Greek Antiquity
Is the Moon’s Double Nature Just Her Phases?
The Moon waxes and wanes, is called female and male, and is repeatedly addressed as a maiden.
The Orphic Collection, Volume I: The HymnsThe hymn puts the Moon’s phases beside her double nature without assigning one sex to each phase. The article considers the coexistence of Greek and Anatolian lunar identities as another way to read the line.
Orientation
At a Glance
- Two pairs share a lineThe hymn calls the Moon both waxing and waning and female and male.
- Maiden remains a repeated titleThe prayer calls the Moon a maiden in the opening praise, later in the hymn, and in the final request.
- Selene and Mene stand togetherThe opening addresses the same lunar power as Selene and Mene.
- The phases frame the double natureThe article proposes that the changing appearance of the Moon makes room for a plurality the language of the phases leaves unexplained.
The fourth line of the hymn to Selene packs two pairs of opposites together, “waxing and waning, female and male.” The edition’s note says that the double nature “is stated as a phase of the moon, not as a doctrine,” and compares the first-born god of Hymn VI, who is twofold as a matter of theology. That’s a reasonable first reading, since the moon visibly changes, so a goddess who grows and shrinks might also be imagined as changing sex, but it raises an obvious follow-up. If the phases explain it, which phase is which?
The hymn does give you a pattern to try, since the two pairs stand in parallel order, so a reader might map waxing to female and waning to male, and you could invent a story for that, the growing moon as fertile and maternal and the shrinking moon as something harder. The grammar won’t cooperate, though, because both participles, auxomenē and leipomenē, waxing and waning, are feminine in form, so even when she wanes the Greek still calls her “she,” and nothing in the line marks either phase as the male one. Any particular mapping is the reader’s invention, and I don’t think one can be defended.
The rest of the hymn pushes the same way. She is “fair-starred maiden” at line 3, “all-wise maiden” at line 10, and the very last word of the hymn is “maiden” again. A goddess addressed three times as kourē, a girl, isn’t being imagined as half the time a man, and the male side never gets an epithet of its own, no male title, no male role, no masculine form anywhere else in the poem. So the phases may set up the idea of a changing moon, but they can’t carry the full weight of “female and male.” If anything, the repeated maiden makes the male half of the line stand out more sharply, as a possibility the hymn names once and then sets aside.
There’s a better explanation sitting in the first lines. The hymn calls the goddess both Selene and Mene, and Mene twice, and the note on those lines points out that “the Greek and the Anatolian moon stand together without distinction,” adding that Men, the Anatolian moon god, was invoked in the Prayer at line 40. Men was male, a young god with a crescent rising behind his shoulders, worshipped all over the inland towns of Asia Minor, so in the world these hymns come from, the moon really was both a goddess and a god, depending on whose temple you walked into. A worshipper in a city of western Asia Minor might pass a shrine of Men on the way to a festival of Selene, and a hymn that wanted to reach the moon in that landscape had good reason to admit both.
That doubleness was widely known and even argued about. In Plato’s Symposium, Aristophanes explains that the original humans came in three kinds, the male descended from the sun, the female from the earth, and the double-sexed from the moon, “because the moon also partakes of both.” Macrobius reports that men sacrificed to the moon dressed as women and women dressed as men, because she was thought to be male and female at once. And the Roman Historia Augusta tells a story about the people of Carrhae, who held that a man who worshipped the moon as female would be ruled by his wife, while one who worshipped the moon as male would rule his.
So the “female and male” of line 4 looks less like a deduction from the phases than like a recognition of what everybody around the Aegean knew, that the moon had been worshipped under both sexes and that a prayer meant to reach her had better cover both. Placing it beside waxing and waning makes it feel natural, since change is the moon’s nature, but the content comes from cult and story rather than from astronomy. The note’s point that it isn’t doctrine still holds, since the hymn builds no theology on it, but it isn’t only a phase either.
How do the different epithets change what we expect of her, then? The maiden titles lead you to a young, bright, watchful goddess, “lover of the vigil,” “of gracious face,” the one who saves “these new suppliants.” The male possibility opens a door to the Anatolian Men, a lord of months by whom people swore oaths, whose name is simply the Greek word for month. And the phase words remind you that she is never the same two nights running, so any single picture of her is provisional. The hymn holds all three expectations at once and asks the goddess, under whatever form she likes, to come. That’s an old habit of Greek prayer, which often added “or by whatever name you wish to be called” to cover a god’s uncertain identity, and the moon hymn achieves the same insurance with a pair of adjectives instead of a formula.
My verdict is that the phases don’t explain the double nature, they frame it. No mapping of waxing and waning onto female and male survives the grammar or the hymn’s triple “maiden,” and the male side is best explained by the moon’s double identity in the hymns’ own world, Greek Selene and Anatolian Men, which the poem names side by side. The hymn addresses a maiden who might also be a god, in a line that uses the moon’s visible changeableness to make that possibility feel at home.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
Why does the author reject a fixed correspondence between waxing/female and waning/male?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- How does the hymn’s repeated description of the moon as a maiden affect the force of its single reference to her as male?→
- What interpretive risks arise when readers turn the parallel order of two pairs of words into a fixed correspondence between them?→
- If the hymn is designed to address the moon under uncertain names and forms, how might that purpose change the way we understand apparent contradictions within it?→