Greek Antiquity

Knowing Everything by Holding Everything

Proteus knows what was, is, and will be. The hymn places that knowledge beside his possession of all things.

Two uses of the Greek word for “for” may explain how Proteus knows everything. The poem’s compressed lines also let the claims of knowing and containing stand side by side.

Orientation

At a Glance

  • A formula for the seerProteus is said to know present things, everything that came before, and everything that will follow.
  • Two reasons may followThe repeated “for” links the god’s knowledge with his ability to contain all things and change himself.
  • Homer connects changes with truthMenelaus must hold Proteus through every transformation before the god gives him the knowledge he seeks.
  • The grammar leaves roomThe article favors reading containment as an explanation, while the poem leaves the connection unstated in a complete sentence.

Orphic Hymns, XXV.4–9, with the note on XXV.4–5

The middle of the hymn to Proteus makes two big claims in a row. First he is “all-honoured, of many counsels, knowing what now is / and whatever was before and whatever will be after,” and the note identifies this as “the seer’s formula,” the same words Homer uses of the prophet Kalchas, adding that “In Homer Proteus is precisely a prophet who must be held while he changes.” Then the hymn says, “for he himself, having all things, changes himself,” and three lines later, “for the first nature laid all things up in Proteus.” The question is whether the second claim explains the first, whether Proteus knows everything because he holds everything, or whether the two simply stand side by side and make each other more impressive.

The case for an explanation starts with the grammar of the passage. Both of the containment lines begin with gar, “for,” the Greek word that gives a reason, so the hymn seems to be saying that Proteus is all-knowing for this reason, that he has all things in himself. And the reasoning has deep roots in Greek thought. Empedocles held that we know each thing by the same thing in ourselves, earth by earth and water by water, so knowledge comes by likeness, and a being that contains all things would by that principle know all things. The Stoics added that the divine reason holds the seed-patterns of everything that will grow, so a god who contains those patterns contains the future as well as the present.

Later Platonists drew exactly this conclusion about Proteus. The Neoplatonist Proclus, writing a couple of centuries after these hymns, interpreted him as a kind of divine mind holding within itself the forms of all things that come to be and pass away, so that his knowledge of past, present and future followed from his containing the patterns of everything that ever changes. On that view the hymn’s two claims fit together perfectly. To hold all forms is to know all things, and to know all things is the seer’s privilege, so the “for” is doing exactly what it says.

The case for juxtaposition deserves a fair hearing, though, because the evidence for it is real. The hymns use “for” loosely, as a connective that moves praise along, and the first gar here may be explaining something other than the knowledge. Line 6 goes on to say that no other immortal changes in the way Proteus does, so the “for” may be grounding his uniqueness among the gods rather than his foresight. And Homer’s Proteus knows things for a simpler reason, because he knows the depths of every sea and has seen everything that happens in his domain. On this reading, the hymn places the seer’s knowledge next to the claim of total containment and lets the two titles amplify each other, without committing to how one produces the other.

The Homeric story offers a clue that brings the two readings closer together. In the Odyssey, the way to get the truth out of Proteus is to hold onto him while he turns into everything, lion, serpent, leopard, boar, water, tree, and only when he has run through his transformations and returned to himself does he speak. The knowledge comes from the one who has become everything. Even in Homer, then, there is a link between becoming all things and knowing all things, though the poem presents it as a test of the hero’s grip rather than as a theory of knowledge.

The hymn compresses all this into a few lines, and the compression is what makes the question hard. It never says “he knows because he contains,” it says he knows, and then, “for” he has all things and changes himself, and “for” the first nature laid all things in him. A reader can supply the link and find a real explanation, rooted in Empedocles and the Stoics, or can let the claims stand together as a cumulative portrait of a god who is all-knowing and all-holding at once. It’s a bit like reading a reference that says a scholar has read everything and knows everything, where you’re left to decide whether the second follows from the first or is just a second compliment. Most readers would take the first as the reason for the second, and that natural inference is probably what the hymn’s singers made too, without needing the philosophers to spell it out.

A Christian reader may think of the line in Hebrews that “all things are naked and opened unto the eyes of him with whom we have to do,” where God’s complete knowledge follows from the fact that nothing is hidden from him, everything lying open before the one who made it. The logic is different, since there knowledge comes from sight rather than containment, but it shares the conviction that total knowledge and total relationship to all things go together. The Proteus hymn puts the relationship in its most intimate form, everything not just seen by the god but laid up inside him.

My verdict is that the hymn does offer an explanation, signaled by its two uses of “for” and grounded in an old Greek principle that like is known by like, so that a being who contains all things knows all things, past, present and future alike. But the explanation is compressed to the point where it also works as juxtaposition, the two claims intensifying each other without the mechanism being spelled out. Proteus knows everything because he holds everything, and he holds everything as the god who becomes everything, which is the same truth Homer told as a wrestling match on a beach in Egypt.

Test your understanding

123

Question 1 of 3

Why does the author treat the hymn’s two uses of gar (“for”) as evidence that containment explains Proteus’s knowledge?

Choose one answer

Guided Inquiry

Questions for Socrates

Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.