Renaissance

Leonardo’s Lost Paradise

Vasari describes a tapestry design in which Leonardo attended to every leaf. Pater sees its perfection as the beginning of dissatisfaction.

The lost cartoon lets Pater imagine a turn away from an earlier style. Leonardo’s surviving drawings show that the close attention to plants continued.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • Vasari remembers a design for weavingAdam and Eve stand among a great variety of plants. Vasari singles out the labor Leonardo gave to the fig tree and the palm.
  • Pater turns patience into a problemThe cartoon brings an earlier Florentine manner to perfection in his account. He imagines that the achievement made Leonardo restless.
  • The surviving works complicate the breakThe Annunciation and Adoration show different uses of detail. A later drawing of the Star of Bethlehem still gives individual leaves close attention.
  • What changes is what detail can doA leaf can decorate a garden and can also become something to investigate. Leonardo’s later work gives Pater’s claim a slower, more visible development.

In Vasari’s account, Leonardo was asked to make a cartoon for a door-hanging, to be woven in gold and silk in Flanders and sent to the King of Portugal, showing Adam and Eve sinning in the earthly paradise. He drew it with the brush in light and shade, heightened with lead white, and filled the meadow with countless kinds of plants and some animals. Vasari singles out a fig tree whose leaves were foreshortened with such loving care that the mind reels at how a man could have such patience, and a palm whose crown of fronds needed all of Leonardo’s skill. Vasari says the work remained a cartoon and locates it in Ottaviano de’ Medici’s house. The design is now lost.

Pater turns that vanished drawing into a hinge for his whole account of Leonardo. It was, he says, “the perfection of the older Florentine style of miniature-painting, with patient putting of each leaf upon the trees and each flower in the grass, where the first man and woman were standing.” And because it was the perfection of that style, “it awoke in Leonardo some seed of discontent which lay in the secret places of his nature.” Then comes one of Pater’s most quotable lines, “the way to perfection is through a series of disgusts,” and Leonardo plunges into the study of nature, leaving the old slight manner behind.

It’s worth noticing how convenient a lost object is for this job. Nobody can go and look at it, so it can be exactly as perfect as the argument needs, the way a band’s lost early recordings become legendary precisely because nobody’s heard them. Vasari’s praise is all about patience and truth to nature, and Pater cleverly turns that same patience into the thing Leonardo had to escape. The leaf-by-leaf care that Vasari admired becomes, in Pater’s telling, the prison of a style that had nowhere left to go. And Vasari’s highest praise, that the mind reels at such patience, is exactly the kind of compliment a restless young artist might come to dread, since it rewards endurance more than discovery.

The psychology behind Pater’s story is real enough, and familiar. Plenty of artists hit the peak of a manner and then refuse to repeat it, like a band that nails its signature sound and then won’t make the same record twice. And there’s surviving evidence of a turn in Leonardo’s early career. His Annunciation in the Uffizi, painted in his early twenties, has a lawn sewn with flowers like a carpet, very much the patient Florentine manner Pater describes, while his Adoration of the Magi, begun in 1481 and left unfinished when he went to Milan, is a churning, shadowy crowd around ruins, a completely different idea of what a painting could be. In the Adoration, the people and ruins make the activity of the whole scene more pressing than any single detail.

But did he really leave the patient leaves behind, as Pater implies? The evidence says he didn’t, and it says so emphatically. Years later he made a study of a Star of Bethlehem and other plants, its leaves whirling out from the center in a spiral, studied with an intensity that makes the flowers on the Annunciation lawn look like wallpaper. Plants also help define the terrain in the Virgin of the Rocks. What changed wasn’t Leonardo’s patience with leaves but what the patience was for, since he stopped placing each leaf as an ornament and started asking how leaves grow, turn toward light and arrange themselves around a stem. Even in the late Saint Anne, the stones and plants at the figures’ feet are seen with a geologist’s eye rather than a decorator’s.

Pater’s own next sentences actually support that reading better than his word “disgust” does. Leonardo’s art, he says, “must be weighted with more of the meaning of nature and purpose of humanity,” and he quotes the idea of nature as “the true mistress of higher intelligences.” That’s not a rejection of detail, since it’s a demand that detail mean something. The discontent Pater describes is real, but it’s a dissatisfaction with decoration, and the cure was more attention to nature, not less, which is the opposite of throwing out the patient leaves.

There’s also something revealing in how much Pater loves this kind of turn. His whole book is about the moment when a style ripens and something stranger begins inside it, and “the way to perfection is through a series of disgusts” is as much a description of his own restless taste as of Leonardo’s career. The lost Paradise works for him because it lets him dramatize that idea with a single object, a summit you can climb in a sentence and leave in the next, without having to show the slow, untidy overlap of old and new that the surviving works reveal.

So here’s my verdict on the hinge Pater builds out of a missing object. The tapestry design makes a perfect hinge precisely because it’s lost, and Pater uses it brilliantly to mark the point where Leonardo’s Florentine apprenticeship gives way to something larger. But the evidence suggests a change of purpose rather than a flight from patience, since the later drawings still give leaves sustained attention. What he outgrew was the idea of a leaf as decoration, and Pater’s “series of disgusts” is better read as a series of deeper questions.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

Why does the article consider the loss of the Paradise cartoon especially useful to Pater’s argument?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.