Greek Antiquity

Necessity in the Sky’s Chest

Night answers to a necessity that masters everything, and Ouranos holds the necessity of nature in his breast.

Two neighboring hymns place necessity in different relations to the gods. The article reads the sky’s ceaseless turning as a way that Ouranos can embody the power that also governs him.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • Necessity rules in the hymn to NightAs Night retreats to Hades, the hymn says that dread necessity masters all things.
  • Ouranos carries necessity within himThe hymn calls the sky the holder of nature’s unapproachable necessity and describes his unwearied motion around the earth.
  • A manuscript reading emphasizes the burdenThe manuscripts describe the necessity as unendurable where Hermann’s reading makes it unapproachable.
  • The sky can embody the ruleThe article takes the necessity held by Ouranos to be the law of the motion that carries Night through her circuit.

Orphic Hymns, III.8–11; IV.1, 3, 5–6, with the apparatus and the note on IV.6; LV.3

Two hymns in a row talk about anankē, necessity, and they seem to put it in different places. Night, at the end of her journey into Hades, gets the line “for dread necessity masters all things,” which sounds like necessity is the boss of the universe, Night included. That was a familiar Greek sentiment, and Euripides could have a chorus sing that of everything it had studied, poetry and astronomy and all the rest, it had found nothing stronger than Necessity, a goddess with no altar and no image who heeds no sacrifice. A page later Ouranos is “holding in your breast the unapproachable necessity of nature,” which sounds like the sky has necessity tucked inside him like a heart. The edition’s note on that line puts the puzzle plainly, saying that Ouranos “both contains necessity and is subject to the ἀνάγκη that masters all,” and that the hymn doesn’t explain how.

It helps to separate three things a god might have to do with a power like this. He could enclose it, the way a box holds a jewel, which would make necessity a thing inside the sky and no more. He could command it, the way a king commands an army, which would put the sky above necessity. Or he could embody it, the way a person’s character is in them, so that necessity is simply what the sky is like from the inside. Each of those gives a different cosmology, and you can’t settle which one the hymns mean by guessing.

Commanding is the easiest to rule out, because nothing in the hymn to Ouranos says he gives necessity orders, and Night’s line says necessity masters all things, which leaves no room for a master above it. Plain enclosure doesn’t work well either, because a power that rules everything can’t just sit in somebody’s chest like a stone in a pocket. That leaves embodiment, and the Greek idiom points the same way, since “holding in your breast” is how Homer talks about a hero’s spirit or his anger, thymos held in the chest, the inner force that drives what he does.

Look at what kind of necessity it is, too, because the line says “necessity of nature,” physeōs anankē, the compulsion built into how things grow and move. And look at what the sky does in the same hymn, “rolling spherewise about the earth,” “ever unwearied.” The sky’s nature is to turn without stopping, and the necessity in his chest is the law of that turning, the drive of the whole revolving frame. The hymn even calls him “unsubdued” a line later, which fits perfectly, since nothing outside him masters him and the only compulsion he answers to is the one he carries inside. It’s the same thing that made Night half-complete in the previous hymn, forced to circle between the upper world and Hades, because the turning of heaven is exactly what keeps her moving.

That means the two lines can describe one relation seen from two sides. From inside, necessity is the sky’s own nature, the force of his rotation, held in his chest the way a dancer holds the rhythm. From outside, that same rotation is a compulsion on everything it carries around, so Night feels it as “dread necessity” mastering her. Neither image contradicts the other, any more than a river contradicts itself by being, for the river, its own current, and for a boat caught in it, an irresistible push.

The manuscripts make the point sharper, as it happens. The edition’s word “unapproachable” is Hermann’s aplēton, but the codices read atlēton, “unendurable,” which would make Ouranos hold in his chest a necessity too heavy to bear. On that reading the sky isn’t calmly in charge of his law at all, he carries it the way Atlas carries the heavens, and the line makes him the first thing subject to the necessity he contains, which is exactly the double position the note describes. Hermann’s change makes the line grander and more serene, a necessity too vast to come near, while the manuscripts make it more troubled and more human, a burden in the chest, and the embodiment reading works with either, since a law you are made of can be both immense and heavy to carry.

Philosophers had pictures of their own, and they show how many ways this could go. Parmenides has mighty Necessity holding what is in the bonds of a limit and binding the surrounding heaven to keep the stars in their bounds, so in his poem Necessity is outside, fastening the sky. Plato’s myth of Er puts Necessity at the center, with the spindle of the heavens turning on her knees. One of the Orphic theogonies goes the other way again, giving Necessity arms that stretch through the whole cosmos until they touch its limits, so that she embraces the world from outside. The hymn’s picture is closer to Plato’s, necessity at the heart of the turning, but it isn’t Plato’s, and the collection gives necessity still other relations elsewhere, since Aphrodite at LV.3 is called its mother.

So my verdict is that the sky contains what governs everything in the only sense that makes both hymns true, by embodying it as his own nature, the law of the turning that carries Night and everything else around. That isn’t commanding, and it isn’t just enclosing either. It would be a mistake, though, to stack these images into a single cosmology, since each hymn speaks to one god at a time and borrows whatever picture serves that god best, and the collection uses necessity the way it uses its epithets, freely and from several angles, and two neighboring hymns that fit together are a happy fit rather than a system.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

How does the article reconcile necessity being within Ouranos with necessity mastering Night?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.