Renaissance

Michelangelo Wanted to Carve the Mountain

Condivi says Michelangelo imagined a colossus cut straight into a seaside crag. Pater finds a trace of that closeness between figure and rock in the finished David.

The mountain figure stayed an idea, but the marble of David still bears evidence of its origin. Those two connections to Carrara give Pater’s image of living rock something concrete to work with.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • Condivi records an unmade colossusAt Carrara, Michelangelo wanted to carve a crag into a figure sailors could see from far off. The shape of the rock was part of what suggested the figure.
  • Pater imagines rock on the point of movingHe describes Michelangelo’s figures as if they only had to shake off dust and stand up. Their relation to the quarry remains part of their appearance.
  • Restoration changed the evidence of colorCleaning the Sistine frescoes made much brighter colors visible. That complicates a literal connection between their palette and Carrara’s gray peaks.
  • David carries its origin in the marbleMaterial analysis identifies the quarrying district. That gives us a physical connection to Carrara independent of Pater’s report of an uncut patch.

Michelangelo’s friend and biographer Ascanio Condivi tells a story from one of the sculptor’s long stays at Carrara, when he looked out from the mountains toward the sea and wanted to carve a whole peak into a colossus that sailors would see from far off. Condivi says he was tempted partly by the shape of the rock and partly by the wish to rival the ancients, but the colossus remained uncarved, and the idea sounds like Mount Rushmore four hundred years early, except that Rushmore puts faces on a mountain while Michelangelo apparently wanted the mountain itself to stand up as a body. Pater never mentions the colossus, but his paragraph on Carrara reads as if he’d been thinking about it, because his whole case is that for Michelangelo a figure and the rock it comes from never quite separate.

He begins with a phrase he credits to “the old Florentine records,” which he says describe a sculptor as a “master of live stone,” and he takes the words literally. “With him the very rocks seem to have life,” he writes, and “they have but to cast away the dust and scurf that they may rise and stand on their feet.” Then he goes to the source, saying Michelangelo “loved the very quarries of Carrara, those strange grey peaks which even at mid-day convey into any scene from which they are visible something of the solemnity and stillness of evening.” It’s gorgeous writing, and it sets up two concrete claims, one about the color of the paintings and one about the top of David’s head.

The biography behind the mood is real but less dreamy than Pater makes it sound. Michelangelo went to Carrara in 1497 to pick the marble for the Rome Pietà, spent about eight months there in 1505 buying blocks for the tomb of Julius II, and was back again from 1516 choosing stone for the façade of San Lorenzo, haggling over cartloads, contracts and boats. His dealings with the Carrara quarrymen also turned bitter, with years of quarrels over late and missing deliveries. Pater’s phrase “sometimes wandering among them month after month” is true to the months and generous about the wandering, since most of that time was spent doing business in a place he loved and cursed in equal measure.

The first concrete claim is that the quarries’ “pale ashen colours seem to have passed into his painting,” and here history has played a trick on Pater. The Vatican restoration of the ceiling and the Last Judgment removed darkened surface deposits and material from previous treatments. The bright colors that emerged make it harder to take Pater’s link between Carrara and Michelangelo’s palette literally.

The second claim is that “on the crown of the head of the David there still remains a morsel of uncut stone, as if by one touch to maintain its connexion with the place from which it was hewn.” That’s Pater’s own observation about the top of a seventeen-foot statue, which most visitors never see, so it’s safest to treat it as his report rather than as a documented feature. What science has documented is the place itself, because a 2005 study of the marble used fragments from a damaged toe to identify the quarrying district around Miseglia in Carrara.

That detail actually helps Pater more than his morsel does. The David’s block had been cut from the mountain decades before Michelangelo ever touched it, and it carries its quarry with it whether or not any raw patch survives, in its grain, its porousness and its tendency to weather, so the statue’s connection with the place it was hewn from is physical and permanent. You can’t polish away where marble comes from, and a statue that’s been standing in Florence for five centuries is still, chemically, a piece of a particular hillside above Carrara.

Modern Carrara puts Pater’s live stone in a harsher light. A quarry is a workplace as well as the landscape Pater describes. Some of its stone leaves in blocks and some as material for other uses. Michelangelo’s uncarved colossus imagines a third possibility, a figure that stays with the hillside that gave it its shape.

So my verdict is that Pater’s evidence is shaky and his idea is sound. The cleaning complicates the ceiling’s supposed ashen palette, and the morsel on David’s crown is a claim we can’t easily check, but the colossus Michelangelo dreamed of carving out of a mountain shows that he really did imagine figures that never leave their rock. A finished statue can carry its quarry with it, and Pater’s real insight is that knowing where the marble came from changes how alive it looks.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

How does the Vatican restoration affect Pater’s claim that Carrara’s pale, ashen colors influenced Michelangelo’s paintings?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.