Renaissance
Must the Angel Defeat the Master?
The angel at the left of the Baptism has a softer turn than its neighbor. The Uffizi’s account finds Leonardo’s hand in more of the panel than Vasari’s story lets us see.
The Renaissance (1893)Vasari makes a collaboration into the story of a pupil’s victory. Looking beyond the angel makes the workshop’s role in the painting easier to see.
Orientation
At a Glance
- The left-hand angel directs the eyeIts body turns and its drapery follows the turn. Vasari makes that particular figure the proof of a young painter’s ability.
- Pater keeps the story as a contrastHe calls the angel a space of sunlight and then qualifies the story of Verrocchio’s defeat. For him, painting was only one of Verrocchio’s arts.
- The panel preserves more than two handsThe Uffizi associates Leonardo with parts of the landscape and Christ’s figure as well as the angel. It also allows for another contributor.
- A workshop makes room for overlapA master could design a panel that others helped paint. The picture gives us a way to compare techniques without deciding who won a contest.
The Renaissance · Leonardo da Vinci, p. 70, the Baptism and the left-hand angel · Leonardo da Vinci, note 173 · Leonardo da Vinci, p. 70, the master and pupil · Leonardo da Vinci, p. 70, the legend and its sentiment
The Uffizi’s Baptism of Christ came from the Vallombrosan church of San Salvi, and down in its left-hand corner two angels kneel on the riverbank holding Christ’s clothes. The one on the far left, turning in three-quarter view with soft golden curls and a look of rapt attention, is traditionally Leonardo’s. Vasari says that when Verrocchio saw it, he was so mortified that a boy knew more than he did that he never touched paint again, and Pater makes the moment into a little tragedy, with Verrocchio turning “away as one stunned” from “the bright animated angel of Leonardo’s hand.” It’s easy to see why the story stuck, since that angel looks like a visitor from a later century who has wandered into an older painting.
Pater even gives the little tragedy a philosophy of history to go with it. It was, he says, “one of those moments in which the progress of a great thing,” here the art of Italy, “presses hard on the happiness of an individual, through whose discouragement and decrease, humanity, in more fortunate persons, comes a step nearer to its final success.” Then, a paragraph later, he quietly takes most of it back. The angel is still there, “a space of sunlight in the cold, laboured old picture,” but “the legend is true only in sentiment, for painting had always been the art by which Verrocchio set least store.” Verrocchio was a sculptor first, so losing to his pupil at painting wouldn’t have broken him.
So what does the story let a viewer see? Quite a lot, and that’s the strongest case for keeping it. It sends your eyes straight to the contrast between the two angels, the Leonardo figure turning softly into space while its neighbor holds a harder, more sculpted pose, and it teaches you to notice the difference between a line that describes a form and light that seems to breathe around it. Without the story, a visitor might walk past a fairly stiff altarpiece. With it, the corner becomes a window onto a revolution, and that’s not nothing.
Now look at what a workshop attribution asks you to notice instead. The panel combines oil and tempera. The Uffizi associates Leonardo’s contribution with the river landscape, its golden light and the figure of Christ as well as the angel. It also allows for another contributor, perhaps the painter who handled the hands of God and the dove. The Baptism turns out to be a team product, made over several years, in which the pupil’s hand reached right into the center of the master’s composition. The older passages, laid down in tempera with fine hatched strokes, sit right beside smooth blended oil, so you can watch the two techniques meeting on a single surface.
That changes the whole story, and it changes it for the better. If the Uffizi’s account is right, Leonardo’s work reached the central figure and the landscape. That gives us a workshop picture in which different painters could shape even important passages. The pattern of contributions is easier to see than the feelings of the people who made them.
Verrocchio’s workshop continued to produce paintings, among them a large altarpiece for Pistoia Cathedral, largely carried out by his pupil Lorenzo di Credi, and his real passion stayed with sculpture, from the bronze Doubting Thomas for Orsanmichele to the great equestrian statue of the condottiere Bartolomeo Colleoni in Venice, on which he was still working when he died there in 1488. Pater’s correction is right, and it’s worth pushing further than he did, since a man who sets least store by painting isn’t crushed by a better angel. A workshop’s continued work is harder to fit into a story of sudden defeat.
What keeps Vasari’s version alive is that it flatters everybody involved, including the viewer. It gives the genius a dramatic entrance, it gives the old master a noble defeat, and it lets us play the judge who sees at a glance that the pupil has won. Pater adds a Victorian twist, the idea that progress needs casualties, which turns a workshop arrangement into a parable about history grinding up individuals. That’s a powerful story, but a workshop isn’t a battlefield, and collaboration was simply how pictures got made in Florence in the 1470s. The duel also suits a modern taste for genius as a lightning strike, when the record shows Florentine genius growing up inside crowded workshops, sharing panels, tools and commissions.
So does the angel have to defeat its maker’s teacher? No, and the picture is better without the duel. Keep Vasari’s story as a pair of glasses for seeing the contrast between two ways of painting, because it really does sharpen the eye. But drop it as history, since the truer account is that a young man’s new way of handling light spread through his master’s picture, angel, river and Christ alike, within a shared workshop practice. Pater half knew this when he called the legend “true only in sentiment,” and the sentiment he should have kept is admiration rather than defeat. The legend survives in every guidebook because it’s a good story, and good stories are hard to retire even after the evidence has quietly moved on.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
According to the article, what is the strongest reason to retain Vasari’s story about Leonardo’s angel?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- When can a historically doubtful story still be a useful way of looking at a work of art, and what limits should govern its use?→
- How does viewing the painting as a collaborative workshop product alter ideas about authorship, genius, and artistic progress?→
- Why might viewers prefer a story of competition and sudden defeat to a more complex account of shared labor and gradual innovation?→