Greek Antiquity

Mother of Everything, Partner of No One

Nature can nourish everything and still have no partner because every relationship in the hymn flows from her.

Physis is common to all and shares with none, yet the hymn calls her father, mother, and nurse. The article reads these titles as relationships of giving and dependence.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • Two claims make a paradoxThe same line calls Nature common to all and says that she alone shares with none.
  • Sharing means partnershipThe Greek compound behind sharing with none can evoke fellowship or a relationship in which both sides take part.
  • Nature gives and nourishesThe titles father, mother, nurse, and foster-mother describe the things that depend on her for life and growth.
  • Her own origin follows the patternThe hymn calls Nature both self-fathered and fatherless, giving her no parent outside herself.

Orphic Hymns, X.1, 8–19, with the note on X.8–10

The hymn to Physis, Nature, is one long string of titles, and in the middle of it come three paradoxes in a row that the edition’s note singles out, “holy, orderer of the gods, and an end that does not end, / common to all, and alone sharing with none, / self-fathered, fatherless.” The note adds that the hymn “does not resolve them, and does not treat them as difficulties.” The one in the middle is the puzzling one for a reader, because the same hymn goes on to give Nature more relationships than any other god in the book, “of all things you are father, mother, nurse and foster-mother.” How can a goddess be everybody’s parent and nobody’s partner?

Start with the Greek word, because it narrows the problem. Akoinōnētos, “sharing with none,” is the negative of koinōnia, which means partnership or fellowship, the word for a business partnership, a political alliance or a marriage. So Nature isn’t being called aloof or stingy, she’s being called unpartnered, the one who has no partner in anything, no co-owner, no consort, no equal standing beside her. The first half of the line, “common to all,” says the opposite thing about a different relation, that everyone can reach her and draw on her, which is a statement about access, not about partnership. The second half also adds mounē, “alone,” and that sharpens the point, because she isn’t just without a partner at the moment, she’s the only one of her kind, standing by herself the way a single mountain stands on a plain.

Now look at the relationships the hymn actually gives her, and you’ll see that they all run one way. She’s “all-mother,” “all-nourishing,” “all-giving,” “life-bringing,” father and mother and nurse and foster-mother of everything, and every one of those is a relation in which she gives and others receive. Nothing in the hymn makes her anyone’s child, anyone’s spouse or anyone’s equal, and the line about parents makes that explicit, “self-fathered, fatherless,” so she has no source outside herself either. She has dependents without number and depends on nobody. Even the line that sounds most like give and take, “bitter to the base, but sweet to those who obey,” runs the same way, since it describes how she treats people according to how they behave, the way the weather treats a farmer who plants on time differently from one who doesn’t, while nothing either farmer does changes the weather.

That’s exactly what lets her be father and mother at once, which might otherwise look like the strangest claim in the hymn. Every other parent in Greek myth needs a partner, and the gods spend a great deal of their mythology arranging marriages and affairs to produce children. Nature needs no one, so she can be both parents herself, “swift in delivery,” as the next line puts it, a goddess who gives birth easily and constantly with no father anywhere in the picture, and the hymn underlines the point a few lines earlier by calling her “self-sufficiency,” autarkeia, the word philosophers used for the state of needing nothing outside oneself. Aristotle argued that the perfectly self-sufficient god would have no need of friends, and the hymn makes the same move with its Nature, all generosity and no need.

A Christian reader may hear an echo here that’s worth naming. Julian of Norwich, the English mystic, wrote that as truly as God is our Father, so truly is God our Mother, and she could say it for the same reason the hymn can, because a God who depends on nothing doesn’t need a consort to be the source of everything, and so can be described with every image of parental care at once. The traditions are different and so are their gods, but the logic of a single source who is both parents is the same, and it makes the hymn’s list feel less strange than it first does.

So the hymn does distinguish having dependents from depending on someone, though it does it by its pattern rather than by an argument. Everything flows out from her, nothing flows back in, and the paradox of line 9 turns out to be a precise description of that asymmetry. Common to all means everyone can draw on her, like a spring in a village square that anyone can drink from, and sharing with none means nobody stands beside her as a co-owner of the spring. The villagers don’t hold the water in partnership with the spring, they just draw on it, and the spring isn’t any smaller for the number who come. Both halves are true at once, and the hymn is right not to treat them as a difficulty.

The other two paradoxes fall into place the same way. “An end that does not end” describes a goal that is never used up, the purpose toward which things grow that remains after each thing has reached it, and “self-fathered, fatherless” describes an origin with nothing behind it. Read together, the three lines sketch a power that is the source, the goal and the support of everything else while needing no source, goal or support of her own, which is a remarkably coherent picture to emerge from what looks at first like a pile of contradictions. The hymn even gives her the vocabulary of rule, “leader, accomplisher” and “queen of all,” and a ruler in that sense is someone on whom many depend and who answers to no one.

My verdict is that Nature can be common to all and share with none because her relationships are all of one kind, the kind in which she gives. She has dependents everywhere and depends on nothing, so she can be father, mother and nurse to everything without being anyone’s partner, and the paradox in line 9 is the hymn’s way of saying so in a single line. It doesn’t need resolving, as the note says, so much as reading as a statement about the direction in which the giving flows.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

According to the article, why are “common to all” and “sharing with none” not contradictory?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.