Renaissance

More Frames in the Same Second

Pater cannot extend the time a person is given. He asks how much more of it they can notice while it is passing.

The difference between the essay’s pulses and pulsations gives the idea a shape. Attention can distinguish moments that would otherwise blur into one.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • A finite intervalPater begins from the limit on the time a life can contain and asks what a person can do within it.
  • What more frames can showThe high-speed camera comparison helps distinguish having more time from noticing more in the time already available.
  • The roughness of the eyeFor Pater a habit of seeing things as alike can erase differences that would otherwise make one encounter distinct from another.
  • A qualification in 1893Pater adds a biblical phrase that limits whom he calls wisest for spending their time in art and song.

Pater starts the middle of the Conclusion with a bookkeeping sentence that lands like a doctor’s verdict. “A counted number of pulses only is given to us of a variegated, dramatic life.” The word “counted” makes the number sound fixed, and “only” makes clear the total won’t be raised, so the essay faces the same problem a person faces after a bad diagnosis, which is what to do with a fixed sum. A page later Pater names his answer, after saying that “we have an interval, and then our place knows us no more,” and it’s surprisingly technical, since “our one chance lies in expanding that interval, in getting as many pulsations as possible into the given time.”

The proposal sounds like a paradox until you look at the words. You can’t expand an interval by making it longer, because the length is fixed, so Pater means making it denser, more beats in the same span of time. Think of the difference between ordinary video and a high-speed camera, where both record the same single second, but one captures thirty frames and the other a thousand, and when you play back the high-speed footage you see a hummingbird’s wing or a drop of milk making a crown that was invisible to the ordinary camera. The second didn’t get longer, but there’s far more in it, and that’s the kind of expansion Pater is after.

His vocabulary keeps duration and richness on separate tracks. Duration is counted, given, fixed, an “interval” with a start and a finish, while richness is described in words of rhythm and multiplication, “pulsations,” a “quickened sense of life,” a “quickened, multiplied consciousness.” Pulses suggest the body’s clock. In the later sentence, pulsations suggest the beats of experience a person actually registers. Two people can live through the same afternoon with the same number of heartbeats and come out of it with wildly different numbers of pulsations, and that gap is the only kind of expansion on offer. The argument lives in the gap between time that elapses and time a person has attended to.

If the plan stopped there, though, it would be a recipe for something we all recognize, an evening spent scrolling a feed, where you take in hundreds of quick hits and come out with nothing you can remember. Many stimuli don’t automatically make many moments, any more than a thousand photos of the same sunset make a thousand sunsets. That’s why Pater pairs his arithmetic with a warning, “Only be sure it is passion,” and why, a few lines earlier, he says that “it is only the roughness of the eye that makes any two persons, things, situations, seem alike.” A moment only counts as a distinct pulsation if you can tell it apart from the one before it, so receptivity supplies the raw material, while discrimination is what turns the material into separate beats.

This is the real engine of the expansion, and it’s subtler than appetite. A blurred hour is one moment, no matter how much happened in it, while a minute you discriminate finely can hold a dozen, the way a trained musician hears ten things in a bar of music where a casual listener hears a pleasant noise. Pater’s earlier phrase about the eye matters here, because the rough eye makes “two persons, things, situations” look alike, so details can pass without being registered. Noticing the difference between two shades, two faces or two moods is how the essay imagines finding more in a life whose length you can’t change.

Pater’s revisions show him refining who gets to spend the interval well. In 1873 he wrote that some spend it in listlessness, some in high passions, and “the wisest in art and song,” while in 1893 he limits the claim to the wisest “at least among” what he calls the children of this world. The note traces the phrase to the parable of the unjust steward in Luke, where the children of this world are said to be wiser in their generation than the children of light. The qualification is honest, since it concedes that there may be other kinds of wisdom about how to spend a life, and it keeps the plan from claiming more than it can deliver.

There’s a real objection to the whole scheme, and it deserves its moment. A life measured by the density of its pulsations could easily become a life of constant self-monitoring, always checking whether this moment is intense enough, which is a good way to ruin moments. The fix, I think, lies in Pater’s own word “passion,” since passion is absorbed in its object and doesn’t sit around counting its beats, while the camera comparison concerns what has been registered, not what a person keeps counting. The counting is the theorist’s description of the result, and the person living it should simply be looking hard at something that matters to them.

The interval can become richer without becoming longer, and Pater’s vocabulary makes the trick precise, separating the fixed count of pulses from the variable richness of pulsations. Receptivity alone gives you more input but not more moments, which is why the plan depends on discrimination, the trained eye that refuses to let two things blur into one. What Pater offers, in the end, is a way of raising the resolution of a life whose running time is already set, and that’s a far more demanding program than the hedonism his critics heard in it.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

What does the article mean by “expanding” life’s fixed interval?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.