Renaissance
Pater Builds the Bookends Last
Two medieval French tales open the book. A later chapter on Joachim du Bellay returns to France and shows why Pater chose them.
The Renaissance (1893)Pater places medieval French writing at the opening and gives the French Renaissance a late chapter of its own. Reading those passages together shows what the arrangement reveals about continuity and how a book’s design can make that continuity feel inevitable.
Orientation
At a Glance
- A deliberate openingPater says he chose two medieval French tales to give the series unity. He admits they may not be the strongest examples of an early Renaissance.
- France at both ends of the storyThe opening finds a rebirth within the Middle Ages. The du Bellay chapter finds medieval life still present in the French Renaissance.
- The dates show the work of arrangementPater composed the two French essays in 1872, after essays such as Winckelmann and Leonardo. The newer chapters help give the older material a shape.
- The frame leaves room for a codaWinckelmann and the Conclusion follow du Bellay. They extend the book beyond its French frame and make clear that Pater is arranging a series of studies.
The Renaissance · Preface, pp. 4–5 · Preface, note 14 · Two Early French Stories, p. 7 · Two Early French Stories, pp. 7–8 · Joachim du Bellay, p. 102
Historians don’t usually tell you that they picked their opening example for the look of the book, but Pater does. He says he has chosen “two little compositions in early French; not because they constitute the best possible expression” of the medieval Renaissance he has in mind, “but because they help the unity of my series, inasmuch as the Renaissance ends also in France, in French poetry, in a phase of which the writings of Joachim du Bellay are in many ways the most perfect illustration.” That’s a writer saying out loud that the shape of his book guided his choice of evidence, and it raises a fair question about what an arrangement can achieve and what it costs when a book’s design starts making historical decisions.
The two compositions are Amis and Amile, a tale of friendship so loyal it borders on the uncanny, and Aucassin and Nicolette, a love story that alternates sung verse and spoken prose. In 1873 the chapter was simply called “Aucassin and Nicolette,” and from 1877 it became “Two Early French Stories.” Now look at the dates Pater printed at the end of the chapters. Winckelmann is dated 1867 and Leonardo 1869, but the French stories and du Bellay, the two ends of the frame, are both dated 1872, the year before the book came out. As the chronology of Pater’s writing shows, he had already written several studies when he wrote the two French essays. Those later chapters helped give the earlier work its shape.
The frame achieves something you can see right away, because the first chapter opens by announcing the book’s ending. “The history of the Renaissance ends in France, and carries us away from Italy to the beautiful cities of the country of the Loire. But it was in France also, in a very important sense, that the Renaissance had begun.” Then, near the end, the du Bellay chapter describes the French Renaissance as “not so much the introduction of a wholly new taste ready-made from Italy, but rather the finest and subtlest phase of the middle age itself, its last fleeting splendour and temperate Saint Martin’s summer,” the warm spell that sometimes comes in November around Saint Martin’s day, what Americans call an Indian summer.
Put those two passages side by side and you can see the frame is a mirror. At the start there’s a Renaissance hidden inside the Middle Ages, and near the end there’s a Middle Ages lingering inside the Renaissance, so the Italian chapters in between become the high noon of a long day that begins with a French spring and ends with a French Indian summer. That symmetry is an argument and not just decoration. It says the Renaissance didn’t arrive from Italy and cancel the Middle Ages but grew out of them and faded back into them, and Pater says as much when he praises the theory of a medieval Renaissance for “healing that rupture between the middle age and the Renaissance which has so often been exaggerated.”
The stakes show up once you notice that when you choose your first and last examples so that they rhyme, the history is going to rhyme, and the rhyme can start doing work that the evidence never did. It’s like a documentary editor who picks the opening and closing shots so the film comes full circle, which leaves the audience feeling that the story itself was circular. A careful reader should ask whether other evidence would make the same shape, and Pater’s own book gives a reason for doubt, since it doesn’t actually end in France. After du Bellay comes Winckelmann in Germany and then the Conclusion, so the unity his sentence promises is looser than the sentence implies.
What saves the arrangement from being a trick is that Pater tells you about it. By admitting that the French stories are not “the best possible expression” of what he means, he hands you the tool for discounting the effect, which is more than most books do with their design. He also never pretends to be writing a survey. He calls his chapters studies and his book a series, the way a musician might call a record a suite, so the reader is warned that the order of the pieces is part of what the book is saying, and that the order was chosen. That warning is a kind of respect, since it treats the reader as someone who can enjoy a design and still think about whether the design is true.
The choice pays off in mood as well as argument. The opening chapter sets the key for much of what follows, describing the moment when “the rude strength of the middle age turns to sweetness,” and that turn toward sweetness, a refinement growing out of something rough, keeps coming back in later chapters in different forms. Starting the book with two small French tales lets Pater sound that note quietly and early, before the big Italian names arrive, much as a good album opens with a track that isn’t the single but tells you what kind of record you’re listening to, so that by the time the hits arrive you already know how to hear them.
So what did the choice achieve, and what was at stake? It achieved a thesis about continuity, carried by a mirror-shaped frame in which the Middle Ages and the Renaissance flow into each other at both ends, and it gave the book a musical shape. The risk was that the shape would do the arguing, making the history rhyme because the book was built to rhyme. Pater’s candor and his German coda keep it honest enough. I’d read the book as an essayist’s composition with a declared design and enjoy how deliberately the later French essays answer one another.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
What historical claim does the article argue is created by the book’s mirror-shaped French frame?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- When does a carefully designed narrative structure illuminate historical continuity, and when does it begin to impose a pattern on the evidence?→
- How should Pater’s admission that his opening examples are not the best possible ones affect a reader’s trust in his larger argument?→
- Does the German coda meaningfully challenge the French mirror-frame, or does it make that frame more intellectually honest? Why?→