with it.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
According to the article, what is the central similarity between the torpedo-fish image in the Meno and the yawn image in the Charmides?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- If perplexity can be evidence that someone is paying attention, how should that change the way participants judge moments when a discussion becomes stuck?→
- Why might publicly naming an unresolved difficulty help a group reason better than trying to maintain an appearance of understanding?→
- Is Socrates’ decision to grant a disputed premise temporarily an intellectually honest way to advance inquiry? What would distinguish a useful provisional assumption from an evasion?→