Renaissance
Is the Body’s Outline as Real as a Flame?
Pater calls the body’s outline an image we make, then compares life to a flame. His metaphors allow a form to be real even while the material making it changes.
The Renaissance (1893)Pater’s account of the body invites two readings of the same edge. The difference matters when he asks how a changing person can keep paying attention.
Orientation
At a Glance
- The eye sees a crisp edgeThe mirror shows a contour that makes the body look separate from the world around it.
- Pater calls that contour our imageThe wording leaves open how much of the outline belongs to the body and how much to the observer’s way of grouping what they see.
- A form can last through exchangeCuvier’s vortex and Pater’s flame both offer ways to imagine a real organization that keeps taking in and losing material.
- Attention needs enough continuity to be practicedThe concluding demand to keep burning gains force if a changing person can sustain a pattern over time.
The Renaissance · 1893 Conclusion, outline, design and flame · Note 329, a design in a web · 1893 Conclusion, the weaving and unweaving of ourselves · 1893 Conclusion, keeping the flame alive · 1873 Conclusion, the original web analogy · Georges Cuvier, Le Règne animal, the life of a body as a vortex
Look in a mirror and what you see first is an outline, the edge of a cheek, the line of a shoulder, the shape that tells you where you stop and the bathroom starts. Pater goes after that outline in one of the Conclusion’s most compressed sentences, saying “That clear, perpetual outline of face and limb is but an image of ours, under which we group them,” and then he gives the image itself, “a design in a web, the actual threads of which pass out beyond it.” A sentence later he adds the flame, saying our life is “but the concurrence, renewed from moment to moment, of forces parting sooner or later on their ways.” The question is what kind of thing that outline is supposed to be.
There are two very different ways to take it. On one reading the outline is an abstraction, a mental filing system, something we draw around a swarm of processes the way people drew the Big Dipper around stars that have no idea they belong together. On the other reading the outline is a real organization that happens to be temporary, like a flame or a whirlpool, things made of nothing but passing stuff that are nonetheless perfectly real, since a flame can still burn your hand. Both readings fit some of Pater’s words, and the choice between them reaches all the way to the end of the essay.
The case for abstraction rests mostly on the grammar of that first sentence. The outline is “but an image of ours,” and it’s something “under which we group them,” which sounds like we’re the ones doing the grouping and the world is only supplying raw material. Even “clear” and “perpetual” can be read with an eyebrow raised, since the outline is clear because we draw it sharply and perpetual because we keep redrawing it. The inward analysis later in the essay seems to push in the same direction, because there each of us ends up “keeping as a solitary prisoner its own dream of a world,” and if the body’s edges are our invention, it’s easy to suspect that every edge is.
The case for a real organization is at least as strong, and it had the science of Pater’s day behind it. Georges Cuvier describes life in the introduction to Le Règne animal as a vortex of varying speed and complexity. Individual molecules enter and leave, while the form of a living body is more essential to it than its particular matter. Cuvier’s image offers a useful scientific parallel to Pater’s account. A pattern in a fabric isn’t imaginary just because its threads run on past it into the rest of the cloth, and Pater’s chosen images, the web, the flame and the whirlpool, are the classic examples of real things that exist only as process.
Where the body ends, then, depends less on choosing a reading than on accepting that real things can have blurry edges. You breathe out air that was part of you a second ago, your lunch is in the middle of becoming you, and the forces at work in your blood are the same ones that rust iron down the street. A traffic jam is a decent comparison, since no single car stays in it for long, its edges shift by the minute, and it’s still real enough to make you late for dinner. The threads run out beyond the outline, and the outline is real anyway, the way a jam is real without any car belonging to it permanently.
So the honest answer to the question is both, with the weight on the second. “An image of ours” and “a design” don’t actually contradict each other, because the design is there in the web, and our recognition picks it out and gives it the crisp edge that the web itself only suggests. The outline is our sharpening of a real but blurry organization, which is why Pater can call it “perpetual” in a sentence about constant change, since the pattern persists while its material passes through. The note on this passage adds that the image returns later, when the self becomes a “weaving and unweaving,” so the same structure that explains the body is about to explain the mind.
That’s exactly where the choice between the readings starts to matter for the essay. If you take the abstraction reading all the way inward, the self at the end of the analysis is just a habit of grouping, and the Conclusion slides toward its bleakest sentence, the one about a “solitary prisoner.” If you take the realist reading, then “that strange, perpetual, weaving and unweaving of ourselves” describes a real weaving, a pattern with enough continuity to be worth cultivating, and that’s what the famous ethic needs. You can’t “burn always” if there’s no you that lasts long enough to keep burning, so success in life, in Pater’s sense, presupposes a self that’s a real pattern rather than a mere label.
The body, on Pater’s account, ends nowhere sharp, and that doesn’t make it a fiction. His grammar hedges with “but an image of ours,” while his images leave room for a real pattern, and I’d read the hedge as a tool for loosening our grip on solidity rather than as a doctrine about what exists. The abstraction reading is useful for a paragraph, to shake you out of thinking of yourself as a statue, but the whole argument of the Conclusion only works if the design in the web is really there, renewed from moment to moment, which makes the outline in the mirror a pattern that the world is genuinely weaving.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
How does the article ultimately reconcile the claim that the bodily outline is “an image of ours” with the claim that it is a real design?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- If a pattern remains while all its material components change, what kind of continuity makes it the same pattern?→
- Does recognizing and sharpening a blurry organization merely describe reality, or does it partly create the thing recognized?→
- Why might the article’s process-based account of the self offer a stronger foundation for Pater’s ethic than either a completely fixed self or a merely invented one?→