Philosophy

No Trying What You Don’t Know

Socrates’ expert city would keep people from doing what they don’t know. An apprentice would have a hard time getting started there.

Taken literally, the imagined city’s rule would catch beginners along with impostors. Learning gives Socrates’ reader a reason to draw the distinction.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • The rule catches beginners tooPeople in the imagined city act within their competence. Taken literally, that rule would also apply to a learner who admits she still needs practice.
  • Practice comes firstAristotle points out that builders learn to build by building. Apprenticeship gives beginners a place to try the work while someone experienced can help.
  • Discovery needs experimentsThe Wright brothers tested gliders and gathered wind-tunnel data before building a powered aircraft. Work like theirs starts before anyone knows how it will turn out.
  • The dialogue is itself an attemptSocrates says he asks because he doesn’t know. The conversation gives readers an example of people trying something worth doing while they are still learning.

Charmides 165a–b, 165c, 171d–172a, 172b–d, 173c–d · Aristotle, Nicomachean Ethics 2.1 (1103a–b) · Smithsonian National Air and Space Museum Researching the Wright Way

The rule is stated twice in a single breath. In the temperate city, Socrates says, “neither would we ourselves try to do what we did not know,” and “Nor would we allow the others we ruled to do anything except what they would do correctly, and that would be whatever they had knowledge of.” As a recipe for avoiding error it’s hard to beat, since if nobody ever acts outside his competence, nobody ever botches a job he wasn’t qualified for. But take the rule literally for a moment, and ask what kind of city it would actually produce. The rule is aimed at incompetence. Its wording draws no line between the quack and the beginner, and both are doing what they don’t know.

The first casualty would be learning, since nobody knows how to do anything at the start, and the only way to learn most skills is to try them before you can do them well. Aristotle put the point memorably, that we become builders by building and lyre-players by playing the lyre, so that the activity comes before the skill rather than after it. A city that let people do only what they already knew would freeze its skills at their present level, since nobody new could ever learn them, and within a generation it would run out of people who knew anything.

Apprenticeship gives the beginner somewhere to practice. A cobbler can watch an apprentice cut leather and point out why the first attempt went wrong. A trainee can carry out a task under supervision before taking it on alone. Both are ways to try work one doesn’t yet know how to do well. A ban on all such attempts would catch people who are learning alongside the people who are pretending.

Discovery depends on a similar permission. Before they built their powered aircraft, the Wright brothers built and tested gliders and used a wind tunnel to check their assumptions about lift. They could already build things and make measurements. What they didn’t yet know was how to reach the result they were after. A city that gave them room to experiment would need to distinguish that kind of uncertainty from ordinary incompetence.

The dialogue doesn’t develop this objection, and it would be wrong to pretend it does. Socrates’ own reason for doubting the temperate city is different, since he asks whether perfect competence would make us happy. But the dialogue does show, in its own action, why the rule can’t be right. Its whole conversation consists of people attempting what they don’t know, a teenager asked to define a virtue he has never studied, an aristocrat defending definitions he can’t support, and a philosopher who says he inquires precisely “because I myself do not know.”

There’s a hint of the issue inside the argument. Just after the picture of the temperate city, Socrates suggests that temperance might help its owner “learn more easily whatever else he learns.” The two proposals are easier to reconcile if the city makes a place for learners to try what they haven’t yet mastered. The rule as Socrates first describes it leaves that place unmentioned.

The example brings out a difference between preventing error and making room for worthwhile risks. A sensible society does try to keep incompetent people out of positions where their mistakes would be disastrous, which is why we license surgeons and pilots, but it also builds protected spaces where people can make mistakes safely while they learn, such as training schools, practice rounds, supervised residencies and laboratories. The temperate city has only the first half of that arrangement, and a city with only the first half would be safe, static and slowly dying.

My verdict is that the temperate city’s rule against attempting what one doesn’t know, taken literally, would abolish learning, apprenticeship and discovery, and that the tension between preventing error and making room for growth is real even though the dialogue doesn’t spell it out. The Charmides answers the rule by example rather than argument, since its own conversation is a long, valuable attempt by people to do what they don’t yet know how to do. A city that wants to avoid mistakes needs some rule like Critias’, but it also needs exceptions for learners, and the dialogue’s characters are all learners.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

Why does the author think a literal ban on doing what one does not know would eventually undermine the city’s competence?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.