Renaissance
Michelangelo Skips the First Five Days
Pater sees a world barely furnished for human life. The Sistine ceiling gives him more creation scenes than he counts, but its bodies still draw the eye first.
The Renaissance (1893)The Vatican’s Genesis scenes correct Pater’s inventory. Looking at the figure of God beside a small patch of plants shows why he remembers a body before he remembers the world around it.
Orientation
At a Glance
- Genesis makes people the last arrivalThe first chapter brings in light, land, plants, heavenly bodies, fish and birds before humans appear on the sixth day.
- Pater remembers an almost bare worldHe contrasts Michelangelo’s rocks and sparse growth with Titian’s forests and Leonardo’s flowers. It makes his people seem to come into the world first.
- The ceiling contains more than Pater saysBefore Adam and Eve, Michelangelo depicts three scenes of cosmic creation. One brings the plants, sun and moon together.
- A body dominates even the plantsIn the fresco, the Creator appears twice and extends an arm toward a small patch of vegetation. Pater’s memory of bodies still tells us something about the balance of the scene.
The Renaissance · The Poetry of Michelangelo, rock, plants and the first five days · Note 134, Grimm and Michelangelo’s letter · The Poetry of Michelangelo, the creation scenes and the making of man · Note 135, the Sistine ceiling’s actual program · Genesis 1, the days of creation · Central Genesis scenes of the Sistine ceiling, Vatican Museums · The Creation of the Sun, Moon and Plants, Vatican Museums · Michelangelo’s 1556 letter quoted in Vasari’s Life
Anyone who has watched a video game being made knows the gray-box stage, when the level exists and the hero can run around in it, but every wall is a blank slab and every tree is a gray cylinder because the art team hasn’t shown up yet. Pater looks at the backgrounds of Michelangelo and sees something very like that, and he says so in one of his best sentences. “No forest-scenery like Titian’s fills his backgrounds, but only blank ranges of rock, and dim vegetable forms as blank as they, as in a world before the creation of the first five days.” It’s a joke with a theology folded inside it, and you need Genesis open on the desk to get it.
In the first chapter of Genesis the world is built in order, with light on the first day, the firmament on the second, dry land and grass and fruit trees on the third, sun, moon and stars on the fourth, fish and birds on the fifth, and land animals and finally human beings on the sixth. Man is the last arrival, moving into a house that has been lit, planted, furnished and stocked for five straight days before he gets the keys. Pater’s line imagines the reverse, a man standing in the world as it looked before any of that work was done, with rock where the orchards should be and dim green smudges where Titian would have painted a forest, so that Michelangelo’s people seem to arrive first and alone.
Pater builds the case with help from Herman Grimm, the German historian whose life of Michelangelo came out in the early 1860s and in English in 1865. “When one speaks of him,” Grimm says, “woods, clouds, seas, and mountains disappear, and only what is formed by the spirit of man remains behind,” and Pater adds that Grimm could find only “a few slight words from a letter of his to Vasari as the single expression in all he has left of a feeling for nature.” The letter, dated September 18, 1556, recalls a visit to hermits in the mountains of Spoleto. Back in Rome he tells Vasari that less than half of him has come home, because peace is to be found in the woods.
Set beside Leonardo, Pater’s point gets sharper, since he says Michelangelo “has traced no flowers, like those with which Leonardo stars over his gloomiest rocks,” and anyone who has looked at the Virgin of the Rocks knows that grotto is full of plants a botanist could name. Titian gives you forests with weather moving through them, while Michelangelo gives you a ledge and a body, and Pater’s phrase about the first five days explains why that’s less a lack of skill or interest than a different idea of what matters. A world that hasn’t been furnished yet is a world where the event that draws the eye is the arrival of a person, and that’s the event Michelangelo wants to paint over and over again.
Then Pater makes a claim you can check by simply looking up, and it doesn’t hold. “Of the whole story of the creation he has painted only the creation of the first man and woman, and, for him at least, feebly, the creation of light.” The ceiling, painted between 1508 and 1512, runs nine scenes from Genesis down its spine, and the first three are all about the world, with God separating light from darkness, God creating the sun, moon and plants, and God separating the land from the waters, all before Adam and Eve appear. So Pater has dropped two whole creation scenes from his count, and one of them contains the very plants he says Michelangelo never bothered with.
Go and look at those plants, though, because they’re the funniest thing on the ceiling. In the scene of the sun, moon and plants, painted around 1511, God appears twice, once on the right flinging the sun and moon into place with both arms, and once on the left flying away from us into the picture, seen from behind, stretching an arm toward a small bush. That bush stands for the whole vegetable kingdom, the third day’s work, every orchard and wheat field and forest Titian would ever paint, and Michelangelo gives it one modest shrub while giving the viewer a clear view of the Creator’s backside. Even when he does paint the plants, they’re an afterthought beside a body in motion, which is about as strong a confirmation of Pater’s point as anyone could ask for.
Pater’s “feebly” for the creation of light is harder to defend, because the scene above the altar shows God twisting in steep foreshortening from below as he pulls light from dark. Yet even this scene is a body, all torso and arms, with darkness and light reduced to a swirl around him. Michelangelo worked from the entrance end toward the altar, so the making of the world was the last thing he painted, as if he had to get through Noah and Adam before he could face the scenery. Pater’s next sentences explain the priority, because for Michelangelo the making of man “is not, as in the story itself, the last and crowning act of a series of developments, but the first and unique act, the creation of life itself in its supreme form, off-hand and immediately, in the cold and lifeless stone.”
So my verdict is that Pater gets the inventory wrong and the impression right, and that his mistake works almost as evidence. A critic who forgets two creation scenes on the most famous ceiling in the world is probably reporting what stays in the mind after you leave the chapel, which is bodies, with the plants and waters and lights absorbed into the bodies that make them. Readers should still know the ceiling’s real program, because Michelangelo did paint episodes from the first days and gave them tremendous force. But the force is all in God’s arms and back, and the world he makes looks a lot like Pater’s gray box, a stage built so that the only thing worth watching is a person arriving on it.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
Why does the author say Pater's description of Michelangelo's world reverses the sequence in Genesis?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- How can Pater's factual mistake about the ceiling function as evidence for the accuracy of his overall impression?→
- What does the article's contrast among Michelangelo, Titian and Leonardo suggest about how backgrounds reveal an artist's priorities?→
- If Michelangelo gives tremendous force to early creation scenes but locates that force mainly in God's body, should those scenes be understood as paintings of nature, paintings of persons, or both? Why?→