Renaissance
Leonardo’s Return to Nature Ran Through Ancient Books
Pater assigns antiquity to Raphael and observation to Leonardo. The two men of science he names show how often Leonardo used old books to ask new questions.
The Renaissance (1893)Luca Pacioli’s geometry and Marcantonio della Torre’s anatomy complicate Pater’s account of how Leonardo learned from nature.
Orientation
At a Glance
- Pater’s divisionPater makes Raphael stand for a return to antiquity and Leonardo for a return to nature.
- Geometry from an old traditionLeonardo’s drawings of solids for Luca Pacioli made ancient geometry easier to see and study.
- Anatomy checked by dissectionLeonardo’s work around the time of his probable association with della Torre shows direct observation testing what ancient medicine taught.
- A productive crossingThe classical sources Leonardo sought and the objects he observed helped him ask better questions of each other.
The Renaissance · Pater on the two returns and Leonardo’s collaborators · Diotimos editorial note on Bacon’s subtlety of nature · Diotimos editorial note on Pacioli · Diotimos editorial note on della Torre · Pacioli’s 1509 Divina proportione, Royal Collection · Leonardo’s anatomical research and della Torre, Royal Collection · Leonardo’s Vitruvian Man, Gallerie dell’Accademia · Plato, Timaeus 55c–56c, Greek text and translation
Pater likes a clean division, and this one is very clean. The movement of the fifteenth century, he says, was twofold, partly the Renaissance and partly the arrival of the modern spirit, “with its realism, its appeal to experience,” and so “it comprehended a return to antiquity, and a return to nature.” Then he assigns the roles, writing that “Raphael represents the return to antiquity, and Leonardo the return to nature.” It’s like sorting a record collection into remastered classics and field recordings, and it feels right for about a minute, until Pater names the men Leonardo spent his time with, since he says Leonardo was “often in intimate relations with men of science,” and names the mathematician Luca Pacioli and the anatomist Marcantonio della Torre.
Start with Pacioli, a Franciscan friar from Sansepolcro who came to Milan in 1496 and quickly became Leonardo’s friend and teacher. Leonardo drew about sixty plates for Pacioli’s De divina proportione, On the Divine Proportion, which was written in Milan between 1496 and 1498 and printed in Venice in 1509, and most of the solids appear in pairs, one with solid faces and one as a hollow skeleton you can see straight through, which lets the reader see relationships that solid faces would conceal. The five regular solids at the heart of the book recall Plato’s Timaeus, which connects four of them with the elements and has the maker use the fifth for the universe as a whole, and the book’s third part is an Italian version of Piero della Francesca’s Latin treatise on the same bodies.
Pacioli’s other great project was the geometry of Euclid. He lectured on the Elements, and in 1509 he published a Latin edition in Venice, built on the medieval translation by Campanus with his own corrections and notes. Leonardo, who called himself a man without letters, copied and worked through Euclidean figures in his notebooks. In another note he reminds himself to learn “the multiplication of roots” from Maestro Luca. So the first man of science Pater names turns out to be a reviver of Plato and Euclid, and the geometry that runs through Leonardo’s later work came to him as a return to antiquity, delivered by a friar with an ancient book under his arm.
Della Torre makes the same point from the side of medicine. Born in Verona in 1481, he taught at Padua and moved to Pavia as professor of anatomy in 1510, then died the next year at Riva on Lake Garda, barely thirty. Vasari’s 1568 edition connects the two men and praises della Torre for bringing Galen’s teaching to medicine and anatomy. Pater’s anatomist, then, was a Galen man, part of the humanist effort to recover ancient medicine from its medieval digests. The collaboration itself is shakier than Pater makes it sound, since the two overlapped for a year or so, and Leonardo had been drawing human skulls since 1489, when della Torre was about eight.
Leonardo also hunted down ancient books on his own account. His memoranda include notes like “Borges shall get for you the Archimedes from the bishop of Padua,” and “Messer Vincenzio Aliprando, who lives near the Inn of the Bear, has Giacomo Andrea’s Vitruvius,” which reads like someone working the waiting list at a library. The famous drawing of a man inside a circle and a square, from around 1490, takes a sentence from Vitruvius, the Roman architect, about the proportions of the human body and tests it on a figure who looks as if he’d just stepped out of the bath. Pater’s champion of the return to nature spent a lot of energy getting his hands on antiquity.
The other side deserves a fair hearing, because Pater’s contrast catches something real about attitude. Leonardo wrote that “Any one who in discussion relies upon authority uses, not his understanding, but rather his memory,” and his anatomical work sometimes tested inherited claims against what dissection showed. Raphael, for his part, really did paint antiquity as a place to live in, and in the School of Athens of around 1510 the figure of Plato has traditionally been said to resemble Leonardo, while Euclid bends over a slate with his compasses. The suggested likeness is fitting, given how much of that ancient world Leonardo himself studied.
Pater’s own Latin tag helps sort this tangle out. He says Leonardo’s finish matched nature’s finesse, her delicacy, the subtilitas naturae, the subtlety of nature, that Francis Bacon notices, and Bacon meant that nature’s subtlety far outruns the subtlety of our senses and our arguments. That principle cuts against any book whatever, ancient or modern, and so it doesn’t set nature against antiquity at all. It says that every text, Euclid’s or Galen’s or Pacioli’s, has to be put back against things, which is exactly what the partnerships look like, with ancient solids modeled and drawn as see-through frames, and received anatomy checked on the dissecting table.
My verdict is that Pater’s division works as a description of what the two painters’ pictures look like and fails as a map of how they learned. The ancient philosophers in Raphael’s fresco and the rocks and water in Leonardo’s paintings give Pater’s contrast a foothold, but the return to antiquity and the return to nature weren’t separate roads with one painter on each. They were the same road walked in both directions, out of the library and into the world and back again with questions, and Leonardo’s collaborations sit right at the crossing. Pater chose the right companions to name, and the irony is that they make his case against himself, since the men of science were the antiquarians, and the antiquity they recovered sent Leonardo back to nature with sharper tools.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
Why does the author consider Pacioli an ironic example for Pater to use as evidence of Leonardo’s association with science?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- When does consulting an ancient authority support empirical inquiry, and when might it interfere with such inquiry, based on the examples in the article?→
- How does the uncertainty surrounding Leonardo’s collaboration with della Torre affect the article’s broader argument about antiquity, anatomy, and experience?→
- If every text must be tested against things in the world, does the distinction between a return to antiquity and a return to nature retain any useful meaning? Why or why not?→