Renaissance
Leonardo’s Quicksilver Toys and the Trouble in Rome
Pater pictures Leonardo stalled among wax animals and mirrors. Leonardo’s letters bring the trouble into focus through a workshop quarrel and a dispute over dissection.
The Renaissance (1893)Vasari’s lively stories and Leonardo’s own complaints give two very different ways into Pater’s portrait of the artist at the Vatican.
Orientation
At a Glance
- A room in motionVasari tells stories of hollow wax animals, a lizard fitted with wings and inflated sheep intestines.
- Pater’s explanationPater links Leonardo’s hesitation in Rome to supposed suspicion of his loyalties to France.
- Leonardo’s own complaintIn a draft letter, Leonardo blames a mirror-maker for interfering with his work and criticizing his anatomical studies to the pope.
- A story the evidence can supportThe complaints document conflict at work and help separate it from Pater’s more speculative account of political suspicion.
The Renaissance · Pater on Leonardo’s Roman workshop and his move toward France · Vasari’s account of the wax animals and the lizard · Leonardo’s draft complaint to Giuliano de’ Medici, Museo Galileo · Leonardo’s letters and notes, translated by Jean Paul Richter · Leonardo’s final years, Royal Collection
“We catch a glimpse of Leonardo again, at Rome in 1514, surrounded by his mirrors and vials and furnaces, making strange toys that seemed alive of wax and quicksilver.” He was in his sixties and lodged in the Belvedere, the papal villa on the Vatican hill, where one of the pope’s architects had listed rooms to be fitted out for him in December 1513, and his patron was Giuliano de’ Medici, the new pope’s brother. Then Pater turns the room into a portrait, since “the hesitation which had haunted him all through life, and made him like one under a spell, was upon him now with double force.” It’s the image of a legendary old director tinkering with puppets in his garage while the studio forgets to call, and everything in it moves except the man.
The toys come from Vasari, and they’re as wonderful as anything in his book. In Rome, he says, Leonardo made a paste of wax and shaped thin hollow animals that flew through the air when he blew into them, until the breath ran out and they dropped. When the Belvedere’s vine-dresser found an odd-looking lizard, Leonardo fixed wings on its back with quicksilver, made from scales stripped off other lizards, so that they quivered as it walked, added eyes, horns and a beard, and kept it in a box to send his friends running. He cleaned a wether’s guts so fine they fitted in a palm, then pumped them up with a bellows in the next room until they filled the space and pushed visitors into the corners, comparing them to virtue. These are a biographer’s stories of court entertainment, and their details give Pater a vivid scene.
Pater sets the toys inside a political story about loyalty. “No one had ever carried political indifferentism further,” he writes, adding that “it had always been his philosophy to ‘fly before the storm’; he is for the Sforzas, or against them, as the tide of their fortune turns.” The record bears out the changes in patrons, since Leonardo worked for the Sforza, for the French in Milan, for Borgia, for the Florentine republic and for the Medici, and his note on Ludovico’s fall in 1499 reads, in Jean Paul Richter’s translation, like a line in a ledger, “The Duke has lost the state, property and liberty and none of his entreprises was carried out by him.” Pater gives no source for the motto in quotation marks.
Then comes the claim that sets up the paralysis. “Yet now, in the political society of Rome, he came to be suspected of secret French sympathies,” and the result, Pater says, was that “it paralysed him to find himself among enemies.” Leonardo’s own drafts of letters to Giuliano tell a different story about the enemies he had in Rome. Two German craftsmen were attached to his workshop, a Giorgio who was supposed to assist him and a Giovanni known for his mirrors, and Leonardo complains that the mirror-maker spied on everything he did, spread gossip about it, filled the Belvedere with mirror workshops and turned Giorgio against him. Worst of all, he writes, the man “hindered me in anatomy, blaming it before the Pope; and likewise at the hospital,” where Leonardo had been dissecting.
What his own papers document is a quarrel about mirrors and a complaint about interference with anatomical work. It’s a more ordinary story, and in some ways a more humiliating one, a painter and engineer trying to hold his ground in a disputed workshop. The mirrors themselves were serious work, concave burning mirrors meant to gather sunlight to a point, which gives the mirror quarrel a practical importance beside the dispute over dissection. Rome in those years belonged to Raphael’s frescoes and Michelangelo’s marble, and Leonardo had a patron who was often ill and who died in March 1516, a loss he seems to have joked about bitterly in a notebook line saying the Medici had made him and destroyed him, with a pun on medici, the Italian for doctors.
How, then, does Pater’s room of toys work as a picture? The objects “seemed alive” while their maker is “like one under a spell,” so the animation has passed from the man into his gadgets, and the life of a great career seems to be leaking out into wax and quicksilver. That’s a brilliant piece of staging, the way a time-lapse of a busy street makes the one person standing still look stranded. The interior full of movement makes the hesitation vivid because hesitation is otherwise invisible, and Pater needs something in the frame to move so that we notice what doesn’t.
The other side has a point, because Leonardo’s French connections were real and his departure fits Pater’s outline. He had served Louis XII in Milan for years as the king’s painter and engineer, the French victory at Marignano in 1515 rearranged Italian politics, and within months of Giuliano’s death he was on his way to the court of Francis I. A man who’d spent years on the French payroll may well have been eyed warily by some Roman courtiers. The trouble is that the papers from those years speak of a lost workspace, a blocked anatomy program and a dying patron, while the French suspicion lives mainly in Pater’s sentence.
My verdict is that Pater makes superb use of the toys Vasari describes, since a room of things that seem alive around a man who can’t act is the perfect emblem of a stalled genius. The cause he gives is the romantic one, though, and the documents point elsewhere. The letters bring workshop rivalry and the limits of patronage into view. Pater’s toys make those constraints imaginable, even if the anecdotes cannot tell us what caused Leonardo’s difficulties. Vasari’s wax animals are the right image for those years, flying beautifully for as long as the breath lasts and then falling back to the floor.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
Why does the article consider Pater’s depiction of moving toys especially effective?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- How does the contrast between animated objects and an inactive maker shape your judgment of Leonardo in Pater’s portrait?→
- When literary interpretation and surviving documents suggest different causes for a person’s difficulties, how should a reader weigh each kind of evidence?→
- Does the article’s final image of the wax animals falling when their breath runs out clarify Leonardo’s Roman years, or does it risk making a complicated situation seem too simple?→