Renaissance
Is Music the Example or the Measure of the Other Arts?
Pater calls music the measure of perfected art. His examples suggest what a song, a painting and an everyday gesture might have in common.
The Renaissance (1893)The famous line about music follows a defense of what each art can do in its own materials. Read together, the passages turn a possible ranking of arts into a question about how closely form and subject belong together.
Orientation
At a Glance
- The condition of musicIn a consummate musical moment, Pater argues, the subject and its expression are inseparable.
- A standard across the artsPater asks critics to notice how much a work would lose if its subject were separated from the way it is expressed.
- The earlier case for poetryIn the Winckelmann essay, poetry has a special claim because it can render speech and action directly.
- Each art keeps its materialEven where a painting has the unity Pater hears in music, its effect still belongs to color, line and light.
The Renaissance · The School of Giorgione, p. 90, what art aspires to · The School of Giorgione, note 212 · The School of Giorgione, p. 92, music as the measure · Winckelmann, p. 137, what poetry commands
Pater sets one sentence of this essay in italics, as if he knew people would pull it out and frame it, and they did, because “All art constantly aspires towards the condition of music” is the one line of his that people who’ve never read him can quote. It’s easy to hear it as a ranking, with music on a throne and the other arts leaning toward it, and Pater hands you the words for that reading, calling music “the typical, or ideally consummate art” and later “the true type or measure of perfected art.” So the question is what music is doing in the essay, whether it’s the measure, a yardstick every art gets scored against, or the example, the clearest case of something any art can do in its own materials.
Start with what the “condition” is, because Pater spells it out right away. In the other arts you can always tell the matter from the form, the incidents of a poem from its words, the event in a picture from the way it’s painted, and yet “it is the constant effort of art to obliterate” that difference, so that the handling will “penetrate every part of the matter.” Music is where the effort comes off most completely, since in its best moments “the end is not distinct from the means, the form from the matter, the subject from the expression,” and the two “inhere in and completely saturate each other.” That’s why a painting doesn’t need a lute player in it to approach the condition, since what it’s after is that union, which light and color can manage on their own.
Pater wasn’t alone in thinking about music this way. In his treatise first published in 1854, the Viennese critic Eduard Hanslick argued that tönend bewegte Formen, forms set moving in sound, are the whole content of music, and he compared music to the arabesque, an ornament with no subject beyond the movement of its own line. The comparison illuminates Pater’s ideal, an art whose content cannot simply be restated in other words, and seen that way “condition” sounds less like a throne room and more like a state of affairs, the way you’d speak of the condition of a road or a patient. You can ask of any work what condition it’s in without wanting it to turn into something else.
Still, the reading that sees a hierarchy here has real teeth. Pater makes one of criticism’s chief jobs “to estimate the degree in which each of those products approaches, in this sense, to musical law,” which sounds like a judge with a scorecard, and in the same essay he ranks inside poetry too, calling lyric “the highest and most complete form of poetry.” He’s also moving a crown he’d once placed somewhere else. Hegel treats poetry as a universal art. In the Winckelmann essay, first published in 1867, Pater makes a related claim for poetry’s reach, saying of human speech and action that “over these poetry has command,” while ten years later he writes, pointedly, “In music, then, rather than in poetry.” Read side by side, those passages make it easy to hear Pater moving the crown.
Painters also found different ways to take music as a model. In 1872 Whistler thanked Frederick Leyland for suggesting the word nocturne for his pictures. A generation after Pater, Wassily Kandinsky compared the artist playing on the soul through color to a hand playing the keys of a piano. Read like that, aspiring to music means acting like music, which pushes painting toward abstraction and makes every picture a second-rate symphony. It’s worth noticing that Pater’s own examples point nowhere near abstraction, since the next things he discusses are an etched country road, a song in a Shakespeare play and the manners of people at dinner.
The essay’s own hedges point in that same direction. The arts “may be supposed constantly to tend and aspire,” and they “may be represented as continually struggling after the law or principle of music,” which is the language of a useful way of describing things rather than a decree. The condition also belongs to music’s “perfect moments,” so a dull hymn or a jingle for a car commercial doesn’t meet it, and a great Titian might meet it better than either, while every art keeps “its incommunicable element,” so the aspiration is toward a state and never toward turning into another art. That makes the measure a question you can carry into any room, which is how far the handling has soaked into the matter, so that you couldn’t restate the thing in other terms without losing it.
The other side still has a point worth taking seriously. A yardstick named after one art tilts the field, because music wins almost by default, having so little detachable subject to begin with, and a measure built on it rewards whatever thins out or hides its subject, as the essay’s praise of the “vagueness of mere subject” in lyric suggests. Music isn’t always pure either, since songs have words and Berlioz wrote a symphony with a printed story attached, so even Pater’s model can come apart into matter and form. Those objections land, and they explain why Pater is careful to tie the condition to music’s “consummate moments” rather than to music as a whole.
So I’d say Pater does set up a hierarchy, but it ranks moments rather than arts, and music names the summit without owning it. The useful thing he leaves critics is the question, and the question works as a measure the way a ruler does, a standard you can hold against a song, a canvas or a road without caring which one it is. Music is the example that made the measure visible, the place where Pater could point and say that the union he’s describing actually happens, and once you’ve seen it there you can look for it anywhere, which is exactly what he does for the rest of the essay.
Test your understanding
Question 1 of 3
What does the article identify as the central feature of music’s “condition” toward which other arts aspire?
Guided Inquiry
Questions for Socrates
Explore these questions with Socrates, with this Feature as your reading context.
- If every art retains an “incommunicable element,” in what sense can music still serve as a common measure without unfairly privileging its own qualities?→
- Does judging art by how completely form and matter unite help critics recognize excellence, or does it undervalue works whose subjects can be clearly restated? Why?→
- How does the distinction between ranking artistic moments and ranking entire art forms change your interpretation of the claim that all art aspires toward music?→