Greek Antiquity

Matter, Forms and a Shape-Shifter

The hymn gives Proteus the language of matter and forms, then asks him to bring pure providence to a human life.

Homer’s shape-changer becomes a figure for the many forms sacred matter can take. The closing prayer brings the same power to bear on the works and ending of a life.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • A wrestler meets a shape-changerHomer makes Menelaus hold on as Proteus takes the shapes of animals, water, and a tree.
  • The hymn names matter and formsThe philosophical words make the changes an account of how the world takes shape.
  • The stuff of change is sacredThe adjective makes the matter Proteus transforms worthy of attention in its own right.
  • The prayer asks for a life’s good endAfter showing the god changing himself, the hymn asks him to come with pure providence and send a good end to the celebrants’ work.

Orphic Hymns, XXV.2–3, 6, 10–11, with the note on XXV.3

The third line of the hymn to Proteus uses words that belong in a philosophy lecture. He “revealed the beginnings of all nature / by changing sacred matter into forms of many shapes,” and the Greek has hylē, matter, and ideai, forms, the pair that Plato and Aristotle had turned into the basic vocabulary of how things are made. The edition’s note calls them “the philosophical pair, in one line,” and counts them, with a handful of words in other hymns, “among the most technical vocabulary in the collection.” It then adds a caution, that “Whether any of it carries doctrine cannot be settled here,” since Proteus’s shape-shifting in Homer “needs no philosophy to describe it.”

The Homeric scene is worth remembering, because it shows what the philosophical words are doing. Menelaus, stranded in Egypt, has to seize the old man of the sea while he sleeps among his seals and hold on while Proteus turns into a lion, a serpent, a leopard, a great boar, running water and a tall tree, until at last he returns to his own shape and answers questions. In Homer the transformations are a wrestler’s tricks, a way of escaping a grip. The hymn takes those same transformations and describes them as matter changing into forms, so the shapes Proteus takes become the shapes that matter takes in the world, and the wrestling match becomes a picture of creation.

That’s what the vocabulary allows the hymn to say. Without “matter” and “forms,” Proteus is a strange sea creature who can disguise himself. With them, every change he undergoes is a case of the general process by which formless stuff becomes a lion or a tree or a stream, and his ability to become anything is the ability of matter to receive any form. Ancient readers of Homer made exactly this move, too, and commentators on the Odyssey record that some interpreted Proteus as matter itself, from which men, trees and water all come, while his daughter Eidothea, whose name echoes eidos, form, stood for the ordering thought.

The hymn adds a word that the philosophers would not usually have used, and it changes the tone, since the matter is called “sacred,” hierēn. In much of Platonic thought matter is the lowest thing there is, the shapeless stuff that gets in the way of perfect form, but here it is holy, and its changing into many shapes is a revelation, the way the beginnings of nature become visible. The hymn doesn’t look down on the shifting, material world. It treats the endless transformation of matter as the place where the god shows himself, which is a warmer view of the physical world than many of the philosophers who coined these terms would have allowed.

Line 6 then turns the changes inward, from the world to the god himself. “For he himself, having all things, changes himself,” so the transformations of the world are Proteus’s own self-transformations, the god becoming lion and tree and water in the way matter becomes them. On this reading Proteus isn’t a craftsman shaping material from outside, like Plato’s maker of the world working on a given stuff. He is the material that shapes itself, holding all things within and letting them out as forms, which makes him less a sculptor than a lump of clay that knows how to become every statue. The image is strange, but it solves a problem the philosophers worried over, how form and matter come together in the first place, by putting both inside one divine figure who is the stuff and the shaping at once.

The closing prayer moves the whole register from the cosmos to a single life. “But, father, come to the celebrants with pure providence / sending a good end of a blessed life upon their works.” Pronoia, providence or forethought, is another of the philosophers’ words, the Stoic term for the divine care that orders the world, and the note points out that it “returns in this hymn’s own last lines.” So the god whose changes shape all of nature is asked to apply the same forethought to the worshippers, guiding the shapes their lives take so that, in the end, their works come to a good and blessed conclusion.

That extension makes good sense once the hymn has described the world as matter taking form. A human life is also a kind of changing material, passing through childhood, labor, age and death, taking one shape after another, and the prayer asks the shape-changer to make sure the last shape is a good one. A Christian reader will hear the language of the old Prayer Book collect that speaks of God’s “never-failing providence” that orders all things in heaven and earth, and then asks God to put away from us all hurtful things. The hymn’s request has the same structure, a providence that governs the whole world asked to care for particular people at particular tasks.

My verdict is that the philosophical vocabulary lets the hymn reinterpret Homer’s wrestling shape-changer as an image of how the world itself takes shape, matter receiving every form, and that by calling the matter sacred it gives the material world a dignity the philosophers often denied it. The closing appeal to providence then carries that cosmic picture down to the celebrant’s life, asking the god whose self-transformations make up nature to guide each life’s changes toward a good end. Whether the words carried a full doctrine, as the note says, can’t be settled, but they let the hymn say something larger about change than Homer needed to.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

How does the article distinguish the function of Proteus’s transformations in Homer from their function in the hymn?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.