Renaissance

One Brushstroke Across the Length of Milan

Matteo Bandello remembered Leonardo crossing Milan to add a stroke or two to the Last Supper. He also remembered days when the painter never put down his brush.

Pater singles out Leonardo’s brief visits to the mural as evidence of how he waited for inspiration. Bandello’s fuller account brings sustained painting, close observation and the dry-wall technique into the same story.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • Pater’s single brushstrokePater turns Leonardo’s walk across Milan into a story about an artist who waits for the right moment to work.
  • Bandello’s longer accountMatteo Bandello remembers entire days of painting, long spells of looking and brief visits for one or two strokes.
  • A place to hear opinionsBandello says Leonardo welcomed frank responses from people who came to see his paintings.
  • A wall that allowed revisionsLeonardo worked on a dry preparation, which gave him time to return to the mural and change a detail.

Picture a summer noon in Milan in the 1490s, and a painter leaving the Old Court, where the storyteller Matteo Bandello places his giant clay horse, walking across town to a Dominican convent, climbing a scaffold, adding a stroke or two to one of the figures on the refectory wall, and leaving again. Pater compresses the scene into a single phrase, Leonardo “often coming the whole length of Milan to give a single touch,” and he files it among the “effective anecdotes” told about the Last Supper, “his retouchings and delays.” It’s the Renaissance version of the songwriter who gets out of bed at three in the morning to change one word in a chorus, and like that story it gets told to prove something about genius. The question is what it really proves about how a long job gets done.

Unlike most of the stories told about Leonardo, this one comes with an eyewitness attached. Matteo Bandello, later a famous storyteller, was a youngster at Santa Maria delle Grazie in those years, living in the convent where his uncle Vincenzo was prior, and in the first part of his Novelle, published in 1554, he prefaced a tale with what he remembered seeing. Leonardo, he says, would come early, climb the scaffold, and paint from sunrise until dusk without ever putting the brush down, forgetting to eat or drink. Then he’d go two, three or four days without touching the picture, though he’d still spend an hour or two a day in front of it, contemplating and judging his figures. And sometimes, as the capriccio o ghiribizzo, the whim or fancy, took him, he’d leave the Corte Vecchia, the Old Court, at midday with the sun in Leo, in high summer, and come straight to the Grazie to give one or two strokes to one of the figures and leave again.

Put Bandello’s paragraph beside Pater’s sentence and you can watch Pater edit. Bandello gives us three rhythms, the marathon, the silent inspection and the drive-by touch, and Pater keeps the last two and turns them into a creed. The anecdotes, he says, “show him refusing to work except at the moment of invention, scornful of anyone who supposed that art could be a work of mere industry and rule.” But the marathon days are right there in the same breath of Bandello’s preface, a man up on a scaffold from dawn to dark who forgets his lunch, and that’s industry by any definition. Pater wants a Leonardo who waits for lightning, while Bandello describes a Leonardo who also put in the hours, sometimes a dozen of them in a row.

Bandello names the Old Court and the Grazie. Pater turns the route into “the whole length of Milan.” The museum dates the mural to the later 1490s, and Leonardo had already made the full-scale clay horse by autumn 1493. Bandello’s account, written decades later, leaves the particular day and stage of the model uncertain. You can still see how the story was shaped twice, first by a storyteller remembering his youth and then by a critic looking for a telling gesture.

So what does the single touch actually mean, if it isn’t proof of contempt for hard work? I think the key is Bandello’s middle rhythm, the hours of judging without a brush in hand. A stroke that arrives at midday after a walk across town isn’t a bolt from nowhere, because it might be the end of a decision that took shape during one of those quiet hours in front of the wall. The Last Supper is a crowd of thirteen people reacting to one sentence, and in a composition like that a small change to a hand or the turn of a head alters how every neighbor reads, so the decisions really are small while the stakes really are large. The touch can be tiny because the thinking behind it was already finished.

Bandello adds a detail that Pater leaves out, and it matters a great deal. Leonardo, he says, liked everyone who saw his paintings to tell him freely what they thought, and the tale itself opens with a group of gentlemen standing quietly in the refectory watching the picture grow. The wall was in a dining hall the friars used every day and Bandello’s gentlemen could stand there and watch, like a small preview audience for a work still in progress. Readiness, on this account, wasn’t only a mood that visited a genius, since it was also a conversation he deliberately kept open.

The other side deserves its due, because Pater is right about the shape of the work even where he’s wrong about its moral. A long project like this one really did depend on intervals of readiness, and Pater’s next sentence quietly supplies the practical condition, since Leonardo chose a method that “allowed of so many after-thoughts, so refined a working-out of perfection.” The edition’s note confirms that the dry-wall technique permitted changes over time, so a figure could take one more stroke whenever a decision arrived, which is just what Bandello watched happen. The drive-by touch is the method working as designed, and Pater sees that clearly.

My verdict is that Pater reads the anecdote rightly and draws the wrong lesson from it. The single touch shows that the Last Supper was built out of many small decisions arriving at irregular intervals, and that Leonardo arranged both his medium and his days so those decisions could land whenever they were ready. What it doesn’t show is a man who scorned industry, because Bandello’s same paragraph gives us the dawn-to-dusk marathons and the long silent sessions of judging that made the midday stroke possible. In Bandello’s telling, readiness is something the labor produced, and the walk across Milan was the visible end of a great deal of invisible work that Pater, for the sake of a temperament, preferred to leave out.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

What is the article’s central objection to Pater’s interpretation of Leonardo’s working habits?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.