Renaissance
Looking for a Lost Horse in a Prisoner’s Room
Leonardo’s clay horse is gone. Pater goes looking for it in a bronze in Venice and in Ludovico Sforza’s painted prison cell.
The Renaissance (1893)Leonardo’s studies document a monument that never reached bronze. Verrocchio’s Colleoni offers a comparison, while the inscriptions at Loches leave Pater’s most moving conjecture open.
Orientation
At a Glance
- A monument stopped before castingLeonardo made the clay horse for Francesco Sforza, but the bronze intended for the monument was diverted to make cannon.
- What survives on paperLeonardo’s drawings document changes to the horse’s pose and plans for casting it on a huge scale.
- The comparison in VeniceVerrocchio modeled the Colleoni monument. Alessandro Leopardi cast the surviving bronze after Verrocchio’s death.
- The prisoner’s roomPater imagines that the painted cell preserves Ludovico’s memories of the project. Its surviving motifs and inscriptions tell us more securely about the captivity.
The Renaissance · Leonardo da Vinci, p. 73, the Sforza commission · Leonardo da Vinci, note 177 · Leonardo da Vinci, p. 81, the model, Colleoni and Loches · Leonardo da Vinci, note 194 · Leonardo da Vinci, note 195
In the Martelet tower at Loches there’s a low vaulted cell whose walls are covered with faded paint, and tradition says the man who painted them was Ludovico Sforza, once duke of Milan, who, according to the Cité royale de Loches, likely died there as a French prisoner in 1508. Pater sends his imagination into that room looking for something that was never there, Leonardo’s colossal horse for the monument to Ludovico’s father, Francesco Sforza. It’s the instinct of a true-crime podcaster hunting for clues on a cell wall, and it produces one of Pater’s most touching guesses. It also gives us a clean lesson in what different kinds of evidence can carry, because in one paragraph he leans on three of them, the drawings, a surviving statue and the prisoner’s room.
Start with what was lost, the monument Pater says Leonardo came to Milan “to model,” which the edition’s note describes as a full-scale clay horse that was never cast. The clay model, perhaps seven meters high, was ready by autumn 1493. In 1494, with a French army marching down Italy, Ludovico sent the bronze set aside for it to Ercole d’Este of Ferrara to make cannon. Pater handles the famous story of what happened next with proper caution, writing that “whether or not the Gascon bowmen used it as a mark for their arrows, the model of Francesco Sforza certainly did not survive.”
Pater is right to pause over the story of the bowmen. The clay model disappeared after the French took Milan, an event the edition’s note dates to 1499. What remains is what Pater mentions next, “certain of Leonardo’s drawings.” The studies and notes at Windsor show how he planned to lift the huge mould and channel molten bronze into it.
Those drawings carry a surprise that matters later on. After a few early sketches of a rider on a rearing horse, the surviving studies give us much more of the horse than of Francesco, from the animal’s overall pose to measurements of its legs. The monument that Pater says “had occupied the two so much during the days of their good fortune at Milan” comes down to us chiefly through drawings of the horse. Hold on to that, because Pater’s last clue depends entirely on the rider.
His second piece of evidence is an analogue, and it’s a good one. To show “of what nobility, amid what racy truthfulness to fact” such work was capable, he points to Verrocchio’s bronze of the mercenary captain Bartolomeo Colleoni, “still standing in the piazza,” the square, “of Saint John and Saint Paul at Venice.” Verrocchio was Leonardo’s master and the commission was the same kind, an armored soldier on a striding horse, so it’s the right sort of comparison. The anecdote Pater attaches is shakier, since he says Verrocchio “died of grief” when the mould failed, while Vasari offers a different account of Verrocchio’s death. The Venice municipal record says Verrocchio supplied the model and Alessandro Leopardi was commissioned to cast it after Verrocchio died in 1488. Leopardi’s name appears on the finished monument.
Then comes the third clue, and here Pater moves from evidence to wish. Ludovico was captured at Novara in April 1500 and held in France, at Loches from 1504 until his death, and Pater pictures him, after “many years of captivity in the dungeons below,” allowed into “one of the rooms of the great tower,” its walls covered with “strange painted arabesques, ascribed by tradition to his hand.” Among “those vast helmets and human faces and pieces of armour,” he says, the motto Infelix Sum, I am unhappy, “is woven in and out,” and it is “perhaps not too fanciful” to see in them “a wistful after-dreaming over Leonardo’s sundry experiments on the armed figure of the great duke.” It’s a gorgeous sentence, the fallen patron in a tower painting half-remembered fragments of the monument his artist never finished.
The painted room that can be visited today is the cell itself. The castle’s account of the restored paintings identifies a surviving French inscription, celui qui n’est pas content, meaning the one who is discontented. It has the same unhappy note as the Latin motto Pater cites. The preserved inscription gives us firmer evidence for the captivity than it does for any memory of Leonardo’s horse.
To be fair to Pater, the link he wants isn’t absurd, since a defeated duke painting himself in a helmet is drawing on the same courtly language that produced the equestrian monument, and patron and artist really had spent years on the image of a Sforza on horseback. The drawings give us a much better record of the horse than of the rider, and the painted cell supplies no clear link to Leonardo’s design. My verdict is that each kind of evidence licenses one kind of claim. The Colleoni supports a claim about scale and ambition, the drawings support claims about the horse itself, and the prison room gives us a visible trace of Ludovico’s captivity. The conjecture enters exactly where Pater stops asking which kind of evidence he’s holding, and anyone who wants Leonardo’s lost horse will find far more of it at Windsor than at Loches.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
Why does the author regard Verrocchio’s Colleoni monument as a useful analogue for Leonardo’s lost Sforza project?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- How does the author distinguish between evidence that establishes a historical fact and an analogue that helps readers imagine a lost work?→
- When, if ever, is Pater’s imaginative connection between the prison paintings and Leonardo’s monument justified despite the lack of a clear visual link?→
- How would the interpretation of the lost monument change if readers relied only on the Windsor drawings and excluded the Colleoni statue and the Loches cell?→