Philosophy
Is Quick Thinking Really Better Thinking?
Charmides agrees that the best deliberator finds things out easily and quickly. At Potidaea, Alcibiades tells us, Socrates stood thinking about one problem from dawn to dawn.
The Platonic Dialogues: CharmidesEase, speed and good judgment come together in Socrates’ argument. A debate in Thucydides and a distinction in Aristotle show why it’s worth pulling them apart.
Orientation
At a Glance
- Ease turns into speedSocrates starts by asking whether learning easily is finer than learning with difficulty. Once Charmides equates easy learning with quick learning, the praise carries over to speed.
- Haste can spoil a decisionIn Thucydides, Diodotus tells the Athenians that haste and anger get in the way of good counsel. Aristotle also distinguishes good deliberation from quickness of mind.
- Socrates takes his timeAlcibiades says Socrates stood thinking through the night at Potidaea. The story gives us an example of someone taking a long time because the question deserves it.
- What speed can tell usA quick answer may come from practiced understanding or from impatience. The passage leaves room to praise a calm, unhurried thinker when the question is hard.
Charmides 153a–c, 159e–160b, 175e–176a · Symposium 220c–d · Thucydides 3.36.2–4, 3.42.1, 3.49.1–2 · Aristotle, Nicomachean Ethics 6.9 (1142b) · Hippias Major 304e
The last example in Socrates’ list is the strangest one. After the body and the schoolroom, he turns to the inner life, saying that “in the soul’s inquiries and in deliberation, it is not the quietest person, I imagine, the one who deliberates and finds things out with difficulty, who is thought to deserve praise,” but the person who does it most easily and most quickly. Charmides agrees, as he has throughout the list. This is the example where the praise of speed starts to sound odd. A decision can need time, and Greek writers had some pointed things to say about what happens when it doesn’t get it.
Look at what Greek writers actually said about making decisions. In the debate Thucydides reports over the fate of Mytilene, a city that had revolted from Athens, the speaker Diodotus opens by saying that the two things most opposed to good counsel are haste and anger, and he says it to an assembly that had voted the day before, in a fit of rage, to kill the adult men and enslave the women and children. A ship had already been sent to carry out the decree. Aristotle later repeats the common saying that people should act quickly on what they’ve decided but deliberate slowly, and he insists that good deliberation is a different thing from quickness of mind. By those lights, the person who deliberates “most easily and most quickly” sounds less like a sage than like the guy who hits reply-all before reading the whole email.
Alcibiades tells a story about Socrates at Potidaea in the Symposium, and Potidaea is where Socrates has just come from when the Charmides opens. One morning, Alcibiades says, Socrates got stuck on a problem and stood in one spot thinking about it through the day and the night. Some of the men brought out their bedding to see whether he’d last till dawn. At sunrise he said a prayer to the sun and walked off. It’s a long bout of thinking for the man now telling Charmides that the praiseworthy thinker finds things out easily and fast. The Charmides itself ends with Socrates calling himself “a poor inquirer,” after a long, hard search that leaves him without a settled definition.
So what exactly is the passage praising when it praises the quick deliberator? There are three candidates, and the choice between them matters a lot. It might be praising speed itself, as though a decision reached in five minutes were better than the same decision reached in five days simply because it came sooner. It might be praising practiced understanding, the ease an expert has, like a chess grandmaster who sees the right move at a glance because years of study have made it obvious to him. Or it might be praising successful discovery, getting to the answer at all, since the person Socrates sets against the winner isn’t the careful thinker but the one who finds things out “with difficulty,” the one who struggles to find out.
The wording shows how the slide from one candidate to another happens. Socrates opens his stretch on the mind by asking whether it’s finer to learn easily or with difficulty. He then puts it a second way. “And learning easily,” he says, “is learning quickly, isn’t it, and learning with difficulty is learning quietly and slowly?” That’s the hinge of the whole thing, because ease and difficulty describe the effort involved, while speed describes how long it takes, and once Charmides grants that they’re the same, every advantage of ease gets credited to speed. By the time the argument reaches deliberation, “most easily” and “most quickly” arrive as a pair, and the praise that belongs to the first rubs off on the second.
Once you pull the two apart, you can ask what people are praising when they admire a quick answer. A doctor who finds the right diagnosis deserves credit, whether it takes a minute or a week. If she works it out at a glance, we may be seeing the result of years of practice, as with the grandmaster. Speed can show mastery. It can also show the impatience that sent the first ship to Mytilene and had the assembly scrambling to send a second. To know which sort of speed we’re looking at, we need to know more about the decision.
That changes what the deliberation example does to the definition of temperance as quietness. If what deserves praise is practiced, successful thinking, then a calm, unhurried thinker who gets the answer right is just as praiseworthy as a fast one, and maybe more so when the question is hard. That makes it harder to say this example counts against calmness. Charmides never said that being quiet meant getting stuck. Read carefully, the example that was supposed to wrap up the case against quietness ends up making room for the quiet thinker, and the man standing all night in the camp at Potidaea is exhibit A.
My verdict is that the strongest reading gives the praise to practiced understanding and treats speed as one of its possible signs. Alcibiades’ story gives us a picture of what understanding can cost when the answer won’t come easily. The slide from “easily” to “quickly” is the weakest link in the refutation, and it’s worth catching, because the same slide still fools people every time a fast answer gets mistaken for a smart one. At the end of the Hippias Major, Socrates says he’s learned the meaning of the proverb that fine things are hard. The search for temperance in the Charmides gives him another chance to learn it.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
What is the key weakness the article identifies in Socrates’ argument about deliberation?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- If ease and speed are separated, what qualities should determine whether a person has deliberated well?→
- How does Socrates’ prolonged inquiry at Potidaea affect the credibility or meaning of his argument to Charmides about quick thinking?→
- Under what circumstances, if any, could quickness provide good evidence of mastery rather than impatience?→