Renaissance

Nicolette Makes a Rope

Pater admires the beauty of Nicolette’s escape. Watch what she does with the bedclothes and towels, and you can see her thinking.

Nicolette judges the danger, notices that her guard is asleep and uses the things in her room to get down from the window.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • She sizes up the dangerNicolette knows what the count might do to her and sees that the woman keeping watch is asleep.
  • She chooses a gownNicolette puts on her finest dress before she climbs down, a gesture that gives her escape room for romance as well as urgency.
  • She uses what she hasShe knots the bedclothes and towels together, fastens them to a window pillar and lowers herself quietly.
  • Her actions change the picturePater admires the beauty of the scene. The sequence of small decisions gives readers a view of Nicolette’s resourcefulness.

Pater sets Nicolette up as part of the scenery. He describes the tale’s “languid Eastern deliciousness,” its “full-blown roses,” its painted chamber and “cool brown marble,” and then says that “Nicolette herself well becomes this scenery, and is the best illustration of the quality I mean.” She’s “the beautiful, weird, foreign girl,” a figure of delicate, slightly exotic beauty who completes the picture the way a jewel completes a costume. Then he quotes the passage he calls “perhaps the prettiest” in the whole piece, her escape from imprisonment, and the passage turns out to be about something very different from prettiness. It’s a little like praising a heist film for its costumes, which may be gorgeous, while the plot is busy showing you how clever the thief is.

Start with how she reads her situation, lying on her bed on a May night, she sees the moon through the window and hears the nightingale, and the tale gives her a moment of romantic feeling, in which “then came the memory of Aucassin, whom she so much loved.” But the very next thought is cold and clear. “She thought of the Count Garins of Beaucaire, who mortally hated her, and, to be rid of her, might at any moment cause her to be burned or drowned.” That’s a precise assessment of a threat, the kind of thinking a prisoner does when she knows her life is in danger, and it comes before any plan. Feeling and strategy sit side by side, and the strategy wins.

Then she checks her guard, since “She perceived that the old woman who kept her company was asleep,” the tale says, and the word “perceived” matters, because it shows her watching and waiting for the right moment rather than acting on impulse. Any escape story turns on this beat, the moment the guard drops off, and the tale gives it to Nicolette as a piece of observation. She isn’t rescued by someone else, and she doesn’t wait for Aucassin, who is himself locked up and weeping in a tower. In this escape, she is the one who acts, reversing the parts a reader might expect in a romance.

The next detail is the one that seems most ornamental, and it’s the most interesting. “She rose and put on the fairest gown she had.” You could read that as vanity, the pretty girl dressing up even while fleeing for her life. But think about where she’s going, since she’s heading out into the town and then to the tower where her beloved is held, and possibly out into the world for good, so the gown is what she will be seen in and what she’ll have to live in. Choosing her best dress is both a lover’s gesture and a practical one, and the tale lets it be both without asking us to choose between them.

Then comes the engineering, “She took the bed-clothes and the towels, and knotted them together like a cord, as far as they would go. Then she tied the end to a pillar of the window, and let herself slip down quite softly into the garden, and passed straight across it, to reach the town.” Every item is from the household, bedding, towels, a window pillar, and every step is practical, gathering materials, knotting them into as long a cord as she can make, anchoring the end and lowering herself quietly. It’s the knotted-sheets escape that has appeared in a thousand later stories, and here it belongs to a medieval heroine who works it out for herself.

Those household details do something Pater’s framing doesn’t, since they make Nicolette’s intelligence visible through objects, the way a detective story shows a character’s cleverness through what she notices and uses. A painted chamber and cool marble are scenery, but bedclothes and towels are tools, and the passage moves her from the first category to the second. The phrase “as far as they would go” is especially good, since it lets us see how she works with the limited materials she has. And she does it all “quite softly,” which shows a sense of noise and timing to go with her sense of distance, since one creak or thud could wake the old woman.

The famous description that follows, with her yellow curls, smiling eyes and feet so white that the crushed daisies look dark beside them, does return to her beauty, and the tale clearly loves to look at her. But by then we’ve seen her plan, wait, dress and climb, so the beauty belongs to an agent rather than an ornament. The tale doesn’t set brains against looks, since it gives her both, and it makes her beauty part of the adventure, something she has to manage as she slips through a moonlit town, rather than the reason the adventure exists. Later she even paints her face dark with a herb and disguises herself as a minstrel to travel in search of Aucassin, which shows how freely she treats her own beauty as a tool.

So the precise household materials make Nicolette’s practical intelligence plain, and they complicate the ornamental role Pater’s description of the setting leads us to expect. I think Pater half sees this, since he chose the passage and called it the prettiest in the book, but his framing keeps her as an illustration of a mood when the passage shows her as the story’s most capable character. The best reading keeps both his eye for her beauty and the tale’s own interest in her resourcefulness, and enjoys a heroine who can look like a picture and still tie her own rope. At the decisive moment, she acts for herself, and the knotted linen is how she gets free.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

What is the article's central criticism of Pater's framing of Nicolette?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.