Renaissance
Lorenzo’s Florence and the Air Everyone Breathed
Pater imagines artists, philosophers, and people in public life learning from one another. What evidence would show that they did?
The Renaissance (1893)Pater compares Florence under Lorenzo de’ Medici with Athens under Pericles. His picture is strongest when a historian can follow an idea across a letter, workshop, or household, and weakest where a famous institution is harder to document than the story suggests.
Orientation
At a Glance
- Two kinds of contactPater imagines an age sharing a common air and people catching fire from one another’s thoughts. One image describes a shared setting. The other asks us to look for an exchange.
- Patrons can bring people togetherPlutarch’s Pericles links politics with philosophy and sculpture. Lorenzo’s Florence likewise offers households, commissions, and friendships that a historian can investigate.
- The academy is a test casePater describes regular Platonic meetings at Careggi. James Hankins’s study asks whether the evidence supports an institution or a less formal set of relationships.
- Venice offers a counterexamplePater praises Venetian painting for developing without the same alliance with philosophy. His comparison helps explain one kind of Florentine art while leaving room for other ways art can flourish.
The Renaissance · Preface, pp. 5–6 · Preface, note 16 · Pico della Mirandola, pp. 27–28 · Leonardo da Vinci, the Milan circle · The School of Giorgione, p. 93
Pater starts with the normal state of things, which is that the different kinds of mind in any age ignore each other. The activities that make up a culture “move for the most part from different starting-points, and by unconnected roads,” and among the people pursuing them “each group is solitary,” and they are “generally little curious of the thoughts of others.” You know this world, the physics department and the art school on the same campus that never once have lunch together. Then he describes the exceptions, the happier eras when “artists and philosophers and those whom the action of the world has elevated and made keen, do not live in isolation, but breathe a common air, and catch light and heat from each other’s thoughts.”
Look closely and there are two mechanisms packed into that sentence, carried by two different metaphors. One is air, a medium everyone shares without choosing it, and the other is fire, which spreads by contact from one burning thing to the next. Pater adds a third ingredient when he borrows a description of Periclean Athens and applies it to Lorenzo de’ Medici’s Florence, calling it “an age productive in personalities, many-sided, centralised, complete.” The word that matters there is “centralised,” because a culture that cross-pollinates needs a hub, somebody or some place that pulls the different groups into one room, and in both cities Pater has a single powerful figure in mind.
The comparison has real history behind it, since in Plutarch’s life of Pericles the Athenian statesman is a friend and pupil of the philosopher Anaxagoras and puts the sculptor Phidias in charge of his building program, so politics, philosophy and art really do sit at one table. Lorenzo was a poet as well as a banker and boss, he supported the philosopher Marsilio Ficino for part of Ficino’s career, kept company with the scholar-poet Poliziano, and took the teenage Michelangelo into his household. The edition’s note puts the point simply, that Pater has in mind a culture in which art, thought and public life develop in close contact, and the two cities offer a lot to work with.
But what would it take to prove the claim rather than just admire it? A historian would need three things, starting with channels, the documented contacts such as letters, shared houses, dinners and commissions, and going on to transfer, an idea that demonstrably moves from one field into another, so that a philosopher’s thought turns up in a painting or a poet’s phrase in a building. Last of all he would need a way of ruling out the dull alternative, that artists and thinkers flourished together because the same money and the same patron paid for both, rather than because they set each other on fire. Pater’s own chapters suggest places to look. He recounts Ficino’s story of meeting Pico on the day he finished translating Plato and describes Leonardo’s ties to the mathematician Luca Pacioli and the anatomist Marcantonio della Torre. The account of a meeting is a lead to check before drawing conclusions from it.
The cautionary tale is the most famous piece of common air in Lorenzo’s Florence. Pater tells you that Cosimo de’ Medici “had founded the Platonic academy,” with regular discussions at the villa of Careggi, and that institution became one of the great legends of the Renaissance. In a 1991 study, the historian James Hankins challenged the institutional story. The evidence for Ficino’s friendships and teaching gives us something more specific to investigate than a regularly convened academy. The most celebrated meeting place of Florentine minds partly dissolves when you ask for the minutes, which is exactly the kind of test Pater’s metaphor never invites.
That’s the trouble with air as an image, since air is everywhere and leaves no tracks, so it suits a claim you can feel but can’t footnote, and it lets Pater gesture at something that documents really do miss, the shared taste and vocabulary of a moment that nobody bothered to write down because everyone took it for granted. The fire metaphor is much better for a historian, because fire spreads by contact, and contact is something you can go looking for. If you want to keep Pater’s picture, you have to cash the air out as roads, letters and rooms, and then see how much of the picture survives, which is a test Pater never runs himself, though his own chapters hand you most of the materials for it.
Pater also makes a specific claim that you can test against his own book. He says the art of fifteenth-century Italy owes much of its grave dignity to “this intimate alliance with mind, this participation in the best thoughts which that age produced.” But a hundred pages later he praises Venetian painting precisely for being “unassisted, and therefore unperplexed, by naturalism, religious mysticism, philosophical theories,” and he treats Venice’s distance from philosophy as a strength. So by Pater’s own account great art can flourish without the common air, and the alliance with philosophy produces one kind of greatness, the grave Florentine kind, rather than greatness as such.
My verdict is that Pater’s picture is plausible and partly documented, but the metaphor he chose hides the work it would take to show it. A real inquiry would trade the air for roads, the letters, households and commissions through which ideas actually moved, and it would have to take seriously cases like the Academy, where the legend outran the evidence, and cases like Venice, where great art grew without the alliance at all. I’d keep the image because it names something real, but I’d treat it as a hypothesis with a checklist attached, and not as a description of what Florence was like, at least until somebody has walked the roads and counted the letters.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
What distinction does the article draw between Pater’s metaphors of air and fire?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- What kinds of evidence would persuade you that a shared cultural atmosphere caused ideas to move between fields rather than merely reflecting common patronage or circumstances?→
- If the metaphor of “air” captures aspects of culture that people took for granted and never documented, how can historians investigate those aspects without turning a plausible impression into an unsupported claim?→
- How should the challenged story of the Platonic Academy and the contrasting example of Venice affect our confidence in Pater’s larger picture of Renaissance culture?→