Philosophy

No Hearing, Just Force

When Charmides promises to use force, Socrates asks for a preliminary hearing. His courtroom joke marks how quickly a conversation devoted to examination can turn into a decision already made.

Socrates asks for a hearing as Critias and Charmides make plans for him. The legal word carries a serious distinction into a playful farewell.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • Socrates asks to be heardCharmides says the plotting is finished. Socrates jokes that they are going to use force without even giving him a preliminary hearing.
  • A court word in the gymAnakrisis was the preliminary examination before an Athenian trial. Socrates uses the word after spending the conversation putting claims to the test.
  • A different way to decideThe men have been asking for reasons about temperance. Charmides and Critias settle what they want Socrates to do by agreeing between themselves.
  • Later history changes the soundSocrates describes resisting actual orders in the Apology. Those episodes give the wrestling-school joke a different weight for readers who know them.

Charmides 176c–d · Euthyphro 2a–b · Apology 32b–c, 32c–d · Liddell–Scott–Jones ἀνάκρισις

The protest comes in the last exchanges of the dialogue. Charmides says the two of them have finished plotting, and Socrates asks whether they’ll use force, “and won’t even give me a preliminary hearing?” Charmides tells him to count on force, “since this man here gives the orders,” and Socrates gives up, saying, “There’s no counsel left,” since when Charmides sets about anything and uses force, “no man alive will be able to oppose you.” The final line is Socrates’ surrender, “Then I won’t oppose you.” It’s a brisk little scene, half courtroom drama and half schoolyard ambush, and it’s the last thing Plato chose to show us.

The legal term matters, because the Greek word is anakrisis, the preliminary hearing held by a magistrate before a case went to court, at which the parties stated their claims and the magistrate examined them to see whether the case could proceed. Socrates is complaining, in mock-legal language, that he’s being condemned without even the first step of due process. And the verb behind the word is the ordinary Greek for questioning someone closely, so what Socrates demands is, quite literally, an examination, the very activity he has spent the whole afternoon conducting. He is asking for his day in court before a sentence he plainly doesn’t mind serving, which is part of what makes the line funny.

That gives the joke its edge, since the dialogue has been one long examination, an attempt to settle a question by asking and answering until the truth comes out or the inquiry fails honestly. The ending settles a different question, what Charmides will do next, by a completely different method, a decision made in private and enforced by will. Socrates’ protest names the contrast precisely, since he asks for the examination that the others have skipped, and the scene shows two ways of settling an encounter side by side, one by inquiry and one by force. The magistrate’s hearing existed so that nobody would be condemned before his case had been looked at, and Socrates’ joke borrows that whole civic value for a moment of play.

There is room for affection in the scene. Socrates has just heard that a promising young man wants to spend more time with him. The exchange can sound like friends dragging somebody to a dinner he’s happy to attend. Charmides sounds like a younger cousin teasing, even if the line about force can sound different to a reader who knows what he and Critias later did.

In the Apology, Socrates describes two occasions when a decision was backed by real pressure. In 406 BC, while serving on the Council, he opposed trying the generals together despite an angry Assembly. Under the Thirty, he says, he was ordered to bring in Leon of Salamis for execution and simply went home. The Euthyphro shows him outside the office of the king archon as his own prosecution gets under way. Those scenes give the wrestling-school joke a legal and political world to echo.

A reader who knows what happened under the Thirty can hear Critias and Charmides differently in these lines. That dramatic irony belongs to the reader. Inside the scene, an insistent pupil and his guardian are trying to arrange more time with Socrates, and he answers with a courtroom joke. The history adds pressure to the joke while the teasing remains audible.

What the scene does establish, without any prophecy, is a contrast between two ways of deciding things. Examination asks for reasons, allows the other side to speak and accepts the possibility of being wrong, while force decides first and invites no reply. The dialogue doesn’t say force is always wrong, and in this case it’s used for a good end, but it lets us see how quickly a group can move from one method to the other, and how easily even a philosopher gives way when the force is friendly and the outcome is one he likes. Plato’s readers had watched that slide happen in their own city, more than once and in both directions, which may be why the scene was worth ending on.

My verdict is that Socrates’ demand for a preliminary hearing makes examination and force into competing ways of settling an encounter, and that this contrast is the scene’s real content. The legal word, which literally means an examination, ties the protest to everything the dialogue has been doing, and the surrender shows how easily examination gives way when force arrives smiling. Later history gives the joke a resonance Plato’s readers would have felt, but the joke itself predicts nothing, and reading it well means keeping the irony without mistaking it for prophecy.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

Why does the author consider Socrates’ request for an anakrisis especially fitting and funny?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.