Philosophy
Musical Chairs on the Bench
A scramble for a seat turns into a contest over who will guide Charmides.
The Platonic Dialogues: CharmidesWhen Charmides sits down, every man on the bench makes room for him by shoving somebody else, and two guys lose their seats. The gag is funny, but look at where the boy ends up sitting, because that seating chart is the whole dialogue in miniature.
Orientation
At a Glance
- Making roomAs Charmides approaches, everyone tries to make room beside himself. The shoving forces one man to stand and tips another off the bench.
- The price of getting closeA polite gesture becomes a contest for a place beside the newcomer. The men at the ends pay for it.
- Between Socrates and CritiasCharmides lands between the philosopher and his guardian. The scramble anticipates their struggle over who will shape his thinking.
- The joke returnsCharmides volunteers to keep company with Socrates, and Critias turns the offer into an order. The closing joke about force recalls the elbows on the bench.
The moment Charmides arrives, the bench turns into a game of musical chairs that nobody agreed to play, and Socrates tells it with a perfectly straight face. “Every one of us who were sitting there squeezed up and shoved his neighbor hard to make room for Charmides to sit beside him,” he says, and the shoving runs down the line until, at the ends of the bench, “we made one stand up and tipped the other off sideways.” The whole room laughs, and it’s easy to laugh along and move on, since a row of grown men scrambling to sit next to the prettiest boy in Athens is a gag that more or less tells itself.
The question is whether the gag just shows how much everybody wants the boy, or whether it shows something more, and the case for keeping it simple is a good one. Plato needs a quick, vivid way to show how badly every man in the room wants to be near Charmides, and a pile-up on a bench does that better than a paragraph of description ever could, while also letting Socrates poke fun at himself, since he’s right there in the “every one of us.” On that reading the bench is a thermometer, and the joke is just how high the reading goes.
I think there’s more going on, and it starts with the verbs. The men “squeezed up,” which is the polite thing you do on a crowded bench when someone new arrives, and at the same time they “shoved,” which isn’t polite at all, and Socrates packs both verbs into the same gesture. Every man is making room and grabbing room at once, offering a courtesy to the boy while taking it out on his neighbor, so the friendliest move in the world, scooting over for a newcomer, turns into a contest the second there’s only one seat worth having. Anyone who has watched friends jockey for the chair next to somebody at a dinner party knows how fast “here, sit by me” becomes a competition.
Like most competitions over something scarce, this one has losers who did nothing wrong. The two men at the ends of the bench weren’t even in the race, since they were just sitting where they were sitting, and they’re the ones who end up standing or on the floor, because the pressure from the middle has to go somewhere. That’s the geometry of attention when there isn’t enough to go around, where every inch one man gains near the center is an inch some guy at the edge loses, and Socrates doesn’t spare himself in telling it. In a gym full of men angling for the same boy, the end of the bench was the worst seat in the house, and Plato makes sure we see who pays when attention gets rationed. Socrates even says “we” made one stand up and tipped the other off, owning his share of the shove instead of narrating the chaos as if it happened around him.
Then look at the result, because the scramble actually settles something. “He came and sat down between me and Critias,” Socrates says, and after all that pushing the two men who end up flanking the boy are the philosopher and the guardian. That’s hardly a random outcome of a pile-up, because those are the two men who are going to compete for Charmides for the rest of the dialogue, no longer for the seat beside him but for the right to shape what goes on inside him, so the bench hands us the dialogue’s real seating chart before anyone has said a word about temperance.
The contest shows up as soon as the argument gets going. Charmides tries out a definition he picked up from Critias, Socrates starts taking it apart, and the guardian, who has been sitting on his hands, finally can’t stand watching his line get fumbled and jumps in, so that from then on the boy sits quietly between two men who are fighting over him with words instead of elbows. The shoving has moved from the bench into the conversation, and it’s every bit as competitive, only better dressed.
By the last page the tug of war has a winner, at least on paper, when Charmides announces he’ll keep company with Socrates and Critias, who still gives the orders, tells him to, which sets up the dialogue’s closing joke about using force to keep Socrates around. Plato’s readers knew how the real contest ended, since Critias went on to lead the Thirty, the oligarchs who ran Athens by terror in 404/3, with Charmides serving the regime as one of the Ten in the Piraeus, until both of them died fighting the democrats in 403. Read with that in mind, the comic seating arrangement of the afternoon looks a lot less innocent, because the boy really was sitting between two futures.
The bench does register desire, and beautifully, but the gag also shows how easily courtesy turns into competition when there’s only one thing everyone wants, and how the scramble ends up putting the most important people exactly where the story needs them. Plato could have just told us the boy sat down. Instead he made us watch a row of grown men squeeze and shove their way to a seating chart, and that seating chart, with the philosopher on one side and the future tyrant on the other, is as close as the Charmides comes to drawing its own map.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
Why does the author focus on the pairing of “squeezed up” and “shoved” in the bench scene?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- When does making room for another person become a form of competition, and what features of the bench scene help you draw that boundary?→
- Why might Socrates’ use of “we” matter to the article’s account of responsibility for the men displaced at the ends of the bench?→
- Does reading the bench as a map of Charmides’ competing futures deepen the comedy, undermine it, or do both at once? Why?→